What will it take for the world's superpowers to agree on AI regulations in war?
asserted
superpowers → take → war
Diplomats to discuss autonomous weapons at a UN meeting this week, but experts say binding rules are unlikely
As the UN prepares to discuss autonomous weapons this week, insiders say hopes of meaningful, binding regulations around AI in warfare are slim — and time may be running out.
uncertain
time → discuss → warfare
Diplomats will discuss lethal autonomous weapons systems, including a possible framework for regulations, at a Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons meeting running Monday to Friday in Geneva, Switzerland.
asserted
Diplomats → discuss → Geneva
More than 100 countries that are party to the convention will be represented, including Canada, the U.S., Russia and China.
asserted
that → represent → Canada
UN Secretary-General António Guterres warned in August that the world was nearing a "moral red line" where autonomous weapons like AI-powered drones could kill without human involvement.
uncertain
weapons → warn → involvement
He's said he wants a legally binding treaty on autonomous weapons by the end of 2026 as AI increasingly becomes a factor in deadly strikes.
asserted
AI → say → strikes
Meanwhile, some experts say the use of AI to determine where and when to strike in the first place is an even more pressing concern than the weapons themselves.
asserted
use → say → weapons
But so far, the world's biggest military superpowers — including the U.S., Russia and China — have shot down any serious attempts at binding rules.
asserted
superpowers → include → rules
The age of AI warfare has dawned.
asserted
age → dawn → warfare
Military commander vows fast action on AI and robots, sees 'untapped potential' for Canada
Leaders are afraid of losing their competitive advantage because of the idea that "whoever wins the AI race will dominate the world," said Paul Lushenko, a senior fellow at Cornell University Tech Policy Institute and a retiring U.S. military officer.
asserted
Lushenko → vow → Institute
He says everyone he speaks to in the military recognizes the moral implications of AI.
asserted
he → say → AI
At the same time, the prevailing consensus among the most powerful militaries is that even if they follow a set of rules, they can't trust their competitors to do the same, creating a Cold War-esque stalemate.
asserted
they → prevail → stalemate
"That's a really challenging position to be in," he said.
asserted
he → say → ?
Paul Lushenko, senior fellow at Cornell University Tech Policy Institute, says the world's military superpowers worry that if they follow regulations around AI, their competitors won't do the same.
asserted
competitors → say → same
Lushenko said he does not expect any kind of "bona fide international policy" or regulation to come out of this week's meetings.
asserted
kind → say → meetings
About one-third of the countries that attended a February military AI summit in Spain, including Canada, agreed to a declaration on how to govern use of the technology in warfare, but the U.S. and China were among those that opted out.
asserted
that → attend → those
UN diplomats were negotiating a treaty in September to regulate the use of lethal autonomous weapons when U.S. and Russian diplomats cut out key safety provisions on the final day.
asserted
diplomats → negotiate → day
According to reporting by the Washington Post, those provisions included language that would have required systems to operate in a predictable and reliable manner, mandated ethical considerations and required that humans review military targets picked by AI before striking.
AI in action
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy, addressing the UN in September, warned there is a "real possibility" that AI will soon begin to decide what happens on the battlefield.
"We need peace before we reach that point," he said.
uncertain
he → accord → point
Ukraine and Russia are both increasingly using AI to gain advantages in battle as the war between the two countries approaches its fifth year.
asserted
war → use → year
In August, the New York Times reported that a Russian drone operated entirely by AI killed three Ukrainian civilians.
asserted
drone → report → civilians
- FRONT BURNER
Israel accused of using AI to choose Gaza targets
Drones and AI are rewriting the rulebook on naval warfare — with uncertain consequences
In one of the most prominent examples of AI-assisted targeting, Israeli intelligence officers described to Israeli-Palestinian publication +972 Magazine and the Hebrew-language outlet Local Call how the military's Lavender AI system allegedly identified 37,000 targets in Gaza, with one saying soldiers had about 20 seconds to review each target before they carried out a strike.
uncertain
they → accuse → strike
The U.S. has since made a major push to ramp up AI use, with the Pentagon declaring the country's military an "AI-first fighting force."
asserted
military → make → use
The U.S. used Anthropic's Claude chatbot to help identify nearly 1,000 targets in the first 24 hours of its war with Iran in February.
asserted
U.S. → use → February
After a U.S. missile strike on a girls' school in Minab, American senators raised concerns over the use of AI tools, including Palantir's Maven Smart System, in target selection.
asserted
senators → raise → selection
Those concerns did not deter the military.
asserted
concerns → deter → military
In June, Cameron Stanley, chief digital and artificial intelligence officer for the department of defence, said Elon Musk's Grok chatbot had been used to launch thousands of missiles at Iran.
asserted
chatbot → say → Iran
The frequency of AI-assisted targeting in Gaza and Iran has raised concerns from experts who worry that even though a human technically may have the final say before strikes are made, that human could effectively serve as a rubber stamp.
uncertain
human → assist → stamp
'Dystopian future'
Craig Martin, a former Canadian navy officer and an expert in armed conflict laws who teaches at Washburn University in Topeka, Kan, also worries about automation bias, whereby humans tend to become overly confident in AI's accuracy and validity.
"This may have been the case in the ... use of Lavender in Gaza, similarly the incident of the strike on the school in Minab by the United States," he told CBC News.
uncertain
he → teach → News
Craig Martin, a former Canadian navy officer and an expert in armed conflict laws, would like to see a ban on fully autonomous weapons.
asserted
Martin → like → weapons
Martin is calling for changes to international law that would ban fully autonomous weapons and restrict semi-autonomous weapons.
asserted
that → call → weapons
He says he has hope for some form of agreement on AI, but it "would be a mistake to say that one is extremely optimistic," given that international law is in "a bit of a crisis right now."
"My greatest fear would be that we miss this window of opportunity and we increasingly develop weapons that are governed by AI over which we have little control and often little understanding and no legal regime that's governing those weapon systems," he said.
asserted
he → say → systems
"It could lead to some kind of dystopian future."
uncertain
It → lead → future
- Analysis
NATO's race against time: Senior commander warns alliance must adapt faster to deter Russia
- Analysis
Why a new round in the U.S.-Iran conflict could be the most devastating yet
Lushenko says his concerns extend to nuclear weapons.
uncertain
concerns → warn → weapons
While noting that AI offers the possibility of built-in deterrents and has potential to reduce human error and civilian casualties, he says war games conducted in research programs have found AI chatbots tend to rapidly escalate to suggesting the use of nukes in evolving crises between powerful countries.
asserted
chatbots → note → countries
Fears of escalation
The fear among major powers of being left behind is driving a "race to the bottom," said Branka Marijan, senior fellow at the Centre for International Governance Innovation and senior researcher with anti-war organization Project Ploughshares.
asserted
Marijan → leave → Ploughshares
"Without those guardrails we really, I think, are in a very dangerous moment," she said.
asserted
she → think → moment
Branka Marijan, senior fellow at the Centre for International Governance Innovation and senior researcher with Project Ploughshares, says the world is in a 'dangerous moment' without guardrails around AI in war.
asserted
world → say → war
Marijan says what keeps her up at night is not necessarily the sheer destruction that could be caused by autonomous weapons or by AI selecting targets in the midst of an ongoing war, but mistakes that could cause an international incident to escalate into a full-blown crisis.
uncertain
incident → say → crisis
CNN reported in September that the U.S. military almost boarded a Chinese vessel in the Middle East because an AI chatbot mistakenly said the ship was carrying nuclear materials.
asserted
ship → report → materials
Marijan says incidents like that "are likely to keep occurring" and next time, the military might not put the brakes on soon enough.
uncertain
military → say → brakes
…and 1 more, not listed.