The deadlocked jury in the Lindsay Clancy trial has begun deliberating for a seventh day after a holdout juror led to a heated exchange between the judge and Clancy’s defense attorney.
asserted
juror → begin → judge
The unusual disclosure about the holdout juror, made in a note to the judge, delivered the clearest glimpse yet of what could be keeping jurors from reaching a verdict on whether the Massachusetts mother is criminally responsible for killing her three children.
uncertain
mother → make → children
The jury has told Judge William Sullivan twice so far that it is unable to agree on a verdict.
asserted
it → tell → verdict
Despite a request from Clancy’s defense attorney, Sullivan ruled Friday morning that he would not question the juror further.
asserted
he → rule → juror
Lindsay Clancy’s lawyer clashes with judge
A heated exchange between the judge and Defense Attorney Kevin Reddington ensued, with Reddington accusing the judge of "glossing over" the problem of the holdout juror.
asserted
Reddington → clash → juror
"I would ask that you not just give them, as I described it yesterday, a soft inquiry,” Reddington said.
asserted
Reddington → ask → inquiry
“I would ask that you specifically direct their attention to proof beyond a reasonable doubt and reinstruct them on that forcefully."
asserted
you → ask → that
Sullivan snapped back: "I think I did that yesterday, didn't I?"
asserted
I → snap → that
Reddington replied: "You did it yesterday, you did it soft, you didn't do it forcefully, and I'm asking that you do it forcefully."
asserted
you → reply → it
Sullivan said in response: "What do you want me, what do you want me to do?
asserted
me → say → what
I read the instruction as written by the SJC.
asserted
I → read → SJC
The fact that I perhaps didn't give it like full inflection, I'm sorry about that, I'm not an actor, I'm just giving the instructions."
asserted
I → give → instructions
Reddington pressed the issue even further, stating: "Well my point, judge, simply is that you're kind of glossing over the issue.
asserted
you → press → issue
The issue is this juror will not, according to that note, apply the law of reasonable doubt, and that's why I've requested, you know what I've requested, so I note my objection."
uncertain
I → accord → objection
"I am specifically not glossing over this issue,” Sullivan replied.
asserted
Sullivan → gloss → issue
“I have thought about this issue long and hard, I know the defendant objects, but the characterization that I'm glossing over it, trust me that's not the situation, I've been thinking about this for quite a while."
asserted
I → think → while
Jury sends note about holdout juror
Sullivan brought in each juror individually on Thursday and questioned them in private after he received the note about the holdout juror.
asserted
he → send → juror
The judge then reread his instructions on reasonable doubt and sent jurors back to continue deliberating.
asserted
judge → reread → jurors
Reddington urged Sullivan to dismiss the juror Thursday, arguing the person had refused to follow the judge's instructions.
asserted
person → urge → instructions
Prosecutors objected and Sullivan refused to remove the juror.
asserted
Sullivan → object → juror
“I don’t feel it is proper for me to side with one side or the other of the deliberations,” the judge said.
asserted
judge → feel → deliberations
“I don’t feel it’s appropriate for me to say, ‘I agree with one juror or the 11.’
asserted
I → feel → juror
I have asked if they are able to follow my instructions.
asserted
they → ask → instructions
They swore earlier that they could.”
uncertain
they → swear → ?
Clancy, a 36-year-old former labor and delivery nurse, doesn’t deny strangling her children in 2023 before trying to take her own life.
asserted
Clancy → deny → life
Her attorney says postpartum psychosis led to her actions, while prosecutors argue she knew what she was doing when she killed Cora, Dawson and Callan Clancy, ages 5, 3 and 8 months.
asserted
she → say → Cora
Prosecutors say Clancy deliberately sent her then-husband on errands to get him out of the house and they questioned the seriousness of her suicide attempt.
asserted
they → say → attempt
Clancy’s livestreamed trial has generated massive interest, with reporters and spectators packing the courtroom.
asserted
reporters → livestreame → courtroom
The case has also sparked deep public divisions over her culpability and the issues around maternal mental health after childbirth.
asserted
case → spark → childbirth
If the jury ultimately can’t agree on a verdict, the judge could declare a mistrial.
uncertain
judge → agree → mistrial
Prosecutors would then have to decide whether to put Clancy on trial again, drop the charges or try to negotiate a plea deal with her lawyer.
asserted
Prosecutors → have → lawyer
If the jury decides Clancy was criminally responsible for her actions, it could convict her of either murder or manslaughter.
uncertain
it → decide → murder
If she is acquitted, a judge could still order her confined to a mental health facility if an evaluation determines that she poses a danger to the public.
uncertain
she → acquit → public
The Aporia
