Lindsay Clancy, prosecutors, defense lawyers, the judge and millions watching on are back where they started after her five-week trial over the murder of her three children ended in a mistrial.
asserted
trial → watch → mistrial
America’s saddest case has ceased for the moment, but the legal wrangling is not over, and a second trial could now be on the horizon, prolonging and repeating an agonizing spectacle that has gripped America and the world.
uncertain
that → cease → America
The trial lurched to its conclusion on Friday as jurors in Massachusetts failed to come to a unanimous verdict.
asserted
jurors → lurch → verdict
A lone male juror holdout appeared to be preventing a conclusion to the case.
asserted
holdout → appear → case
That meant the trial ended as it had begun: with no legal certainty about what was in Clancy’s mind when on 24 January 2023 she killed five-year-old Cora, three-year-old Dawson, and eight-month-old Callan, and later cut her wrists and jumped from a bedroom window, sustaining injuries that paralyzed her.
asserted
that → mean → her
Clancy, a 36-year-old former labor and delivery nurse, did not deny the killings but pleaded not guilty to the murders.
asserted
Clancy → deny → murders
Defense attorney Kevin Reddington blamed postpartum psychosis coupled with overmedication.
asserted
Reddington → blame → overmedication
Prosecutors said she knew what she was doing.
asserted
she → say → what
The jury deliberated for six days and over 30 hours, coming back three times in total in a deadlock.
asserted
jury → deliberate → deadlock
The jury foreperson said in a note to the judge on Thursday that a single juror had expressed reasonable doubt but would “not follow the law”.
asserted
juror → say → law
The mistrial finally came after a nail-biting delay when the judge allowed Clancy’s defense to petition the Massachusetts supreme court to replace the outlying juror with an alternate.
asserted
defense → come → alternate
Massachusetts justice Dalila Argaez Wendlandt took the matter under advisement and soon after issued a decision not to intervene in the proceedings, forcing Judge William Sullivan to declare a mistrial.
asserted
Wendlandt → take → mistrial
Reddington stared at the ground and let out a sigh as the judge made the ruling.
asserted
judge → star → ruling
At the back of the courtroom, largely occupied by supporters, people could be seen wiping away tears.
uncertain
people → occupy → tears
And now it starts again.
asserted
it → start → ?
Reddington said he would file a motion for a directed finding of not guilty within days – a ruling that Sullivan could make on grounds that the prosecution failed to present enough evidence to prove the case.
uncertain
prosecution → say → case
A status hearing is set for 29 September when a new trail date could be set.
uncertain
date → set → September
“This whole case has been unbelievable,” said victims’ rights attorney and survivor advocate Shari Karney.
asserted
Karney → say → ?
“Eleven jurors believed that Lindsay Clancy did not have criminal intent to commit this crime, understood the consequences of her act, and could not conform her conduct to the law.”
uncertain
Clancy → believe → law
The decision to try Clancy again rests with Plymouth county district attorney Tim Cruz, a prosecutor since 1985 who has served as district attorney for more than 20 years.
asserted
who → try → years
Before Cruz’s most recent re-election, in 2022, he took aim at progressive district attorneys, saying they have been causing “anarchy and chaos” across the US.
asserted
they → take → US
“I am against getting rid of life without parole for first-degree homicide people,” said in a debate.
asserted
I → rid → debate
“I am against having a list of cases that will not be prosecuted because it does not work.”
asserted
it → have → cases
Outside court on Thursday, Reddington said he was ready to retry the case.
asserted
he → say → case
“Bring it on,” he told reporters.
asserted
he → bring → reporters
But he did not rule out the possibility of a plea deal.
asserted
he → rule → deal
“We’ll see what Mr Cruz wants to do, and then we’ll talk about our options,” he said.
asserted
he → see → options
For now, Clancy returns to Tewksbury hospital, where she has been held since the killings.
asserted
she → return → killings
According to Karney, the complexity of the Massachusetts law on proving “criminal responsibility” – or what in other states would rest on the defense showing the defendant was insane – is a double standard.
uncertain
defendant → accord → defense
“It’s very complicated,” she says.
asserted
she → ’ → ?
Part of the difficulty jurors may have had is that mental health issues are not as a transparent as physical issues, and under criminal law there is a bias against them, she says.
uncertain
she → have → them
Karney said: “Clancy was basically having a mental health stroke, and mental health is the stepsister of the healthcare system.
asserted
health → say → system
It’s not right.
asserted
It → ’ → ?
But because we cant see it, that doesn’t mean it doesn’t exist.
asserted
it → see → it
And the medical healthcare system doesn’t want to recognize and pay for mental healthcare apart from giving out drugs to make them go away.
asserted
them → want → drugs
During the trial, jurors heard from mental health experts who clashed over Clancy’s medical records.
asserted
who → hear → records
But it was her mother and step mother who may have provided the most powerful testimony when they testified about the steps Clancy had taken to seek help.
uncertain
Clancy → provide → help
Paula Musgrove, Clancy’s mother, testified that she often stayed with her daughter in the months leading up to the killings because Clancy was afraid of sleeping alone, was increasingly paranoid and believed the medications she was taking “were destroying her mind”.
asserted
she → testify → mind
Susan Clancy, Lindsay Clancy’s former mother-in-law, said she was “begging for help” and “was struggling – we were all concerned”.
asserted
we → say → help
Forensic psychiatrist Phillip Resnick, for the defense, testified near the end of the trial testimony that that Clancy was “frankly psychotic” the day of the killings, and supported her claim that she heard a voice that ordered her to kill the children and herself.
uncertain
that → testify → children
…and 10 more, not listed.
The Aporia
