Supreme Court, in 5-4 vote, clears way for Trump’s new ballroom
-
asserted
Court → clear → ballroom
Click here to listen to this article -
- Supreme Court, 5-4, clears way for Trump to finish a privately funded $400-million White House ballroom, overturning lower-court rulings that said he needed congressional approval.
asserted
he → click → approval
- Conservative majority tossed the National Trust for Historic Preservation’s lawsuit on standing grounds, saying preservationists weren’t personally harmed.
- In a dissent, Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr. said the construction project was ‘likely unlawful’ and should not be allowed to continue.
asserted
project → toss → dissent
A divided Supreme Court has cleared the way for President Trump to finish building his new White House ballroom with mostly private money and without approval from Congress.
asserted
Trump → clear → Congress
By a 5-4 vote, the justices granted an emergency appeal from Trump and his lawyers on Monday, setting aside a judge’s order that would stop the construction.
asserted
that → grant → construction
But Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr. dissented, along with the court’s three liberals.
asserted
Jr. → dissent → liberals
Roberts said the construction project was “likely unlawful” and should not be allowed to continue.
“The White House is not just any building ... when it comes to historic preservation,” Roberts wrote.
asserted
Roberts → say → preservation
“Winston Churchill once remarked that ‘[w]e shape our buildings, and afterwards our buildings shape us.’
asserted
buildings → remark → us
All the more reason to ensure that those responsible follow the rules in deciding what to tear down and what to build up at the People’s House.”
asserted
those → ensure → House
The outcome turned on the standing of the plaintiffs, the National Trust for Historic Preservation and its members.
asserted
outcome → turn → Preservation
The conservative majority pointed to Alison Hoagland, one of its members, who said she lives in Washington, walks by the White House about once a month and said she found the “scale,” “height” and “massing” of the huge ballroom to be distasteful.
asserted
scale → point → ballroom
“This court has not found standing in circumstances like these before.
asserted
court → find → these
To the contrary, we have repeatedly held that mere offense, disagreement, or distaste does not qualify as a concrete and particularized injury,” the unsigned order said.
asserted
order → hold → injury
Trump has responded to growing legal and political obstacles to his ballroom, arch and other projects by attempting to force approvals through faster than opponents can challenge them.
asserted
opponents → respond → them
It is a major victory for Trump, whose ballroom project has become a signature effort of his second term and a political lightning rod in Washington, where Republicans have refused to fund it with public money.
asserted
Republicans → become → money
Trump celebrated the victory with a post on social media, declaring the venue would now be built “without any further contingency, doubt, or threat.”
“We are living in the Golden Age of America, and this Building will be one of the Greatest ever constructed in Washington, D.C.,” Trump wrote.
asserted
Trump → celebrate → Washington
“When completed in the Summer of 2028, the magnificent Ballroom and Military Complex will be something that the entire Country is very proud of.”
The massive new structure, set to dwarf the historic White House mansion, is the president’s singular vision — one of a string of aesthetic projects Trump has pursued in a feverish effort to cement his legacy by putting his personal stamp on the nation’s capital.
asserted
Trump → complete → capital
But preservationists and architects have criticized the proposed ballroom as a garish, rushed project that ignored the input of experts.
asserted
that → criticize → experts
The president has personally overruled his own chosen architects after being told the building would overwhelm the executive complex.
asserted
building → overrule → complex
Democrats have seized on the president’s fixation on the ballroom as a symbol of vanity and detachment from the concerns of everyday Americans heading into November’s midterm elections.
asserted
Democrats → seize → elections
According to recent polls, a bipartisan majority of voters disapprove of the president’s handling of the economy and say the country is facing an affordability crisis.
uncertain
country → accord → crisis
The ballroom is projected to cost more than $400 million, excluding the undisclosed cost of underground security upgrades.
asserted
ballroom → project → upgrades
Trump’s three appointees — Justices Neil M. Gorsuch, Brett M. Kavanaugh and Amy Coney Barrett — joined conservative Justices Clarence Thomas and Samuel A. Alito in an unsigned opinion ruling for the president.
asserted
appointees → join → president
The conservative majority also said Trump and his appointees had stressed the new ballroom was needed for national security and said the lower courts judges should not have interfered.
asserted
judges → say → security
California officials stressed that the court’s ruling does not allow final implementation of the new rules requested by Trump.
asserted
ruling → stress → Trump
Administration officials have argued that an underground “integrated military complex” was the heart of the project and that the ballroom would merely be sit top of the facility “vitally required by national security.”
asserted
ballroom → argue → security
The decision is not a final ruling, but it gives a green light to Trump’s go-it-alone approach, which is in keeping with his history as a hotel builder.
asserted
which → give → builder
He believed the White House needed a grand ballroom that could seat hundreds of dignitaries.
uncertain
that → believe → dignitaries
Acting on his own, he ordered the East Wing torn down in October to make room of his larger ballroom.
asserted
Wing → act → ballroom
He also said most of the project would be paid for by private donations.
asserted
most → say → donations
But the Constitution gave Congress the power to manage property belonging to the United States.
asserted
Constitution → give → States
A 1912 law says new buildings “shall not erected ... on public grounds within the District of Columbia without express authority of Congress.”
asserted
buildings → say → Congress
Trump chose to ignore the law and did not seek approval from Congress, which is led by Republicans.
asserted
which → choose → Republicans
The Republican president’s lawyers had asked the justices to reconsider their refusal to hear his appeal.
asserted
lawyers → ask → appeal
The court denied Trump’s petition along with several others.
asserted
court → deny → others
The National Trust for Historic Preservation sued in December, contending Trump was a “temporary tenant, not the owner” of the White House.
asserted
Trump → sue → House
U.S. District Judge Richard Leon ruled Trump had no authority to build a ballroom on the White House grounds without the approval of Congress, and he ordered a halt to the above-ground construction.
asserted
he → rule → construction
The District of Columbia Circuit Court affirmed his decision by a 2-1 vote.
asserted
Court → affirm → vote
“Congress has not ceded unfettered authority to the Executive Branch to dramatically redesign, reshape, and reconstruct the White House — the People’s House — to fit a particular President’s desires,” wrote Judge Patricia Millett for the appeals court.
asserted
Millett → cede → court
Trump’s lawyers sent a fast-track appeal to the Supreme Court on Aug. 14.
asserted
lawyers → send → Aug.
…and 1 more, not listed.
The Aporia
