Every Israeli election ballot has now been counted, and the final tally confirms one of the major stories of the contest is the remarkably strong performance of the so-called Arab parties.
asserted
one → count → parties
These parties attract most of their support from Arab citizens of Israel, many of whom identify as Palestinian citizens of Israel, and make up about 20 per cent of the population.
asserted
many → attract → population
The Arab parties won 19 seats, a major improvement on the 10 they claimed at the last election.
asserted
they → win → election
This reflects a massive increase in voter turnout in Israel’s Arab sector; around 80 per cent of Arab-Israelis are believed to have voted this year, up from 53 per cent in the last election.
asserted
cent → reflect → election
A surge of violent crime, unsolved murders and home demolitions under far-right National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir convinced Arab-Israelis to vote in record numbers.
asserted
surge → convince → numbers
Supreme Court Justice Noam Sohlberg has asked the country’s internal security agency, Shin Bet, to investigate claims that Qatar used foreign interference to drive up the Arab vote, leading to accusations from Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s Likud party that the elections had been stolen.
uncertain
elections → ask → party
Opposition parties have backed the investigation, while condemning Likud’s alarmist rhetoric before the full facts are known.
asserted
facts → back → rhetoric
Qatar has called the allegations “ridiculous and dangerous”.
asserted
Qatar → call → allegations
The opposition bloc of Zionist parties led by former military chief Gadi Eisenkot and the Arab parties won 67 seats in total, more than Netanyahu’s conservative coalition (53 seats) and easily enough to form a new government.
asserted
bloc → lead → government
Many Israelis who want to see Netanyahu removed from power are clamouring for this to happen one way or the other, but it currently looks to be a remote prospect because of imposing political and practical problems.
asserted
it → want → problems
To see why, it is first important to understand the differences between the two main Arab party groupings.
asserted
it → see → groupings
The Joint List is a coalition of three mostly Arab parties – Hadash, Ta’al and Balad – that won 11 seats at this election.
asserted
that → win → election
Hadash represents the remnants of the Communist Party of Israel and other far-left groups.
asserted
Hadash → represent → Israel
It has favoured the creation of a Palestinian state alongside Israel and the recognition of Israel’s Arab community as an official minority.
asserted
It → favour → minority
Balad is a more radical Palestinian nationalist party that favours a one-state solution, with Jews and Arabs sharing the same country from the Mediterranean Sea to the Jordan River.
asserted
Jews → favour → River
Its opposition to Israel as a Jewish state has repeatedly seen it banned from participating in elections.
asserted
it → see → elections
The Central Elections Committee disqualified Balad’s leader, Sami Abu Shehadeh, from running in this year’s elections for an article he wrote on October 8, 2023, describing the October 7 attacks as an “important historical event”.
asserted
he → disqualify → event
Critics said it displayed “support for armed struggle against Israel” and Shehadeh eventually withdrew from the elections.
asserted
Shehadeh → say → elections
The Joint List is an ideologically committed grouping that puts great emphasis on the need to reach a political settlement with the Palestinians.
asserted
that → put → Palestinians
Its members display ambivalence to, or outright hostility towards, Israel’s status as a Jewish majority state.
asserted
members → display → state
This leads to a complicated relationship between the parties and government.
asserted
This → lead → parties
The Joint List parties have not traditionally sought to join Israeli governing coalitions on the grounds that it would be wrong to provide legitimacy to the Israeli government until the occupation of the Palestinian territories in the West Bank and Gaza ends.
asserted
occupation → seek → Bank
This is why the prospect of the Joint List agreeing to the equivalent of a supply-and-confidence agreement with Eisenkot has been floated as a way to remove Netanyahu from power and install a new minority government.
asserted
List → agree → government
The party began as an offshoot of the Islamic Movement in Israel, which has close ties to the Muslim Brotherhood.
asserted
which → begin → Brotherhood
The party performs extremely well in the Negev Desert, including among Israel’s Bedouin communities.
asserted
party → perform → communities
Led by former dentist Mansour Abbas, Ra’am is increasingly willing to work within the Israeli system to achieve practical improvements for Arab Israeli citizens on issues such as crime.
asserted
Ra’am → lead → crime
Ra’am joined a short-lived coalition government led by former prime minister Naftali Bennett and Yair Lapid in 2021-22 – the first time in Israeli history an Arab party had been part of a governing coalition.
asserted
party → join → coalition
Abbas used the position to gain extra resources for Arab communities and would like to do so again.
asserted
Abbas → use → communities
Which raises the question of why the Arab parties are not being treated as the kingmakers their parliamentary numbers suggest they should be.
asserted
they → raise → kingmakers
The short answer is that October 7 changed the dynamics in Israel, making it harder for many Jewish Israelis to stomach co-operation with Arab parties.
asserted
Israelis → change → parties
As for Abbas, he has forcefully condemned the October 7 attacks, but has declined to say whether he regards Hamas as a terrorist organisation that needs to be eliminated.
asserted
that → condemn → organisation
This was a key condition that Eisenkot issued for parties to join a coalition led by him.
asserted
parties → issue → him
His conditions also include mandatory military service for all Israelis, another complication given the vast majority of Arab-Israelis do not serve in the Israel Defence Forces and several parties do not support universal conscription.
asserted
parties → include → conscription
Right-wing secular leader Avigdor Lieberman, a member of Eisenkot’s bloc, has repeated since the elections that his party will not go into a coalition with the support of the Arab parties (or Netanyahu).
asserted
party → repeat → parties
This means Eisenkot would lose at least eight of Lieberman’s seats from his bloc.
asserted
Eisenkot → mean → bloc
Bennett has also been firm on not relying on the support of Arab parties.
asserted
Bennett → rely → parties
Eylon Levy, a former Israeli government spokesperson who favoured a change from Netanyahu, says it would be political suicide for Eisenkot to pursue a minority government dependent on the support of “Islamists and communists”.
asserted
Eisenkot → favour → Islamists
“If this happened, it would be massively unpopular, extremely unstable and drag the country back to another round of elections in which Netanyahu would win an even bigger majority,” he argues.
asserted
he → happen → majority
“If they are even flirting with the idea, they are putting themselves in a very dangerous position.”
asserted
they → flirt → position
Israel’s ambassador to Australia, Hillel Newman, argued in a pre-election briefing that any minority government dependent on the Arab parties would be short-lived, probably collapsing within a year over disagreements about military funding.
asserted
government → argue → funding
…and 10 more, not listed.
The Aporia
