As the nation prepares to mark 25 years since Sept. 11, 2001,
, the Democratic nominee for U.S. Senate in Michigan, may be facing the risk of renewed scrutiny and fresh political attack.
uncertain
nominee → prepare → scrutiny
El-Sayed is a leader of a new crop of candidates from a wing of his party that opposed American wars and capitalized on anger over anti-Arab sentiment in a state with a robust and active Muslim community.
asserted
that → oppose → community
But now he is now attempting to adapt – and in some cases delete – past statements that may run afoul of a broad, general election audience.
uncertain
that → attempt → audience
against Republican Rep. Mike Rogers, El-Sayed, a former public health official, has from the views of Hasan Piker, a popular Twitch streamer who has appeared at El-Sayed's campaign events and who generated controversy for declaring that "America deserved 9/11" before later retracting the remark.
asserted
America → have → remark
Meanwhile, El-Sayed's past references to the deadly attacks have continued to surface, including two deleted social media posts verified by CBS News that have not been previously reported.
asserted
that → continue → News
In those posts, he calls for the American public to muster the same outrage for the COVID-19 death toll that they displayed after 9/11.
asserted
they → call → 9/11
In one, from April 2020, El-Sayed compared the nearly 3,000 Americans killed on Sept. 11 to the mounting COVID-19 death toll and argued for a response commensurate with the nation's post-9/11 mobilization.
asserted
Sayed → compare → mobilization
In another, El-Sayed wrote that because more Americans had died from COVID than in the Sept. 11 attacks, he hoped "that means we'll spend the next ten years fighting a war for public health & against poverty ... like we launched a global #WaronTerror after 9/11.
asserted
we → write → 9/11
We could save lives rather than take them."
"Abdul has always unequivocally condemned terrorism and the September 11 attacks," a spokesperson for El-Sayed's campaign said in a statement to CBS News.
uncertain
spokesperson → save → News
"Mike Rogers' attempts to misrepresent Abdul's beliefs are bad-faith lies meant to mislead Michiganders.
asserted
attempts → misrepresent → Michiganders
In another deleted post, first reported by the Washington Free Beacon, El-Sayed wrote on Sept. 11, 2021: "Today, I mourn the 3K lives, 6K injuries, & infrastructural devastation in NYC, perpetuated ignorantly in the name of my faith.
asserted
I → delete → faith
Tomorrow, I'll mourn ~1M lives, millions of injuries, & infrastructural devastation in 3 countries, perpetuated ignorantly in the name of my country.
asserted
I → mourn → country
"
For El-Sayed, the emergence of old social media posts could present a unique challenge, said Adrian Hemond, a bipartisan political consultant based in Lansing.
uncertain
Hemond → present → Lansing
"El-Sayed has what I call a 'Quacks like a duck problem,'" Hemond said.
asserted
Hemond → have → duck
"There's enough quacking going on, sort of directionally, that it has raised questions for a lot of people, and he hasn't done a very good job addressing those questions."
asserted
he → be → questions
The coming anniversary will mark another chance for El-Sayed to navigate a uniquely sensitive chapter of American history in a way that reassures moderate voters without alienating the progressive activists who make up a significant part of his political coalition.
asserted
who → come → coalition
"I think that people underestimate how critically important the Arab vote is in Michigan," said Kristian Ramos, a Washington-based progressive strategist.
asserted
Ramos → think → Michigan
"I think that the war in Iran and everything else has scrambled a lot of people's perceptions on what is and isn't acceptable in this moment," Ramos added.
asserted
Ramos → think → moment
"And I also think what people are missing is there's a reason that he came out of the primary the way that he did: because he was speaking to issues that resonated with Michigan primary voters who he will need to win the general."
asserted
he → think → general
The Sept. 11 attacks have largely served as a source of unity in American politics.
asserted
attacks → serve → politics
The attacks killed nearly 3,000 people, launched two decades of military conflict and reshaped everything from foreign policy to airport security.
asserted
attacks → kill → security
For candidates seeking statewide office, even indirect references to the attacks can invite scrutiny that references to other tragedies might not.
uncertain
that → seek → tragedies
Matt Grossmann, a political scientist at Michigan State University, said El-Sayed's deleted social media posts are unlikely to damage his campaign on their own, but they feed a narrative pushed by his opponent that he holds fringe views.
asserted
he → say → views
"Is any specific tweet going to matter for the general election?
asserted
tweet → go → election
It seems unlikely," Grossmann said.
asserted
Grossmann → seem → ?
"But does the general impression that he might be too extreme [...] will that make a difference?
uncertain
that → make → difference
That has a bigger chance of doing so."
The more El-Sayed is questioned about his prior rhetoric, the less he will be able to wage successful attacks on his opponent, former Republican Rep. Mike Rogers, said Democratic strategist and CBS News contributor Joel Payne.
asserted
Payne → have → opponent
"He applies a kind of non-traditional voice to some of those ideas.
asserted
He → apply → ideas
That allowed him to stand out.
asserted
him → allow → ?
That also allowed him to demonstrate his willingness to kind of break from convention," said Payne.
asserted
Payne → allow → convention
"Right now, I think what that's created for him is that [his non-conventional voice] is what people want to talk about, as opposed to him executing an economic case against Mike Rogers.
asserted
him → think → Rogers
The most acute example of this dynamic emerged when El-Sayed sought to address his association with Piker, the Twitch personality who in 2019 declared that "America deserved 9/11" before later retracting the remark.
asserted
America → emerge → remark
As El-Sayed campaigned alongside the streamer this spring, he was repeatedly pressed to explain the relationship.
asserted
he → campaign → relationship
In an interview on Fox & Friends in April, El-Sayed said: "Of course I don't think 9/11 was justified.
asserted
9/11 → say → April
Just because you appear with somebody doesn't mean you agree with them on everything."
asserted
you → appear → everything
Republicans have since sought to turn the issue into a broader test of character and judgment, arguing that El-Sayed's continued association with Piker reflects poorly on his political instincts.
asserted
association → seek → instincts
His opponent, Rogers, issued a statement after El-Sayed secured the Democratic nomination that falsely attributed Piker's comments to El-Sayed himself.
asserted
that → issue → Sayed
"I spent years hunting terrorists and bringing Osama bin Laden to justice," Rogers said.
asserted
Rogers → spend → justice
"Never in a million years did I think that I would be running against someone who believes America deserved 9/11."
asserted
America → think → 9/11
Separately, El-Sayed had called the events of September 11 "craven terrorist attacks" and said they "devastated him" in his 2020 book "Healing Politics."
More broadly, the Sept. 11 issue fits a recurring challenge for El-Sayed's campaign.
asserted
issue → call → campaign
…and 3 more, not listed.
The Aporia
