Eoin Higgins is the author of “Owned: How Tech Billionaires on the Right Bought the Loudest Voice on the Left.”
asserted
Billionaires → own → Left
It always felt inevitable that Bari Weiss’s tenure at CBS News would see the network devolve into rank Islamophobia — but even for most of us, who took a dim view of her takeover of the news behemoth, tying Michigan Democratic Senate nominee Abdul El-Sayed to the 9/11 attacks was an unexpected new low.
asserted
tying → feel → attacks
To make matters worse, many centrist Democrats and their allies cleared the way for just this kind of attack.
asserted
Democrats → make → attack
On Monday, CBS reporter Zak Hudak published an article headlined with the critique that El-Sayed’s “deleted tweets on Sept. 11 attacks invite scrutiny of past remarks.”
asserted
tweets → publish → remarks
Weiss, whose time in charge of CBS has been rife with controversy, was reportedly deeply involved with the story’s promotion and framing, going so far as to praise it in a newsroom meeting and champion it “to the entire network,” according to media-industry newsletter Status.
uncertain
time → involve → Status
She “even personally directed the headline to be tweaked to specifically mention” the 9/11 angle.
asserted
headline → direct → angle
The story immediately came under harsh criticism, even from people whose politics when it comes to Muslims are virtually indistinguishable from Weiss’s.
asserted
it → come → Weiss
Atlantic writer Jonathan Chait, for example, called the tweets a “non-story.”
asserted
Chait → call → tweets
CBS declined to mention that two of those three deleted posts were asking Americans to take the death toll of the Covid-19 pandemic as seriously as the attacks.
asserted
two → decline → attacks
It’s worth noting — CBS did not — that invoking 9/11 to put the Covid death toll in perspective wasn’t unusual at the time; then-Gov. Andrew Cuomo directly compared the pandemic, which ravaged New York City, to the attacks the same month that El-Sayed did.
asserted
Sayed → ’ → attacks
Another post at issue was a rather anodyne comment about the consequences of the decadelong war on terror and a call to action: “We could save lives rather than take them.”
uncertain
We → save → them
El-Sayed’s campaign previously told Politico that all posts older than July 2023 were deleted “to prevent any old posts from being taken out of context.”
asserted
posts → tell → context
Weiss’s guidance led to CBS News’s racist framing that there’s just something different — even untrustworthy — about El-Sayed, and that the upcoming 25th anniversary of 9/11 is the right time to ask what that is.
asserted
that → lead → 9/11
In doing so, she’s embracing a long-standing bipartisan tradition of Muslim dehumanization — a playbook still being deployed on both sides of the aisle.
asserted
she → do → aisle
The current anti-Muslim environment reflects the growth and regression in the country since the 9/11 moment: growth in the number of Muslims in political and public life, and the regressive backlash to multicultural liberalism that’s defined the Trump era.
asserted
that → reflect → era
This kind of bigotry was rampant during the early 2000s, particularly in 2002 and 2003, when the George W. Bush administration weaponized Americans’ anger and shock over the attacks to gin up support for its war of choice on Iraq.
asserted
administration → weaponize → Iraq
More recently, in the wake of mass protest and opposition, mainly from the left, to Israel’s genocide of Palestinians in Gaza, institutional power on both sides of the partisan divide has cracked down on dissent.
asserted
power → crack → dissent
In the immediate aftermath of the October 7 attacks, expressing sympathy for Palestine was enough to engender severe career consequences.
asserted
expressing → express → consequences
Since 2023, the landscape of public opinion has shifted significantly.
asserted
landscape → shift → opinion
A supermajority of Democratic voters are opposed to Israel’s war on Gaza and support sanctions on Israel.
asserted
supermajority → support → Israel
Increasingly, primary voters are punishing incumbents who have been diehard supporters of Israel.
asserted
who → punish → Israel
The callback to the anti-Muslim rhetoric of the post-9/11 era has also fallen flat with the base, who are more concerned with affordability and opposing Trump than they are with ensuring U.S. dominance over the region.
asserted
they → fall → region
Rather than adapt to this new political reality, some of the Democratic Party’s most enthusiastic cheerleaders are fighting back by playing dirty.
asserted
some → adapt → dirty
Neera Tanden, president of the powerful Democrat-aligned think tank Center for American Progress, has turned attacking El-Sayed and the Twitch streamer Hasan Piker — who was raised Muslim — into her main focus.
asserted
who → align → focus
Tanden’s venomous online behavior has gained traction with anti-Muslim voices on the Democratic side, including activists Fred Guttenberg and Shannon Watts, who made their names protesting against gun violence against children — unless they live in Gaza.
asserted
they → gain → Gaza
But Tanden, with her reach and influence in the party, which has included stints in both the Biden and Obama administrations, is far more influential, and she wields that influence to her advantage against progressives and Muslims in her own big tent.
asserted
she → include → tent
She’s reposted commentary from white supremacist streamer Nick Fuentes and arch-right provocateur Laura Loomer, in the latter case boosting a comment accusing Piker of using “Ninja Taqiyya,” a white nationalist meme referring to a secret Muslim plot to infiltrate Western society with their Islamic faith.
asserted
She → reposte → faith
Tanden later deleted it, claiming it was a “mistake,” but didn’t disavow the content.
asserted
it → delete → content
A number of Democratic politicians eager to revive the party’s Islamophobic war on terror days have joined these attacks.
asserted
number → revive → attacks
Piker, a public figure aligned with progressives but just outside the mainstream enough to threaten the establishment, is a perfect foil for centrist Democrats fighting against a lefty uprising.
asserted
Piker → align → uprising
Democratic senators and representatives have in turn targeted Piker as a way to swipe at the party’s ascendant left in more and more deranged and defamatory ways, and have repeatedly called on El-Sayed to disavow the streamer, who campaigned for him in the primary.
asserted
who → target → primary
Piker’s recent comments that Israel’s actions are making Jews around the world less safe — echoing remarks previously made by Ezra Klein and others — were were cynically used as another example of the streamer’s “antisemitism” by right-wing Democrats, with Democratic Rep. Josh Gottheimer telling CNN, “There’s no way I’m ever coming out for El-Sayed.”
asserted
I → make → Sayed
Rep. Brad Sherman, a California Democrat, claimed Piker endorsed Hamas fighters raping children.
asserted
Piker → claim → children
And Sen. John Fetterman, the nominal — at the time of this writing — Democrat from Pennsylvania has mumbled at various moments about Piker’s opposition to Israel as part of a dealbreaker for him staying in the party.
asserted
him → mumble → party
This mainstreaming of liberal Islamophobia at the party and think tank level has emboldened media figures to indulge in the same bigotry.
asserted
mainstreaming → embolden → bigotry
At CNN, it’s anchors Dana Bash and Jake Tapper who are most enthusiastic about smearing critics of Israel and engaging in open hate toward Muslims.
asserted
who → ’ → Muslims
As Intercept contributor Adam Johnson has pointed out, CNN’s “State of the Union,” the network’s flagship Sunday news show hosted by Tapper and Bash, “hasn’t had on a Palestinian or Palestinian-American guest in over 7 years, and the last time they did it was Rashida Tlaib and Jake Tapper asked her if she believed in Israel’s ‘right to exist’ three different times.”
asserted
she → point → right
Over at The Atlantic, writers like Chait are often so hostile toward El-Sayed and Piker that they’re earning the kinds of rebukes mostly left to private conversations.
asserted
they → earn → conversations
Chait’s latest smear of El-Sayed was so dishonest it prompted former Atlantic associate editor Siddhartha Mahanta to publicly question the writer, asking if he had requested comment for the claims he was making about the candidate.
uncertain
he → prompt → candidate
Chait snapped back that as an opinion writer, he wasn’t subject to those kinds of ethical requirements — a familiar retort.
asserted
he → snap → requirements
…and 41 more, not listed.
The Aporia
