With jury deadlocked, judge declares a mistrial in Lindsay Clancy's murder case
The judge has declared a mistrial in the case of Lindsay Clancy, the Massachusetts woman charged with murdering her three young children in 2023.
asserted
judge → deadlocke → 2023
This came after the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court denied the request of Clancy's defense attorney for an emergency appeal Friday.
asserted
Court → come → appeal
After deliberating for six days, the jury told the judge they could not reach a verdict because one juror did not agree with the 11 others.
uncertain
juror → deliberate → others
The judge said the jury's note read, as WBUR reported, "It is with a heavy heart that we report we are unable to come to a unanimous decision, and we will not be able to."
asserted
we → say → decision
Clancy, 36, was charged with strangling 5-year-old Cora, 3-year-old Dawson and 8-month-old Callan, in the family's home in Duxbury, Mass.
asserted
Clancy → charge → Duxbury
Her defense argued she should not be held criminally liable because she was suffering from severe postpartum psychosis at the time, an approach often called the insanity defense.
asserted
she → argue → time
The prosecution argued Clancy was well enough to plan and act with intention.
asserted
Clancy → argue → intention
After declaring the mistrial, Judge William Sullivan thanked the jury for how hard they worked on the case.
asserted
they → declare → case
"Each one of you knew how long the case was going to go.
asserted
case → know → you
You knew how difficult the case was going to be to listen to, facts wise.
asserted
case → know → ?
But still, you braced for that duty."
asserted
you → brace → duty
The district attorney will now decide whether to re-try the case.
asserted
attorney → decide → case
Clancy will remain in custody in a state hospital where she has been held for more than three years.
asserted
she → remain → years
In a press conference after the mistrial was declared, Plymouth County District Attorney Tim Cruz declined to say whether his office would pursue a retrial.
asserted
office → declare → retrial
He noted it had been an "emotional trial for everybody.
asserted
it → note → everybody
"But in the end, I bring it all back to the child victims in this case, Cora, Dawson, and Callen.
asserted
I → bring → case
This was, and has always been, about getting justice for those three little babies," he said.
asserted
he → get → babies
Speaking outside the court Friday, defense attorney Kevin Reddington praised Clancy for enduring in such a difficult situation.
asserted
Reddington → speak → situation
"It's not right what she had to go through because she grieves the loss of those three children," he told reporters.
asserted
he → have → reporters
"Every time somebody had something to say about those young kids, Lindsey would smile and say, 'I'm glad.'
asserted
I → have → kids
She wants them to be remembered."
asserted
them → want → ?
Reddington also said the jury's 11-1 split should make the prosecution rethink re-trying the case.
asserted
prosecution → say → case
"If I was Tim Cruz, I would probably say I don't think I want to do a retrial because he's going to lose," Reddington said.
asserted
Reddington → say → retrial
The Supreme Judicial Court heard an emergency appeal from Reddington in the case early Friday afternoon.
asserted
Court → hear → case
The appeal asked that the court either excuse the juror who was allegedly refusing to follow instructions or inquire further to determine whether the juror could in fact follow the judge's instructions to correctly apply the law.
uncertain
juror → ask → law
Clancy's lawyers wrote in the appeal that the holdout juror's "reasoning reflects a bias against those who suffer from debilitating mental illness."
asserted
who → write → illness
Reddington had asked Judge Sullivan to dismiss the holdout juror on Thursday.
asserted
Reddington → ask → Thursday
Reddington referenced two notes the jury foreperson sent the court about the juror, who, according to Reddington, admitted doubt but refused to join the other 11 jurors in finding Clancy not guilty.
uncertain
Clancy → reference → jurors
However, Judge Sullivan denied that request.
asserted
Sullivan → deny → request
He did however give the jury new instructions on the meaning of "reasonable doubt."
asserted
He → give → doubt
When asking the judge to give him time for an appeal on Friday, Reddington said of the holdout juror, "I believe that this is a situation where there is a clear and present danger that this individual, for some reason — what it is we don't know — but is taking a position that's intractable, regardless of proof beyond a reasonable doubt."
asserted
that → ask → doubt
Reddington also asked the judge to survey the jury to see if they could reach an agreement on a lesser charge, such as second-degree murder or manslaughter, before declaring a mistrial, so that Clancy couldn't be tried again for first-degree murder.
uncertain
Clancy → ask → murder
The judge denied that request as well.
asserted
judge → deny → request
Grueling weeks of testimony
In a trial that stretched over five weeks, included more than 80 witnesses and attracted international attention to the issue of postpartum mental health, jurors heard competing theories about Clancy's mental condition.
asserted
jurors → stretch → condition
While both sides agreed she was struggling, the key question under Massachusetts law was whether her mental state made her unable to tell right from wrong, or to follow the law, as WBUR reported.
asserted
WBUR → agree → law
Clancy's attorneys said she was in the grips of mental illness at the time of the killings.
asserted
she → say → killings
The defense called forensic psychologist Paul Zeizel, who testified that Clancy was experiencing postpartum psychosis, as NPR reported, noting that she said she heard a male voice ordering her to kill her children and herself.
asserted
she → call → children
She attempted suicide shortly after killing the children.
asserted
She → attempt → children
If you or someone you know may be considering suicide or be in crisis, call or text 988 to reach the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline.
They also noted that she sought medical help repeatedly, but they said she didn't receive effective care and was overmedicated.
uncertain
she → know → care
(Clancy and her ex-husband, Patrick Clancy, have filed separate medical malpractice suits against some of her health care providers.)
asserted
Clancy → file → providers
…and 21 more, not listed.
The Aporia
