Despite Trump's renaming of Lake Ontario, Great Lakes endure as symbol of U.S.-Canada collaboration
Renaming Lake Ontario may sound like a joke, but environmental threats to the Great Lakes are very real
The Great Lakes, one of the largest stores of freshwater and a source of water for some 40 million people, have long symbolized how closely intertwined Canada and the U.S. are.
U.S. President Donald Trump took a public sledgehammer to that relationship Thursday as part of his trade war with Canada, signing an executive order directing that Lake Ontario be renamed Lake America.
uncertain
Ontario → endure → America
It's unclear whether Trump can unilaterally rename the lake, whose name predates European colonization of the Americas and has been widely recognized internationally for centuries.
uncertain
name → rename → centuries
But the move comes amid a broader push by the Trump administration that has hindered U.S.-Canada collaboration on scientific research and restoration work in the Great Lakes.
asserted
that → come → Lakes
Scientists at U.S. weather forecasting agency ordered to get clearance before talking to Canadian counterparts
The U.S. is cutting billions from science.
asserted
U.S. → order → science
Canadian researchers say it's time to step up
"
asserted
it → say → ?
The way that this current administration in the United States views the environment and views science is demoralizing," said Aaron Fisk, professor at the Great Lakes Institute for Environmental Research at the University of Windsor.
asserted
Fisk → view → Windsor
"With the U.S. moving away from evidence-based decisions about the environment … that's a real concern to me because we need them to be a world leader.
asserted
them → move → me
This really goes against their long term investment in good science," he said.
asserted
he → go → science
As part of its massive cuts to the federal public service, the Trump administration has made major cuts to iconic U.S. scientific agencies such as the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration and the Environmental Protection Agency.
asserted
administration → make → Oceanic
Those cuts have, in turn, affected monitoring and research in the Great Lakes.
asserted
cuts → affect → Lakes
"The water does not respect political boundaries, and you have to manage it as a water body, as a watershed, not just as a national or state or provincial boundary," said Joel Brammeier, president and CEO of the Alliance for the Great Lakes, a U.S. non-profit that advocates for Great Lakes conservation and restoration.
asserted
that → respect → conservation
"Which is why it's always a bit painful when we see somebody out of the U.S. side challenging that collaboration.
asserted
somebody → see → collaboration
Because, honestly, the Great Lakes don't get cleaned up and they don't get protected unless the U.S. and Canada collaborate and co-operate.
asserted
U.S. → clean → ?
Bipartisan support saves key Great Lakes program
Even amid the cuts, support for the Great Lakes has crossed political lines.
asserted
support → save → lines
The Great Lakes Restoration Initiative, a two-decade-old program to restore ecosystems and clean up industrial pollution, was targeted for near-total elimination by Trump during his first administration.
asserted
Initiative → restore → administration
The U.S. House of Representatives voted to reauthorize the program through 2031, with nearly $500 million US in federal funding per year going to local communities in the region.
asserted
US → vote → region
The measure received both Democratic and Republican support and is now working its way through the U.S. Senate.
asserted
measure → receive → Senate
"There are few issues that unite political parties like the Great Lakes.
asserted
that → be → Lakes
The Great Lakes Restoration Initiative has been so successful in doing that," Brammeier said.
asserted
Brammeier → do → that
The Great Lakes region has been central to industrial growth in both the U.S. and Canada, Brammeier said, hosting major industries such as steel, chemical and aluminum manufacturing.
asserted
Brammeier → say → manufacturing
That growth has also left widespread industrial contamination that communities across the region want cleaned up.
asserted
communities → leave → region
"Even though a lot of damage was done across a large part of the Great Lakes, in an odd way that's actually led to this near universal support for the restoration program because so many decision-makers, so many members of Congress have seen the harm in their own communities," he said.
asserted
he → do → communities
Climate change brings new threats
asserted
change → bring → threats
Climate change is bringing extreme heat and shifting precipitation to the region, which researchers say requires close study on both sides of the border.
asserted
researchers → bring → border
Mike Shriberg, director of the University of Michigan's Water Center, said water availability and access are emerging challenges.
asserted
availability → say → challenges
We've had increasing drought and then increasing intensity of precipitation.
asserted
We → have → precipitation
So water flows have changed because of climate change," he said.
asserted
he → change → change
That, combined with future water demand from data centres, power generation and especially agriculture — which is expanding farther north as the climate warms — could create problems in the coming years.
uncertain
climate → combine → years
Shriberg also said he expects more people to move to the region from parts in the U.S. facing water shortages, particularly in the West, potentially putting further strain on the Great Lakes.
asserted
people → say → Lakes
Andrew Gronewold, professor at the University of Michigan, is also thinking about future demand.
asserted
Gronewold → think → demand
"I think we're going to face some very difficult choices and questions about how Great Lakes water is used," he said from Hamilton, Ont., where he was meeting with Canadian and First Nations research partners.
asserted
he → think → partners
Gronewold pointed to efforts by a group of Great Lakes state governors and premiers to "future-proof" the Great Lakes compact and agreement, a set of pacts among U.S. Great Lakes states, Ontario and Quebec governing how the water is used.
asserted
water → point → states
"I think over the next several decades, there's going to be increased pressure from outside of the basin for that water, whether it's for agriculture or industry or other uses.
asserted
it → think → agriculture
That's something that we need to be paying attention to," he said.
asserted
he → need → attention
The Aporia
