The government is having to walk some fine lines at the moment.
asserted
government → have → moment
Three weeks ago, announcing Labor’s migration policy, Tony Burke was keen to stress that the housing supply problem was not caused by immigration.
asserted
problem → announce → immigration
But, he said, immigration was part of the answer.
asserted
immigration → say → answer
Then last week deja vu – as Jim Chalmers, seeking to get ahead of Tuesday’s interest rate rise, leaned away from suggestions government spending was driving up inflation.
asserted
spending → seek → inflation
At the same time, he recognised there was “more work to do” on cutting spending.
asserted
he → recognise → spending
Are the two ministers contradicting themselves?
asserted
ministers → contradict → themselves
No – in fact, both have legitimate cases.
asserted
both → have → cases
Burke squared his circle by arguing the major factor that changed was not immigration but the fact Australians, post-pandemic, wanted to live with fewer people.
asserted
Australians → square → people
So immigration, which has recently fallen, wasn’t the cause – but cutting it could now help.
uncertain
cutting → fall → it
Similarly, Chalmers’ argument effectively is that Labor has been cutting spending as quickly as is responsible in a changing environment.
asserted
Labor → cut → environment
The fact more can be done doesn’t automatically mean that more should have been done already – especially given the fact nobody knew how events in Iran would play out.
asserted
events → do → Iran
You can disagree with both men on the numbers involved – there are plenty who think both migration and spending should be lower than they are – but there is nothing wrong with the fundamental logic.
asserted
they → disagree → logic
Still, you can see from the nuances involved how delicately balanced the current political situation is.
asserted
situation → see → nuances
There is an old political adage that when you are explaining, you are losing.
asserted
you → be → ?
That probably goes double for an environment as feverish as this one.
asserted
That → go → one
You could observe this fever in the overwrought media response to the Reserve Bank governor’s comments following the rate hike.
uncertain
You → observe → hike
Much coverage suggested Michele Bullock had dealt the government a significant blow by pointing to the fact that inflation “has been driven by domestic capacity pressures”, added to by events in the Middle East.
uncertain
inflation → suggest → East
But how could she have said otherwise, given the fact – which she pointed out – that interest rates began rising before the Iran war?
uncertain
rates → say → war
Chalmers, it should be noted (as Barrie Cassidy did) had been careful in interviews before the hike to stress the Middle East had made an existing inflation problem worse – precisely what Bullock then said.
asserted
Bullock → note → what
“Much worse” were the words both used.
asserted
both → use → ?
Bullock’s point is an important one because if Iran were resolved tomorrow, it would be dangerous for people to simply assume inflation was fixed.
asserted
inflation → resolve → ?
There are clearly inflationary pressures that are not to do with Iran.
asserted
that → be → Iran
That is not the same thing as Bullock pinning it all on government spending.
asserted
Bullock → pin → spending
Remarkably, while all this reading of tea leaves was going on, more direct messages from Bullock went largely ignored.
asserted
messages → go → Bullock
Asked about productivity, she made three clear recommendations.
asserted
she → ask → recommendations
Regulations should be loosened so that financial institutions could more easily lend money to businesses.
uncertain
institutions → loosen → businesses
And she said this: “it’s also incumbent upon businesses to take opportunities to improve productivity …
asserted
it → say → productivity
So businesses need to step up to the plate as well.”
asserted
businesses → need → plate
Her other recommendation was that journalists ask the Productivity Commission chair, Danielle Wood.
asserted
journalists → ask → chair
Really, she was just pointing out the appropriate person to ask.
asserted
she → point → person
Still, it’s worth noting that Wood, like Bullock, has been arguing businesses could do more, saying that on AI we “need businesses willing to take a swing”.
uncertain
we → ’ → swing
It’s not the only area of convergence.
asserted
It → ’ → convergence
Wood has been saying we should loosen housing regulations – and this, too, was something Bullock was quite direct about in her press conference, saying governments needed to continue working to encourage higher-density housing.
asserted
governments → say → housing
Wood has made many other points, some of which get overlooked.
asserted
some → make → which
She has emphasised the gap between advantaged and disadvantaged school students – something you’d hope a country priding itself on “the fair go” would care more about.
asserted
country → emphasise → go
One of her most important points is that acting on productivity now is a “game of inches”.
asserted
acting → act → inches
As she says, those inches can add up – but the truth of making a difference is that lots of smaller actions are needed.
asserted
lots → say → actions
This doesn’t let the government off the hook – the Commission has plenty of recommendations for Labor (including doing more to challenge the cosy oligopolies in this country, another thing business and its backers in the press don’t like to talk about).
asserted
business → let → press
But it undermines the current strain of debate implying Labor should fix productivity this minute.
asserted
Labor → undermine → productivity
Which brings us to the other big demand being made of Labor right now: that it act immediately to fix inflation by cutting spending.
asserted
it → bring → spending
…and 13 more, not listed.