Can the Carney government's second budget help put Canada on a path to net zero?
asserted
budget → put → net
This week's budget is an opportunity to fill out a new federal climate agenda
In the spring of 2024, nine months before he formally entered politics, Mark Carney made a couple of public appearances to discuss the state of the Canadian economy and the possible paths forward.
asserted
Carney → fill → economy
And on at least one specific area of policy Carney suggested he would do things differently than Justin Trudeau.
uncertain
he → suggest → Trudeau
"Personally, would I swap one battery plant for a million, million-five heat pumps?" Carney asked himself rhetorically during a Q&A in Toronto, referring to a series of deals the Trudeau government signed to attract battery manufacturing facilities to Canada.
asserted
government → swap → Canada
Because that would deliver — let's deliver stuff for people."
asserted
's → deliver → people
The government, he said, needed to "make choices that deliver for people today as part of a larger change."
What we know about Ottawa's $2B rebate plan for heat pumps
Canada facing carbon tariff threat from European Union
Earlier this month, Carney acted on something like that idea, announcing a $2-billion heat pump rebate program that the federal government projects could benefit approximately 820,000 households.
The Carney government hardly invented the idea of helping Canadians retrofit their homes or install heat pumps — the Trudeau government had its own initiatives, including a specific program for households that used oil to heat their homes.
uncertain
that → say → homes
But the new program did add something to a Carney climate agenda that has so far been defined by the Trudeau-era policies he has subtracted.
asserted
he → add → policies
Nonetheless, the Canadian Climate Institute greeted the announcement as a "modest" boost toward greater electrification.
asserted
Institute → greet → electrification
"It's modest in terms of the level of ambition that this government is showing on other public policy files.
asserted
government → show → files
It's modest in terms of the amount of money that this government is spending on other public policy files.
asserted
government → spend → files
And it's modest in terms of the time frame and the number of homes impacted," says Rick Smith, president of the climate institute.
asserted
Smith → impact → institute
"I hesitate to use this overused expression, but it's a good first step.
asserted
it → hesitate → expression
That more needs to be done is fairly indisputable.
asserted
needs → need → ?
Analysis published by the Canadian Climate Institute last month confirmed that Canada is not on track to meet its greenhouse gas emissions target for 2030.
asserted
Canada → publish → 2030
The Trudeau government set a goal of reducing emissions by 40 per cent below 2005 levels, but the institute estimates emissions might only fall by 21 per cent.
uncertain
emissions → set → cent
That Canada would not achieve its target for 2030 was tacitly acknowledged by the prime minister in June when he said the changes made by his government would mean that "our emissions will be higher in the next few years than they were projected to be under the previous government's plan."
asserted
they → achieve → plan
The Carney government remains committed to aiming for net-zero emissions by 2050, but the institute's projections still show what it calls a "cavernous gap" between Canada's current track and the mid-century goal.
asserted
it → remain → track
Could this week's federal budget go some way toward filling that gap?
uncertain
budget → go → gap
What will the budget mean for climate policy?
asserted
budget → mean → policy
Pre-budget submissions from climate-focused groups — the Green Budget Coalition, New Economy Canada, Clean Energy Canada, Efficiency Canada and the Pembina Institute — offered a number of proposals for boosting clean electricity and supporting home and building retrofits.
asserted
submissions → focus → retrofits
Such initiatives would seem to be in line with where the Carney government would like to focus.
asserted
government → seem → line
Carney has said Canadians' affordability concerns are weighing on climate policy and he has put clean electricity at the centre of his agenda moving forward.
asserted
he → say → agenda
"The path to net-zero is electrification," the prime minister said earlier this year, announcing the government's new electricity strategy.
asserted
minister → say → strategy
That strategy embraced the goal of doubling Canada's electricity grid by 2050.
asserted
strategy → embrace → 2050
But getting to that goal without overly burdening ratepayers might require significant amounts of federal funding.
uncertain
getting → get → funding
Carney himself has spoken of "using the government balance sheet" in a way that "spreads out the cost over a long period."
asserted
that → speak → period
To that end, the climate institute has proposed a new federal fund to help provincial utilities manage the cost of expansion.
asserted
utilities → propose → expansion
Tyler Meredith, a former policy adviser in the Trudeau government, has proposed a new federal transfer of $5.4 billion per year contingent on legislated conditions (similar to the way the federal government provides provinces with funding for health care).
asserted
government → propose → care
"First and foremost [to doubling electricity and getting Canada on track to net-zero] is helping provinces finance the electricity build out and the interconnections that are needed," says Merran Smith of New Economy Canada, a coalition of business and labour organizations.
asserted
Smith → double → organizations
"I'm not sure they're going to have exactly what the answer is [in the budget], but I'll be looking for progress on identifying how the federal government thinks it can work collaboratively with [provincial utilities]."
asserted
it → go → utilities
That the government chose to put a picture of electricity transmission lines on the cover of the budget might bode well for such hopes.
uncertain
chose → choose → hopes
But obviously the details within the budget will matter more than the nice photo on the front.
asserted
details → matter → front
In an op-ed published earlier this fall, Rick Smith argued that Carney could now be measured against his own climate commitments, including the target of net-zero by 2050.
uncertain
Carney → publish → 2050
The prime minister has, for instance, set ambitious goals for electric-vehicle adoption.
asserted
minister → set → adoption
Recent changes to vehicle regulations were met with disappointment from climate groups, but the government also promised a new national charging infrastructure strategy.
asserted
government → meet → strategy
The Carney government has also talked about improving industrial carbon-pricing systems and perhaps linking provincial carbon markets — a federal-provincial working group is scheduled to offer recommendations on the latter next summer.
asserted
group → talk → latter
"To the extent that the current government has a climate change plan, it is a series of specific commitments that the prime minister has made that the federal government has yet to put the legs under," Smith says.
asserted
Smith → make → legs
When the Environics Institute surveyed Canadians in 2019, 24 per cent said climate change was the most important issue facing the country.
asserted
change → survey → country
When Environics asked again this year, just three per cent said the same, putting climate change far behind concerns about Donald Trump and the cost of living.
asserted
cent → ask → living
The Carney government also faces only limited pressure within the House of Commons to take action to reduce emissions — the Conservatives are primarily focused on opposing existing federal climate policies.
asserted
Conservatives → face → policies
…and 6 more, not listed.
The Aporia
