Liberalism needs a new philosophy of immigration

Noahpinion · collected 2026-09-09 · by Noah Smith commentary
Read the original at Noahpinion ↗

Summary

The article argues that liberalism needs a new philosophy of immigration, citing the recent landslide election victory of Germany's far-right party, AfD, in the eastern state of Saxony-Anhalt. According to experts, including Adam Tooze and Robin Brooks, immigration is the key issue driving AfD popularity, with voters prioritizing security and anti-foreigner sentiment over economic concerns. Data from a 2024 study suggests that immigration is a main reason for the surge in right-wing parties across Europe. The article implies that the liberal-left's inability to effectively address immigration has allowed far-right parties to capitalize on voter discontent.
Written by the local model on 2026-09-09, using this article's own text rather than the other coverage of the same event (that is the story summary below).

Signals How these are calculated →

Claims extracted
121
claim-shaped sentences
Uncertain
2%
3 of 121 hedged
Leaning
Leans strongly right
expected in commentary, which argues a position
Publisher trust
not scored
Commentary is not rated for newsroom trust
Outlets on this story
61
Politics
Narrative spread
1
articles carrying this framing
Analyzed 2026-09-09 · how these are computed

AI analysis (generated at analysis time, not now)

Story summary

A far-right party called the Alternative for Germany (AfD) is poised to gain power in a state election in Saxony-Anhalt, which would be the first time a far-right party has held state-level power in Germany since World War II. The AfD's candidate, Ulrich Siegmund, has been campaigning on a platform that includes restricting immigration, quitting the Euro, and restoring ties with Russia. According to exit polls, the AfD is leading with around 44% of the vote, more than double its showing five years ago in the region.

This election could have significant implications for German politics and potentially signal a shift towards a harder-right path for the EU's biggest economy. The AfD has been gaining popularity in recent years, buoyed by popular disillusion with successive governments in Berlin and drawing support from formerly communist states in the east. A win for the AfD would also mean that they could overcome the "firewall" of mainstream parties' refusal to work with them.

The election is seen as a potentially historic shift in German politics, and the outcome will be closely watched by observers around the world. If the AfD does gain power, it would likely lead to significant changes in areas such as education, immigration policy, and foreign relations.

Written for “Germany's AfD Rise to Power” on 2026-09-12, grounded in this article and the 60 other(s) covering the same event.
Why this leaning score
The article's own words the score was based on. Each is quoted verbatim and was checked against the article text before being stored, so you can find it in the original.
Score +0.85 Confidence high
Leaning score +0.85 for article 7187 (high confidence, 3 verified quotes) · logged 2026-09-11

Story

📰 Germany's AfD Rise to Power
Politics · 61 article(s) covering the same event.

How this is being covered How these are calculated →

Article leaning vs. publisher reliability
Source leaning vs. consistency

Compared with similar articles

This article reads leans strongly right and hedges 2% of its claims. Each row says how that neighbour differs.
Semafor
⚖️ Leans right further left than this 🔴 20% hedged 1 of 5 📰 publisher trust 96
“Both articles report on the AfD's landslide election victory in Saxony-Anhalt, with Article A predicting this outcome and Article B describing it as having happened.”
BBC News
⚖️ Leans left further left than this 🔴 16% hedged 7 of 44 📰 publisher trust 96
“Both articles report on the AfD's landslide election victory in Saxony-Anhalt on the same date”
Al Jazeera
⚖️ Centre further left than this 🔴 0% hedged 0 of 2 📰 publisher trust 96
“Both articles report on the AfD's election victory in Saxony-Anhalt, with identical locations and outcomes.”
CBS News
⚖️ Leans right further left than this 🔴 13% hedged 8 of 63 📰 publisher trust 60
“Both articles mention the same election in Saxony-Anhalt where AfD won, with similar details about the party's victory and its implications.”
Times of India
⚖️ Leans right further left than this 🔴 35% hedged 9 of 26 📰 publisher trust 94
“Both articles report on the same state election in Saxony-Anhalt, Germany, where AfD won a landslide victory.”
Fox News
⚖️ Leans right further left than this 🔴 13% hedged 7 of 52 📰 publisher trust 95
“Both articles describe the AfD's landslide election victory in Saxony-Anhalt, on Sunday (presumably September 5, 2026, based on Article A) and mention it as a significant event in Germany's political landscape.”
The Guardian
⚖️ Leans right further left than this 🔴 12% hedged 4 of 34 📰 publisher trust 94
“Both articles report on the AfD winning a state election in Saxony-Anhalt, with Article A mentioning polls opening and exit polls expected, while Article B reports on the outcome of that election as a 'huge landslide victory'.”
CBC News
⚖️ Leans right further left than this 🔴 14% hedged 5 of 35 📰 publisher trust 95
“Both articles describe the AfD's landslide election victory in Saxony-Anhalt, with no mention of any other events or elections.”
The Straits Times
⚖️ leaning not scored 🔴 25% hedged 5 of 20 📰 publisher trust 94
“Both articles report on the same regional election in Saxony-Anhalt, Germany, with similar details and outcomes, such as the AfD's landslide victory and their potential to miss an absolute majority.”
National Post
⚖️ Leans left further left than this 🔴 7% hedged 2 of 28 📰 publisher trust 96
“Both articles mention the AfD's landslide election victory in Saxony-Anhalt state, with identical location and context.”

Publisher

Noahpinion · 23 article(s) · 0 correction(s) detected
No corrections detected for this publisher. That may mean careful reporting, or simply that nothing has been checked.

Who wrote this

Noah Smith
21 article(s) here · 1 carrying a prediction
🔮 While Mamdani’s low rating might be partially due to his leftist policies and his association with the DSA, it struck me that all three of these unpopular figures had one thing in common — they are associated with the intrusion of Middle Eastern politics into American politics.
2026-09-12 · assertive framing · Get the Middle East out of my politics!
🔮 Second, it means that something is making many German voters so angry that they’re finally willing to overlook all of the AfD’s catastrophic flaws — its obvious ties to Vladimir Putin, the fact that the party is filled with crooks, its extreme rhetoric, its lack of governing experience, and so on.
2026-09-09 · assertive framing · Liberalism needs a new philosophy of immigration
🔮 People who think of AI as a job-killer might not have thought of the second and third of these.
2026-09-07 · assertive framing · AI keeps stubbornly refusing to take our jobs
🔮 Cyberwarfare so far hasn’t been decisive in military conflicts, but AI’s incredible cybersecurity prowess could change that.
2026-09-05 · mixed framing · America is still beating China in the AI race
🔮 You’d think a lot of these would be foreign, but international investors mostly avoided the boom (except for a few who bet big on Korean memory stocks).
2026-09-05 · assertive framing · Why did South Korean stocks just crash?
🔮 Would you like to see an example of a badly conceived policy?
2026-09-05 · assertive framing · Slopulism is taking over America
🔮 I remember using a hand calculator and seeing if my uncle could get it right without a tool faster than I could; more often than not, he could.
2026-09-05 · assertive framing · The end of the age of heroes
🔮 Some people thought Donald Trump’s approval rating would have a floor around 40%.
2026-09-04 · assertive framing · Are the Democrats going to save us this time?
🔮 It’s pretty amazing that a pause on data center construction has become such a consensus, middle-of-the-road issue stance that it’s the thing Hong’s supporters would rather talk about!
2026-09-04 · assertive framing · Banning data centers would blow up the U.S. economy
🔮 But I suppose there’s one reason it might be interesting, which is that over the past decade or so, a fairly large portion of the left-leaning intellectual class in America has become fairly-to-very resentful of the American tech industry, and has spent an enormous amount of intellectual effort on criticizing that industry.
2026-09-04 · assertive framing · The poverty of anti-tech thought
Also by Noah Smith
Nothing else under this byline is closely related to this article, so these are simply their most recent.
All 21 articles by Noah Smith →

Topics

AfD AfD. Germany Saxony-Anhalt U.S.

Subjects

AfD ORG · 12× Germany GPE · 5× Western European NORP · 2× Adam Tooze PERSON · 1× AfD. ORG · 1× Covid ORG · 1× German NORP · 1× Saxony-Anhalt GPE · 1× U.S. GPE · 1× Vladimir Putin PERSON · 1×

Narrative

The results of the European Parliament election, France’s snap election, three German state elections, and the Austrian election all showed a strong rightward drift and signaled voters’ distrust in their national governments, confirming the notable shift in tone on migration in Europe toward a more securitized, hardline approach, even among mainstream parties.
framing: assertive · carried by 1 article(s) · first seen 2026-09-09
🔮 Second, it means that something is making many German voters so angry that they’re finally willing to overlook all of the AfD’s catastrophic flaws — its obvious ties to Vladimir Putin, the fact that the party is filled with crooks, its extreme rhetoric, its lack of governing experience, and so on.
2026-09-09 · Noahpinion
Liberalism needs a new philosophy of immigration · assertive framing

Claims (121 extracted, 3 hedged)

So, Germany’s far-right party, the AfD, just won a huge landslide election victory in the eastern state of Saxony-Anhalt. asserted
party → win → Anhalt
This doesn’t mean AfD is taking over Germany — the far right is much more popular in the post-communist east than in the more populated western regions. asserted
right → mean → regions
Germany is also a parliamentary democracy, and almost everyone else hates and fears the AfD. asserted
everyone → hat → AfD.
But the statewide victory is a warning shot, and everyone in Germany — and in Europe — is taking it seriously. asserted
everyone → take → it
AfD’s surge means two things. asserted
surge → mean → things
First, it means that the rise of far-right parties was not simply a reaction to the pandemic. asserted
rise → mean → pandemic
Back in 2024-25, a number of pundits I respect argued that voters in the U.S. and Europe were backing rightist leaders out of anger at incumbents over Covid. asserted
voters → respect → Covid
That thesis now looks dead. asserted
thesis → look → ?
Second, it means that something is making many German voters so angry that they’re finally willing to overlook all of the AfD’s catastrophic flaws — its obvious ties to Vladimir Putin, the fact that the party is filled with crooks, its extreme rhetoric, its lack of governing experience, and so on. asserted
party → mean → experience
A number of socialist types have tried to claim that AfD’s new voters are responding to economic despair, and can be won back with more socialism. uncertain
voters → try → socialism
But more sober voices agree that the “something” is immigration. asserted
something → agree → ?
Adam Tooze, who strongly leans to the left, tries to be gentle as he explains that there’s no getting around the immigration issue: asserted
he → lean → issue
If you ask AfD voters what they worry about, along with their xenophobic concerns about “too many foreigners”, they will mention the cost of living and their concerns for their standard of living. asserted
they → ask → living
They also mention climate change and the threat of external war… asserted
They → mention → war
But if you ask them what they think about the AfD and why they voted for it, economic issues are barely mentioned. asserted
issues → ask → it
What comes first is security, foreigners, woke politics, remoteness etc… asserted
comes → come → ?
If you are hard up and working-class it would after all be nothing short of bizarre to vote for the AfD in the hope of improved social protection…Voting for the AfD in the current landscape, whatever your economic issues, in short, is not a vote to have your economic issues addressed by social democracy, or welfare or government intervention. asserted
issues → vote → democracy
It is a vote to crackdown on foreigners[.] [emphasis mine] Robin Brooks is more blunt: There’s lots going on in Germany at the moment, but - when it comes to the surge in AfD popularity - you don’t need to overthink it. asserted
you → crackdown → it
The AfD is relentlessly campaigning on immigration, which tells you that this is what resonates most with voters… asserted
what → campaign → voters
A key driver of the recent surge in AfD popularity is that the CDU - SPD grand coalition is proving itself incapable of confronting immigration with the urgency many voters want. asserted
voters → prove → urgency
In fact, anger over immigration is probably the main reason that the right is surging everywhere in Europe. asserted
right → surge → Europe
We use regional data spanning over 4500 electoral outcomes…between 2000 and 2017 to assess the impact of immigration on Western European Far-Right voting. asserted
We → use → voting
To deal with potential reverse causation, we use immigration in neighboring countries as an instrument for domestic immigration. asserted
we → deal → immigration
The estimated effects of immigration are positive, significant and larger compared to those obtained by simple OLS and fixed effects regressions. asserted
effects → estimate → OLS
Depending on the measure of immigration used, we find that a 1% increase in immigration stocks leads to a between 1.78% and 2.97% in Far-Right voting… asserted
increase → depend → voting
Our estimated effects explain a large part of the observed rise in Far-Right in Western European countries that experienced high levels of immigration during the span of our sample. 2026 is hardly the beginning of the trend. asserted
2026 → estimate → trend
Here’s Brookings in 2024: asserted
Brookings → ’ → 2024
In the European Union (EU), one election after another has demonstrated the centrality of irregular migration and border security in public discussions and forced mainstream parties to take more restrictive approaches… asserted
election → demonstrate → approaches
The results of the European Parliament election, France’s snap election, three German state elections, and the Austrian election all showed a strong rightward drift and signaled voters’ distrust in their national governments, confirming the notable shift in tone on migration in Europe toward a more securitized, hardline approach, even among mainstream parties. asserted
results → show → parties
Trump voters rated it as one of their top issues, along with inflation. asserted
voters → rat → inflation
It was the issue where Trump had the strongest lead over Kamala Harris in polls. asserted
Trump → have → polls
American voters clearly soured on immigration in 2023-24. asserted
voters → sour → 2023
Progressives in America and socialists in Europe still desperately claim that what angry working-class voters really want is more economic support. uncertain
want → claim → what
They keep offering more and more lavish promises of welfare supports and price controls, while staunchly opposing restrictions on immigration. asserted
They → offer → immigration
The approach keeps failing, and the far right keeps rising. asserted
right → keep → ?
Center-right and center-left politicians, on the other hand, realize the source of their voters’ anger very clearly, and are taking steps to reduce immigration. asserted
politicians → realize → immigration
Germany’s center-right CDU has already stanched the flow with restrictive policies: And Chancellor Friedrich Merz is responding to AfD’s gains by making it harder to get citizenship. asserted
it → stanch → citizenship
Meanwhile, France and Italy are tightening border controls. asserted
France → tighten → controls
France is making it harder to become a citizen. asserted
it → make → ?
The EU is toughening up its asylum rules. asserted
EU → toughen → rules
…and 81 more, not listed.
💬 Give feedback
🕘 History 🎫 Support