President Donald Trump faces legal uncertainty over whether his administration can put new federal mail-ballot rules in place ahead of the 2028 presidential election, legal experts told Fox News Digital.
asserted
experts → face → Digital
The president issued an executive order in March directing the Postal Service to pursue new rules for federal mail ballots, including standardized ballot envelopes with an Official Election Mail designation and unique machine-readable barcodes.
asserted
president → issue → designation
Per the order, the Postal Service would be empowered to turn away ballots that failed to meet its new standards, or those belonging to individuals who don’t appear on state-submitted lists of eligible mail voters.
asserted
who → empower → voters
On Sept. 14, the Supreme Court declined to lift a preliminary injunction blocking the rules from being implemented ahead of November’s midterm elections.
asserted
Court → decline → elections
Now, whether or not his changes can be implemented before the 2028 election looms large over Washington.
asserted
implemented → implement → Washington
Experts who spoke to Fox News Digital argued that the ruling will hinge on how the Supreme Court parses competing claims to authority between the executive branch’s ability to regulate mail and the right of states to administer elections however they see fit.
uncertain
they → speak → elections
"If the Court views this primarily as an attempt by the President to regulate federal elections, the Court is likely to invalidate it," Florida State University law professor Michael Morley told Fox News Digital.
asserted
Morley → view → Digital
"The President has no constitutional authority over federal elections and Congress has not delegated him broad statutory authority over the field.
asserted
Congress → have → field
If the Supreme Court views the case through another lens, however, Morley says that could change things.
uncertain
that → view → things
"In contrast, the Court may instead view the new rules primarily as administrative requirements for the post office to ensure efficient operations and protect the integrity of the [mail]," he said.
uncertain
he → view → ]
"Viewed from this perspective, the rule would be viewed as a much more prosaic matter and likely be upheld.
asserted
rule → view → matter
It would be remarkable for the Court to conclude the Postal Service lacks authority to regulate the process through which millions of parcels of important (i.e., election-related) mail are submitted for delivery.
asserted
millions → conclude → delivery
"
The Supreme Court ruled by a margin of 7-2 to uphold the injunction preventing Trump’s executive order from being implemented ahead of the midterms.
asserted
Court → rule → midterms
Justices Clarence Thomas and Samuel Alito dissented, while Justice Brett Kavanaugh voted to uphold the injunction, noting that, though the Post Office may have the authority to implement such a regulation, forcing its new rule to be implemented so close to an election likely runs afoul of federal law.
uncertain
forcing → dissent → law
Some have attempted to use the ruling to predict how the court will ultimately rule on the merits of the Post Office’s ability to regulate election-related mail.
asserted
court → attempt → mail
"At least six justices seem to think that the administration will lose on the merits," Stephen Richer, a legal fellow at the libertarian Cato Institute, told Fox News Digital.
asserted
Richer → seem → Digital
"The Constitution doesn't vest authority to regulate elections to the president and I think that they would say that this effectively dictates how elections can be run."
asserted
elections → vest → president
"The Constitution delegates brought authority to the Congress and to the states to administer elections.
asserted
delegates → bring → elections
And having this requirement sure seems like an additional requirement for administering mail voting elections," Richer, who was formerly a Republican election official in Arizona, continued.
asserted
who → have → Arizona
Others, however, see the court’s ruling as primarily a procedural consideration rather than a proper rebuke of the administration’s efforts to regulate mail voting.
asserted
Others → see → voting
"Justice Kavanaugh, whose vote decided this outcome, was explicit that he believes the Postal Service likely has the statutory authority to require verified voter lists and tamper-resistant envelopes for federal ballot mail," America First Policy Institute senior legal fellow Chad Mizelle told Fox News Digital.
asserted
Mizelle → decide → Digital
"He concluded there simply wasn't enough time left before the midterms to implement the rule responsibly.
asserted
He → conclude → rule
That's a timing question, not a ruling on the underlying law," Mizelle, who recently served as the chief of staff at the Justice Department, added.
asserted
who → underlie → Department
The kind of chain-of-custody standards most people would assume already exist for something as important as a ballot.
asserted
people → assume → ballot
Regardless of what the Supreme Court’s decision ultimately means for the rule’s future, the president has characterized the injunction blocking its implementation in the 2026 elections as a major defeat.
asserted
president → mean → defeat
"Republicans just got another bad decision from the United States Supreme Court, one that the Court System took forever to give, and then blamed it, in part, on no time left to implement a solution to our totally CORRUPT and out of control Mail-In voting ‘disaster,’" the president wrote on Truth Social shortly after the court handed down its decision.
asserted
court → get → decision
"It is a big loss for Republicans, and America itself, and makes cheating by the Radical Left ‘Dumocrats,’ on Mail-In Ballots, a much easier thing to d.
asserted
cheating → make → Ballots
"
There have been individual cases of election and mail-ballot fraud, but they do not show that widespread fraud is occurring across U.S. mail voting.
asserted
fraud → show → voting
If the president is right about the impact of his mail voting rule, however, that leaves a big question mark on the board as Election Day approaches.
asserted
Day → leave → board
It's not a slam dunk," Ilya Shapiro, a former law professor and current senior fellow at the right-leaning Manhattan Institute, told Fox News Digital.
asserted
Shapiro → lean → Digital
It's about who gets to set the rule for it, whether it's the state, Congress, or federal agency acting under general postal statutes that are quite broad."
asserted
that → get → statutes
The White House did not respond to a request for comment when reached by Fox News Digital on Friday.
asserted
House → respond → Friday