Trump cites national security as Supreme Court weighs challenge to ballroom
asserted
Court → cite → ballroom
-
Click here to listen to this article -
- Chief Justice John G. Roberts issued an order giving the court more time to decide a legal challenge to the ballroom.
-
asserted
Roberts → click → ballroom
The Trump administration argued that a judge’s order blocking further construction threatened the safety of the president and must be overturned.
asserted
order → argue → president
The Supreme Court is weighing President Trump’s claim that his new White House ballroom is urgently needed to protect him, his staff and guests from attacks by drones, terrorists and snipers.
uncertain
ballroom → weigh → drones
On Friday, with a lower-court order about to go into effect halting construction on the controversial project, Chief Justice John G. Roberts decided that the court needed more time.
asserted
court → go → time
He issued a temporary order pausing the case and allowing construction to continue while the justices decide on a pending legal challenge.
asserted
justices → issue → challenge
Last week, Trump’s lawyers described the East Wing ballroom as an “integrated military complex” that is “vitally required by national security.”
asserted
that → describe → security
They argued that a judge’s order blocking further construction threatened the safety of the president and must be overturned.
asserted
order → argue → president
They also said the project is nearly two-thirds completed.
asserted
project → say → ?
At issue is whether the president acting on his own may build a huge new ballroom complex that is expected to dwarf the historic Executive Mansion.
uncertain
that → act → Mansion
It is a confrontation over the boundaries of executive power at a moment when Trump has repeatedly tested the ability of courts, Congress and independent institutions to constrain his agenda.
asserted
Trump → test → agenda
Trump bulldozed the historic East Wing before the courts had resolved whether the administration had the authority to proceed, leaving opponents to argue the project could become effectively irreversible before judicial review was complete.
uncertain
review → bulldoze → opponents
The National Trust for Historic Preservation sued in December and argued that the president had overstepped his authority.
asserted
president → sue → authority
U.S. District Judge Richard Leon agreed and ordered a stop to the above-ground construction — that is, on the ballroom.
asserted
that → agree → ballroom
He said the work on the underground bunker may proceed.
uncertain
work → say → bunker
The U.S. court of appeals affirmed his order by a 2-1 vote on Aug. 7 but put the decision on hold until Friday.
asserted
court → affirm → Friday
Roberts’ order did not explain the reason for the delay, or how soon the court might rule.
uncertain
court → explain → delay
In a fast-track appeal to the Supreme Court, Trump administration lawyers sought to refocus the case as one about national security and the president’s safety.
asserted
lawyers → seek → security
“Given the current unprecedented levels of danger ... every day the President does not have access to the vital security features of the military complex presents unacceptable risk,” Solicitor Gen. D. John Sauer said Wednesday in his final brief to the court.
asserted
Sauer → give → court
The Constitution and federal law say new buildings may not be erected on public property in the District of Columbia “without the express authority of Congress.”
uncertain
buildings → say → Congress
But acting on his own, Trump ordered the East Wing of the White House torn down in October and work began on a new and much larger building to replace it.
asserted
work → act → it
He said the new ballroom could provide safe and secure seating for 1,000 dinner guests.
uncertain
ballroom → say → guests
He did not ask Congress to weigh in or approve the massive project.
asserted
He → ask → project
In defense, Trump administration lawyers pointed to an annual appropriation from Congress that funds “the care, maintenance, repair, alteration, refurnishing” and other such improvements at the White House.
asserted
that → point → House
They also said private donations would pay most of the $400-million cost of the new ballroom.
asserted
donations → say → ballroom
One estimate placed the cost of the ballroom and the bunker at $600 million, with taxpayers covering half, the Washington Post reported.
asserted
Post → place → half
The president, his family and White House employees would have secure underground space, Sauer said, while a “totally secure ballroom space” would provide a new level of protection for guests and foreign dignitaries.
asserted
space → have → guests
Otherwise, they would be seated outside in tents on the lawn, Trump said, which was neither appealing nor safe.
asserted
which → seat → lawn
His solicitor general also argued it was too late to stop the project.
asserted
it → argue → project
“A 250-person crew is working 20 hours a day, seven days a week to keep the project ahead of schedule and under budget,” he wrote on Aug. 13.
asserted
he → work → Aug.
“Today, the project is 65% complete in its entirety, and moving quickly toward total completion.”
asserted
project → move → completion
Trump’s signature construction project has fueled accusations from his political opponents that he is abusing his power to build a lavish space for entertaining guests as ordinary Americans struggle with affordability.
asserted
Americans → fuel → affordability
In April, Republicans in Congress sought to put federal money behind the project, despite Trump’s earlier insistence that private donors would pay for the ballroom.
asserted
donors → seek → ballroom
The effort never became law, faced with bipartisan opposition to a bill that would tie them to the unpopular project, leaving the administration to proceed with a privately financed effort whose legal authority was already being challenged in court.
asserted
authority → become → court
The Society for the Rule of Law and a group of former White House lawyers warned the court against accepting Trump’s broad claims of power.
uncertain
Society → warn → power
“Under the executive’s view, the President could bulldoze the entire White House and replace it with a new building of his own design, including a skyscraper.
uncertain
President → bulldoze → skyscraper
No other President has asserted such transformative power,” they wrote in a friend-of-the-court brief.
asserted
they → assert → brief
“The invocation of national security is not a magic incantation that suspends the rule of law,” they added.
asserted
they → suspend → law
The National Trust for Historic Preservation sued to block the ballroom, arguing that the president lacks authority to erect new buildings on government property.
asserted
president → sue → property
The biggest hurdle facing the challengers may be the issue of standing.
uncertain
hurdle → face → standing
…and 6 more, not listed.
The Aporia
