The best lines and policies it has pitched to voters are being appropriated and stolen by the Liberals, altered, and presented to the public as if Prime Minister Mark Carney himself had thought of them.
Recommended Videos
Pierre Poilievre and other Conservative party figures can try to gloat through the pain and sneer that they are the faction with the best ideas.
asserted
they → pitch → ideas
However, policies are not copyrighted, and the public will not judge Carney for championing an expanded housing supply, accelerated major projects, and stronger national defence, among other plans.
asserted
public → copyright → plans
Imitation only flatters the people in power, not the opposition, and Carney is reaping the benefits of his own popularity.
asserted
Carney → flatter → popularity
He can pick the 2025 Conservative platform clean, without a care in the world, and blend what he takes with his own agenda and the leftovers of the Trudeau government.
asserted
he → pick → government
It is very possible that the current era of Canadian conservatism, with its genesis in carbon taxes and the pandemic, is winding down as a viable force.
asserted
era → wind → force
In the summer of 2024, it appeared to be ascendant both federally and provincially.
asserted
it → appear → 2024
On Monday, the Liberals swept a trio of byelections with majorities in every one, retaining two seats they had won in the 2025 federal election and seizing one more from the Conservatives in Quebec.
asserted
they → sweep → Quebec
An August 30 projection from 338Canada has the Conservatives winning just 84 seats if an election were held tomorrow.
asserted
election → have → seats
Those on the right should not waste time on the first four.
asserted
Those → waste → four
They’ve had since April 28, 2025, to accept that the momentum built over the past few years will not produce a Conservative government anytime soon.
asserted
momentum → have → government
The wheels have come off the bus, and it is time to start looking for a new vehicle.
asserted
it → come → vehicle
To be clear, Poilievre’s economic populism has tremendous merit.
asserted
populism → have → merit
Indeed, Canada’s youth are being crushed by a cartel economic model that greatly benefits the asset-rich, while imported labour and other impediments delay their adulthood and careers.
asserted
labour → crush → adulthood
One of the best things to happen under Poilievre’s leadership has been the broadening of the Conservative voter pool, encompassing everyone from frustrated younger voters to blue-collar workers rallying to the Conservative standard.
asserted
One → happen → standard
Keeping the tent open to them is essential going forward.
asserted
Keeping → keep → them
Still, the loss of boomers and other older suburban voters was a crushing blow.
asserted
loss → crush → boomers
Carney and the Liberals still possess another massive advantage: ownership of a largely, semi-fictional version of Canada.
asserted
Carney → possess → Canada
When Donald Trump began his rhetorical war on Canada, the Liberals were, for that reason, very comfortable waving the flag, to devastating electoral effect.
asserted
Liberals → begin → effect
The recent byelections proved that once again.
asserted
byelections → prove → that
The Canadian right is very good at attacking Liberal economics and spending, but is rather hapless when it comes to critiquing the Liberals’ national narrative, much less offering a strong alternative.
asserted
it → attack → alternative
Canadians are more emotional than they pretend to be.
asserted
they → pretend → ?
They have a longstanding pattern of somewhat irrationally rallying around the flag, especially when threatened with economic or political absorption into the United States.
asserted
They → have → States
Our attachments to loved ones are not perfectly rational, yet who would question enduring great pain or even shedding blood to protect them?
asserted
who → love → them
Love of country applies too.
asserted
Love → apply → country
Attacking Liberal vanity with a calculator and tax fact sheets will not displace their strange, administrative nationalism that so many Canadians are inspired by, owing to the lack of an alternative.
asserted
Canadians → attack → alternative
Nor can the right simply copy and paste the ideals of the American Revolution and graft them onto Canada.
asserted
right → copy → Canada
Taken together or individually, these are inherently liberal conceptions of what constitutes a people, and the right should move away from trying to craft its own liberal “idea” of Canada.
asserted
right → take → Canada
Properly understood, Canada is the sum of its Canadian people, their Canadian history, and their Canadian sacrifices.
asserted
Canada → understand → people
There is great value and power there that goes beyond ideology.
asserted
that → be → ideology
Currently, Canadians are not even granted legitimacy on their own land if the land acknowledgements recited by the federal government are regarded as the official Liberal position.
asserted
acknowledgements → grant → position
There is a wider range for Conservatives to pitch a right-of-centre and nationalist alternative for Canada than many think.
asserted
many → be → Canada
How else should they spend their current spell in the wilderness?
asserted
they → spend → wilderness
As recently as the spring, British Columbia promised to become a laboratory of revitalized conservative governance in the wake of a weak, flailing NDP government.
asserted
Columbia → promise → government
All the party needed was the right leader, and it could become the right’s political vanguard in the Carney era.
uncertain
it → need → era
That leadership race was won by Kerry-Lynne Findlay, a former federal MP and cabinet minister under Stephen Harper, whose experience in Ottawa was touted as a great advantage.
asserted
experience → win → advantage
Three months after her victory, no fewer than nine provincial Conservative MLAs have bolted to become independents, citing poor ethics, coziness with Alberta separatists, and poor relations between the inner circle and caucus.
asserted
MLAs → bolt → circle
In Ontario, the Progressive Conservatives have ruled the province with little difficulty since 2018, but Premier Doug Ford seems uninterested in advancing the cause of conservatism with any great vigour.
asserted
Ford → rule → vigour
The best thing the right has going for it right now is the intellectual growth it has undergone since 2020.
asserted
it → go → 2020
As Howard Anglin, a veteran of conservative politics, has noted, there are more right-of-centre journals, societies, and networks than ever, all dedicated to debate and strengthening the intellectual fabric of the right.
asserted
all → note → right
Converting that intellectual growth into political power will be a challenge, but the infrastructure itself is a start.
asserted
infrastructure → convert → power
…and 5 more, not listed.
The Aporia
