Days before he won the Democratic primary for a US Senate seat in Michigan, insurgent newcomer Abdul El-Sayed was asked whether he was concerned about being labeled a “socialist”.
asserted
he → win → Michigan
“I’d rather think of myself as a capitalist who has actually read about capitalism,” El-Sayed told CBS News anchor Ed O’Keefe.
asserted
Sayed → think → O’Keefe
“I’m not a socialist.
asserted
I → ’m → ?
While El-Sayed might take pains to distance himself from the label in the swing state of Michigan, O’Keefe noted that the candidate has been linked to the Democratic Socialists of America (DSA), the ascendant leftist group whose meteoric rise has captured the enthusiasm of voters desperate for bold change and whose recent wins have stoked the anxieties of both conservatives and the party’s establishment.
uncertain
wins → take → conservatives
“I’m not DSA,” El-Sayed stressed in the interview, though he made clear there is room for the DSA in the “big tent” he said he’s seeking to build.
asserted
he → ’m → tent
El-Sayed is just one of a number of progressive candidates and elected officials across the country who are navigating their relationship and differences with the DSA, which has come under increasing pressure as its candidates have won one race after the other in Democratic primaries mostly in blue states.
asserted
candidates → elect → states
But as other progressive candidates to the left of the Democratic establishment have mounted bids for office, there has at times been confusion about who is a “DSA candidate” – a confusion some Republicans have been eager to exploit.
asserted
Republicans → mount → times
Some, like El-Sayed, espouse many of the group’s political priorities – fighting fascism, instating universal healthcare, getting money out of politics and boosting labor rights, to name a few – but are not members, nor have they been endorsed by the DSA.
asserted
they → espouse → DSA
Others, like New York’s Claire Valdez, have been organizing with the group for years.
asserted
Others → organize → years
Then there are those like Colorado’s Melat Kiros and Pennsylvania’s Chris Rabb who have long identified as socialists but only recently joined the organization.
asserted
who → be → organization
(All three are DSA-endorsed.)
asserted
three → endorse → ?
Brad Lander was once a member but left the group over its response to the 7 October 2023 attacks in Israel.
asserted
Lander → leave → Israel
Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, the national figure most often associated with the DSA, rejoined the New York City chapter last month after letting her membership lapse for seven years, as speculation mounts about her intention to run for president.
asserted
speculation → associate → president
But DSA membership doesn’t guarantee endorsement, and intense debates have roiled the organization in recent months about which candidates to endorse and how to best ride the current momentum.
asserted
debates → guarantee → momentum
In Los Angeles, for example, the local DSA chapter voted to endorse mayoral candidate Nithya Raman this week after weeks of discussions on whether she was too centrist to earn their backing.
asserted
she → vote → backing
A decade into Trumpism and the Democrats’ failure to stop it, and buoyed up by the popularity of longtime member Zohran Mamdani, the DSA has helped popularize positions once viewed as radical – from taxing the rich to ending support for Israel.
asserted
DSA → stop → Israel
The DSA has become a “shorthand for this rebellion against Democratic party leadership”, said Peter Sterne, an editor at City & State New York who has extensively covered the DSA and a former member of the group.
asserted
who → become → group
In recent months, the group has seen its membership soar to 120,000, its leaders are getting prime time on cable news and a recent poll found that one-third of Democrats now openly identify as “socialist”, a term not long ago viewed as a slur.
The backlash has been swift.
asserted
backlash → see → slur
After DSA candidates won nine out of 10 races in which the group had fielded candidates in New York City in June, party establishment figures issued a string of hostile statements.
asserted
figures → win → statements
Third Way, a centrist Democratic group, announced a $15m effort to go to “war” against them.
asserted
Way → announce → them
DSA leaders and members have become tabloid fodder.
asserted
leaders → become → ?
And this week, House Republicans – joined by eight Democrats – adopted a resolution condemning “socialism” and specifically naming the DSA.
asserted
Republicans → join → DSA
The organization’s critics point to some of its more radical stances, from eliminating the Senate to abolishing borders and defunding the police, as a sign of its unseriousness.
asserted
critics → point → unseriousness
But many DSA members view those as aspirational and consistent with the group’s fundamental values, while calling for a more realistic approach.
asserted
members → view → approach
Even some more moderate Democrats recognize that the DSA’s message is resonating because the rest of the party has failed to present a satisfying vision of its own.
asserted
rest → recognize → own
“You can’t beat something with nothing,” said Bill Galston, a senior fellow in governance studies at the Brookings Institution thinktank in Washington.
asserted
Galston → beat → Washington
“The more moderate wing of the Democratic party is going to have to raise its game substantially.”
asserted
wing → go → game
The DSA’s popularity and campaigning capacity on the one hand, and the animosity from more conservative corners on the other, has left some candidates, particularly in swing states, navigating a balancing act.
asserted
animosity → leave → act
In Florida, Angie Nixon, who recently won the Democratic Senate primary in one of the biggest upsets of the primary season, joined the DSA only in June but has not been endorsed by the group.
asserted
who → win → group
When asked whether she identified as a democratic socialist, she equivocated.
asserted
she → ask → socialist
“I don’t agree with everything that they agree with, but they’re fighting hard to ensure we have access to universal healthcare, access to free college and fully funded public schools,” she said in an interview with the Guardian.
asserted
she → agree → Guardian
“I’ve always been a lifelong Democrat but I’m more of [a] social democrat who believes in strong safety nets.”
asserted
who → ’m → nets
Some of the most popular politicians associated with the DSA have broken with the group on some issues.
asserted
Some → associate → issues
The group has for months been debating how to respond to a possible presidential run by Ocasio-Cortez.
asserted
group → debate → Cortez
Some factions, and particularly many NYC-DSA members, have openly encouraged it, while others are suspicious of what they view as her willingness to compromise on DSA priorities.
asserted
they → encourage → priorities
Mamdani has also broken with the group over policing.
asserted
Mamdani → break → policing
Ultimately, the decision will be made democratically – DSA members report often excruciatingly deliberative processes and stress that the “democratic” element of the group’s identity is just as fundamental as its socialist one.
asserted
element → make → one
Endorsements, Sterne noted, can power a campaign with an “army” of canvassers and phone bank volunteers – the DSA’s New York City chapter says that its 50,000 volunteers knocked on doors 1.6m times in support of Mamdani’s candidacy.
asserted
volunteers → note → candidacy
But the “DSA doesn’t just want to help get people into office and then let them do whatever they want”, he added, noting that there was some concern within the organization that candidates may opportunistically hitch their wagon to the group but not work with it after getting elected.
uncertain
candidates → want → it
The tension between the pragmatists and the purists, he argued, is healthy, and a sign of the organization’s strength.
asserted
he → argue → strength
…and 2 more, not listed.
The Aporia
