The Globe and Mail
· collected 2026-09-06 · by Laura Stone, Jeff Gray
Ontario Premier Doug Ford's Progressive Conservatives held onto two seats in Thursday's by-elections, while the NDP retained one seat. The results leave the provincial legislature unchanged despite critical circumstances due to Canada-US trade talks collapsing last month and tensions with US President Donald Trump. In York-Simcoe, PC candidate Susan Lahey won almost 50% of the vote, while in Hamilton East-Stoney Creek, PC candidate Jeff Beattie won with about 39% of the vote. NDP Leader Marit Stiles framed her party's victory in Scarborough Southwest as a message to Premier Ford that they are coming for him.
Written by the local model on 2026-09-06,
using this article's own text rather than the other coverage of the
same event (that is the story summary below).
Doug Ford’s Progressive Conservatives held on to two seats in Thursday’s Ontario by-elections while the NDP retained a third, results that leave the status quo in the provincial legislature unchanged.
asserted
that → hold → legislature
The races happened at a critical time in Canada-U.S. relations and after the Ontario Premier engaged in a war of words with President Donald Trump.
asserted
Premier → happen → Trump
The contests were seen as the first political test for Mr. Ford’s majority government since trade talks between Canada and the U.S. collapsed last month.
asserted
talks → see → Canada
Earlier this week, Prime Minister Mark Carney’s Liberals swept three federal by-elections across the country, including winning a Quebec seat that was previously Conservative.
asserted
that → sweep → seat
Thursday’s results were a blow the Ontario Liberals, who are set to name a new leader on Nov. 21.
asserted
who → set → Nov.
Ontario’s by-elections were held in York-Simcoe, Hamilton East-Stoney Creek and Scarborough Southwest.
asserted
elections → hold → Simcoe
Going into the vote, Mr. Ford’s Progressive Conservatives held the two seats in York and Hamilton, which were vacated when former cabinet ministers Caroline Mulroney and Neil Lumsden resigned.
asserted
Mulroney → go → York
The Scarborough seat in Toronto’s east end was previously held by Doly Begum, who resigned her position as NDP deputy leader to run for the federal Liberals.
asserted
who → hold → Liberals
In Hamilton East—Stoney Creek, PC candidate Jeff Beattie won with about 39 per cent of the vote.
asserted
Beattie → win → vote
The NDP’s Monique Taylor came in second with almost 33 per cent, and Liberal Heino Doessing was in third with 23 per cent.
asserted
Doessing → come → cent
In York-Simcoe, PC candidate Susan Lahey won almost 50 per cent of the vote, with Liberal Naomi Davison in second at 39 per cent, and the NDP candidate a distant third with 4 per cent.
asserted
candidate → win → cent
The Liberals did significantly better than they did in the 2025 vote, when they won only 24 per cent.
asserted
they → do → cent
In Scarborough Southwest, the NDP held onto its seat, with candidate Fatima Shaban garnering about 40 per cent of the vote - well ahead of Liberal Ahsanul Hafiz at about 30 per cent and PC candidate Noor Tarun at 23 per cent.
asserted
Shaban → hold → cent
Speaking alongside Mr. Beattie outside his victory party in Hamilton, Mr. Ford congratulated his candidate and thanked the opposition parties for their campaigns.
asserted
Ford → speak → campaigns
The Premier vowed to keep up his fight against Mr. Trump’s tariffs: “The enemy isn’t each and every one of us, all of us together.
asserted
enemy → vow → us
And we’re going to fight against Donald Trump.”
asserted
we → go → Trump
The victory in Scarborough was a rare bit of good news for NDP Leader Marit Stiles, after the loss of her deputy leader, which sparked the by-election race, and a series of polls that have shown her party behind Ontario’s leaderless Liberals.
asserted
that → spark → Liberals
She told cheering organizers in Scarborough that Thursday’s victory belonged to them – and that the results showed that her party was the one that could eventually defeat Mr. Ford.
uncertain
that → tell → Ford
“You delivered a message today to Doug Ford,” Ms. Stiles said, flanked by her candidate and several of her MPPs.
asserted
Stiles → deliver → MPPs
“You said, ‘You better watch your back, because we are coming for you.’”
asserted
we → say → you
Mr. Ford’s popularity took a hit earlier this spring after a series of controversies, including his government’s purchase of a $28.9-million private jet and a hotel-expenses scandal that resulted in the resignation of one of his cabinet ministers.
asserted
that → take → ministers
But the Premier has since rebounded in some polls amid a public spat with Mr. Trump, who has personally attacked the Premier.
asserted
who → rebound → Premier
Last week, Mr. Ford told Mr. Trump to “kiss my ass” and called him a loser.
asserted
Ford → tell → him
The PCs used the conflict with the U.S. President as part of their campaign materials, saying the Premier is the only one who can “stand up to Trump.”
asserted
who → use → Trump
But political opponents accused Mr. Ford of deflecting from his own government’s record, including on health care and education.
asserted
opponents → accuse → care
Political observers expected the PCs to hold rural York-Simcoe, north of Toronto, long a Conservative stronghold.
asserted
PCs → expect → Toronto
But the Hamilton seat was seen as being in play for the opposition parties.
asserted
seat → see → parties
NDP candidate Ms. Taylor was a former long-time MPP from a neighbouring area, and the Liberals were hoping to make inroads with Mr. Doessing, who placed second in the 2025 provincial election.
asserted
who → neighbour → election
The Scarborough seat was seen as the most unpredictable.
asserted
seat → see → unpredictable
Both Ms. Stiles and Interim Liberal Leader John Fraser watched the by-election results roll in at candidate events in Scarborough.
asserted
results → watch → Scarborough
The NDP saw the seat, which was won three times by Ms. Begum, as a must-win for candidate Ms. Shaban.
asserted
which → see → Shaban
But the Liberals were looking to take it back, after a nomination battle in which former Liberal MP Nate Erskine-Smith accused the party of wrongdoing after he narrowly lost to candidate Mr. Hafiz.
asserted
he → look → Hafiz
The Ontario PC Party, meanwhile, barred journalists from attending their candidates’ by-election parties, which are traditionally open to media.
asserted
which → bar → media
Voter turnout for the races was low: 29 per cent in Hamilton-Stoney Creek, 26.5 per cent in Scarborough and 21 per cent in York-Simcoe, according to Elections Ontario.
uncertain
turnout → accord → Ontario
