On Oct. 7, 2023, Hamas-led militants broke through Israel’s border and attacked communities in southern Israel, killing about 1,200 people and taking roughly 250 hostages.
asserted
militants → lead → hostages
Most of those killed were civilians.
asserted
Most → kill → those
Yet the years since Oct. 7 have highlighted another phenomenon: celebrities increasingly inserting themselves into one of the world’s most complicated conflicts.
asserted
celebrities → highlight → conflicts
The attack’s brutality is well documented.
asserted
brutality → document → ?
A U.N. mission later found reasonable grounds to believe that conflict-related sexual violence, including rape and gang rape, occurred at several locations during the Oct. 7 attacks.
asserted
violence → find → attacks
Everyone is entitled to an opinion.
asserted
Everyone → entitle → opinion
Actors, singers, and musicians certainly have the same right to speak as anyone else.
asserted
Actors → have → anyone
But fame does not give someone’s political views greater authority, and a large audience is not the same as expertise.
asserted
audience → give → expertise
That distinction is too often forgotten.
asserted
distinction → forget → ?
John Cusack, Roger Waters, Susan Sarandon, Cynthia Nixon, Mark Ruffalo, Macklemore, and others are among the prominent entertainers who have publicly criticized Israel or supported the Palestinian cause.
asserted
who → criticize → cause
Their celebrity gives them enormous platforms.
asserted
celebrity → give → platforms
But what particular expertise does being an actor or musician provide on the history, politics, and security of the Middle East?
asserted
being → provide → East
Cusack provides one example.
asserted
Cusack → provide → example
The advocacy organization StopAntisemitism named him its “Antisemite of the Week” in 2024 and accused him of sharing posts denying that Hamas raped women on Oct. 7.
asserted
Hamas → name → Oct.
Cusack rejected the organization’s accusations, calling them lies.
asserted
Cusack → reject → them
, this actor retweeted an antisemitic meme featuring a hand with the Star of David crushing people, adding the trope “follow the money.”
asserted
actor → retweete → money
He later deleted the tweet, apologizing and claiming he thought he was endorsing a pro-Palestinian message.
asserted
he → delete → message
That is precisely why public figures should exercise caution when making sweeping pronouncements on complicated events.
asserted
figures → exercise → events
Millions of followers do not transform opinion into fact.
asserted
Millions → transform → fact
Celebrities have every right to criticize Israel, defend Palestinians, criticize Hamas, or argue about U.S. foreign policy.
asserted
Celebrities → have → policy
Their audiences have an equally important right to decide how much weight those opinions deserve.
asserted
opinions → have → weight
An Oscar, a Grammy, or a sold-out concert shows artistic achievement.
asserted
Oscar → sell → achievement
Fame does not mean expertise.
asserted
Fame → mean → expertise
William Pollack has spent four decades owning and operating local radio stations, television stations, and movie theaters.
asserted
Pollack → spend → stations