Behind the glamor of red carpets, military bands, and a state dinner for Chinese President Xi Jinping, the tension between press freedoms in the two nations — and the underlying battle of President Donald Trump’s own war on the media — punctuated Thursday’s White House state visit.
asserted
tension → underlie → visit
Xi’s 10 a.m. White House arrival on Thursday preceded joint remarks delivered by the two leaders, a full military review complemented by numerous bands and a White House flyover, hours of closed-door bilateral meetings, Trump leading Xi on a personal tour of Marine One and the newly christened White House helipad, and a lavish state dinner in the evening where attendees were treated to sesame-crusted sea bass.
asserted
attendees → precede → bass
The night before, Trump welcomed Xi to Joint Base Andrews in Maryland with a literal, 100-foot-long red carpet, dozens of waving American and Chinese flags, and hundreds of military personnel.
asserted
Trump → welcome → personnel
The White House remarks between the two leaders, an otherwise momentous occasion for the superpowers, were not carried live by any of the major television networks as Trump’s media ban of three outlets played out into Thursday morning.
asserted
ban → carry → morning
Moreover, the usually chatty Trump did not answer questions as he showed Xi around the White House grounds.
asserted
he → answer → grounds
On state visits, it’s typical for a president to adopt the press norms of a visiting dignitary.
asserted
president → ’ → dignitary
And, true to form, Trump and his counterpart declined to answer any questions asked by American reporters, despite multiple opportunities.
asserted
Trump → decline → opportunities
Furthermore, two separate narratives collided on campus Thursday, further underlining the vast differences in press freedoms between the respective countries.
asserted
narratives → collide → countries
First, ahead of Xi’s arrival Thursday morning, Chinese reporters and their diplomatic aides scuffled with U.S. Secret Service and White House staffers over what Beijing’s delegation deemed to be unfavorable positioning of their cameras.
asserted
delegation → scuffle → cameras
The verbal altercation bordered on physical violence, as a Chinese official shoved off the hands of a White House aide seeking to move him into the appropriate position and started shouting at Secret Service agents, just feet away from the Washington Examiner.
asserted
official → border → Examiner
A Chinese photographer also sprinted across the newly paved South Lawn driveway in hopes of finding a better staging location before being corralled by the Trump administration.
asserted
photographer → sprint → administration
The White House’s in-house photographer eventually calmed the peace by pointing out that even she wasn’t positioned in front of the attending journalists.
asserted
she → calm → journalists
“This day will be very long,” the Washington Examiner heard the White House photographer tell the Chinese delegation.
asserted
photographer → hear → delegation
“We can do this.
asserted
We → do → this
No more fighting.”
This isn’t the first time Chinese officials have jostled American journalists and government officials, nor was it the last time it happened on Thursday.
asserted
it → jostle → Thursday
Similar incidents occurred during Trump’s previous meetings with Xi, and, again on Thursday, one Chinese photographer bowled over an American female reporter in the White House briefing room while the press pools waited to be let into the Oval Office for a bilateral spray with Trump and Xi.
asserted
pools → occur → Trump
Print, television, and radio reporters were excluded from the event, but after getting their pictures snapped, Trump joked to Xi that the Chinese reporters were much nicer than their American counterparts.
asserted
reporters → exclude → counterparts
Second, later in the afternoon, Trump’s own fractious relationship with the press took center stage after the White House consented to a judge’s overnight ruling and allowed CNN, MS Now, and Politico reporters back onto campus.
asserted
House → take → campus
Though Trump’s media ban, handed down last week, was overturned hours before Xi’s arrival, journalists from those outlets weren’t allowed back onto the grounds until around 1 p.m.
The White House attributed the delay to the need to revert credentialing in the Secret Service database and to redistributing previously confiscated physical credentials back to the respective outlets.
asserted
House → hand → outlets
Still, despite the chaos in the press corps, Trump appeared to be flying high throughout the day.
asserted
Trump → appear → day
The president briefly interacted with the press while touring Xi around the South Lawn helipad and construction of the White House ballroom.
asserted
president → interact → ballroom
Trump did not answer questions from the Washington Examiner and other reporters on future weapons transfers to Taiwan, China’s role in the fentanyl epidemic, imprisoned Hong Kong businessman Jimmy Lai, the origins of the COVID-19 pandemic, or any other topics.
asserted
Trump → answer → pandemic
Instead, he told the press that he and Xi were having a “great meeting” and touted his counterpart’s supposed geological interests.
asserted
he → tell → interests
“He’s an expert on stone, aside from many other things,” Trump said with a smile.
asserted
Trump → ’ → smile
“And he loves good granite.”
asserted
he → love → granite
The Aporia
