This weekend, the Wall Street Journal reported that Prime Minister Mark Carney is pushing for associate membership with the European Union in an effort to diversify Canada away from the United States.
asserted
Carney → report → States
Though, on Sunday evening Carney downplayed the story, and said he is seeking a “unique alliance” with the EU.
asserted
he → downplay → EU
It’s a convenient dodge in any case as both terms are undefined in any legal sense and Canadians deserve to know what the Prime Minister is actually up to.
asserted
Minister → ’ → what
While there are solid economic and security reasons to pursue greater integration with Europe, it is far from clear that these are the only forces driving the government.
asserted
these → be → government
One senior Canadian official was quoted by the Journal as saying “Canadians, we sound like Americans, we dress like Americans, but as a society we’re much more European.”
asserted
we → quote → society
Recommended Videos
That is reflective of an elite and out of touch attitude which may sound good in urban Toronto, Montreal and Vancouver, but which does not reflect the reality of most Canadians and could end up seriously harming them.
uncertain
which → sound → them
Elements under discussion between Canada and the EU reportedly include “ways to let Canada’s goods, services and workers involved in strategic supply chains such as energy, AI, defense and critical minerals move freely” and “laying underwater cables, jointly constructing data centers, cloud storage and new satellite networks and infrastructure to ship Canadian energy to the EU.”
uncertain
goods → include → EU
We have seen this play out in Europe before, notably in the United Kingdom.
asserted
this → see → Kingdom
The simple reality is that more people in Europe (and the world) speak English as a second language than vice-versa.
asserted
people → speak → versa
That affects the direction of travel of the workers.
asserted
That → affect → workers
On pure linguistic grounds alone, it is nearly certain that Canada, as a primarily English-speaking nation, would be opening its workers up to far more competition from English speaking Europeans, than, say, Greek or German workers would face from Greek or German speaking Canadians.
asserted
workers → speak → Canadians
Any politician who avoids the difficulty of that question alone is in for a massive shock when push comes to shove.
asserted
push → avoid → shove
A “free flow” of people and workers goes both ways and isn’t an unalloyed good for Canadians.
asserted
flow → go → Canadians
However, the idea of Canada acting as a close and trusted European partner to host data centres and export energy to Europe is a fantastic one.
asserted
Canada → act → Europe
How much oil and gas does Europe want from Canada?
asserted
Europe → want → Canada
Whatever the answer, start building the pipelines to supply it tomorrow and then build five more.
asserted
answer → start → five
This is as much of an economic no-brainer as any country is likely to find.
asserted
country → find → brainer
Europe needs reliable gas that doesn’t come from Russia and Canada has enormous gas reserves.
asserted
Canada → need → reserves
A more ideal partnership is hard to imagine, excepting of course the niggling problem that we can’t get the gas to our east coast in large quantities because the pipelines aren’t there.
asserted
pipelines → imagine → quantities
Also of importance, and hidden behind the Wall Street Journal’s reporting, are the serious problems related related to any EU deal in general.
asserted
problems → hide → deal
Notably, given our recent blow up with the United States over our trading relationship, is the issue of sovereignty.
asserted
issue → give → sovereignty
Much about what exactly went wrong in that negotiation remains unclear, but Canadians were told by both the prime minister and chief trade negotiator Janice Charette that the United States sought provisions which would be “constraining or limiting (to) Canada’s ability to enter into future free trade agreements.”
uncertain
which → go → agreements
That threat to our sovereignty was unacceptable so Canada walked away.
asserted
Canada → walk → sovereignty
If true, we were right do so.
asserted
we → do → ?
However, the notion that an EU association, or “unique alliance,” would not come with similar or analogous restrictions on Canada’s sovereignty is pure fantasy.
asserted
association → come → sovereignty
The European Union negotiates trade deals on behalf of the bloc of member countries.
asserted
Union → negotiate → countries
Individual countries are not permitted to unilaterally enter into trade deals on their own.
asserted
countries → permit → own
That is to say, they sacrifice a piece of their sovereignty for the large negotiating power which comes from the 27 member countries acting together.
asserted
which → say → countries
Further, the EU does not even allow Norway, not an EU member but a member of the European Economic Area (a type of EU association), to negotiate trade deals that allow backdoor entry to the EU.
asserted
that → allow → EU
That is to say, Norway’s sovereignty is limited beyond what would be expected in a typical trade agreement, despite not being an EU member, just as Canada’s could be, depending on exactly what is being pursued.
uncertain
what → say → agreement
To believe that this country will somehow be given a free ride and can keep doing just as we please if we enter the close cooperation apparently being discussed, is to conveniently ignore the harsher realities of European integration.
asserted
we → believe → integration
Further worrying is the lens Canada seems to be putting on European association, with a senior official telling the Wall Street Journal that “as a society we’re much more European.”
asserted
we → seem → society
It is hard to imagine a more out of touch comment being made by any negotiator.
asserted
comment → imagine → negotiator
I have no doubt that many highly educated members of Canada’s elite wish to think of themselves as Europeans, perhaps they even live as though they are.
asserted
they → have → Europeans
The vast majority of Canadians, however, do not.
asserted
majority → do → Canadians
In our current situation it may not be comfortable to recognize that we share far more with Americans than any other country, but that is our reality.
uncertain
that → recognize → country
I say this as someone who lived and studied in Europe for years and speaks French, Spanish and German.
asserted
who → say → French
Indeed, there’s every reason to think close EU association might be very beneficial to me personally.
uncertain
association → ’ → me
So, can believing the unnamed senior official be superficially appealing?
asserted
believing → believe → official
Minster Carney can position Canada as the European energy and critical mineral supplier of choice
asserted
Carney → position → choice
…and 2 more, not listed.
The Aporia
