What Trump’s focus on an oil pipeline says about Canada-U.S. trade
About 85 to 90 per cent of Canada's crude oil exports go directly to the United States
U.S. President Donald Trump says a Canada-U.S. oil pipeline project cancelled by two of his predecessors "may be awoken from the grave" under a new bilateral trade agreement between the neighbouring nations.
uncertain
project → say → nations
But a former executive involved with Keystone XL and other industry experts suggest the remark may have more to do with politics than petroleum.
uncertain
remark → involve → petroleum
In a social media post late Tuesday, less than two hours before punishing new levies on Canadian goods entering the U.S. were due to start, Trump announced a "deal" with Canada and a three-day halt on new tariffs.
asserted
Trump → punish → tariffs
"The great Keystone XL Pipeline, long ago killed by Sleepy Joe Biden, may be awoken from the grave!" he wrote in a post on his Truth Social platform, referring to his predecessor in the White House.
uncertain
he → kill → House
Prime Minister Mark Carney did not address this in a statement responding to Trump’s post.
asserted
Carney → address → post
"The fact that Trump has signalled that is something that he sees in the deal, I think is helpful to Carney [and] the trade-offs he's going to have to make over the next 72 hours," said Dennis McConaghy, former executive vice-president of corporate development at TransCanada Corporation, now called TC Energy.
asserted
McConaghy → signal → Corporation
From auto parts and lumber to steel and aluminum, the Republican president has targeted key sectors of Canada's economy since Feb. 1, 2025, when his administration announced sweeping tariffs on goods from Canada.
Since then, he has regularly stated that the U.S. does not need anything that Canada has, even as key items like oil, potash and critical minerals have stayed exempt from U.S. tariffs.
asserted
items → target → tariffs
"In the context of a person who says we don't need anything from Canada, that [Keystone XL remark] was somewhat welcome," McConaghy said.
asserted
McConaghy → say → Canada
However, Carlo Dade, director of international policy at the University of Calgary's School of Public Policy, told CBC Radio's Calgary Eyeopener that a revival of the controversial project would face familiar political and environmental challenges today.
asserted
revival → tell → challenges
"Let's not get too excited about Keystone just yet," Dade said on Wednesday.
asserted
Dade → get → Wednesday
"Will it be done by the end of his term?
asserted
it → do → term
Because we potentially have Democrats ... in the offing, which is going to make this extremely difficult," he said.
asserted
he → have → offing
"He looks at this as a rejection of the policies of previous administrations, Biden, Democrats, et cetera."
asserted
He → look → administrations
Valérie Beaudoin, a member of the federal government's Advisory Committee on Canada-U.S. Economic Relations, said greenlighting Keystone XL will be far easier for Carney than Trump.
asserted
greenlighting → say → Trump
"For them, it can be a nightmare," she said.
asserted
she → say → them
"Even if Trump says, 'Oh, Keystone XL is back on track,' who is going to want to invest when we know in 2028, the next president can be a Democrat?"
asserted
president → say → 2028
"It's all definitely meant as a retort to Biden," Commodity Context founder Rory Johnston told CBC News in an email.
asserted
Johnston → mean → email
"[It] would be completely out of the blue, and make little immediate sense, to literally reanimate KXL given the work done on the other projects thus far.
asserted
It → make → projects
[It's] also a much different market from when KXL was initially proposed."
asserted
KXL → propose → ?
Ottawa revives interest in Keystone XL
asserted
Ottawa → revive → XL
About 85 to 90 per cent of Canada's crude oil exports go directly to the U.S., down slightly since the 2024 expansion of the Trans Mountain pipeline, which ships to Asian and other non-U.S. markets from terminals on the West Coast.
asserted
which → go → Coast
Owned and operated by Calgary-based South Bow Corp., the 4,327-kilometre Keystone Pipeline System delivers Canadian and U.S. crude oil to American refining markets in Illinois, Oklahoma and Texas.
asserted
System → own → Illinois
South Bow did not respond to a request for comment on Wednesday.
asserted
Bow → respond → Wednesday
In 2008, TransCanada and ConocoPhillips, the owners of Keystone at the time, proposed a major extension to the network called Keystone XL.
asserted
TransCanada → propose → network
After years of political, legal and environmental opposition, including cancellation by the Obama and Biden administrations in the U.S., the project was effectively abandoned by its backers.
asserted
project → include → backers
When he returned to the White House in 2025, Trump rescinded Biden's revocation order and granted approvals to revive sections of the project in the U.S.
asserted
Trump → return → U.S.
Since then, he's openly praised the project's merits on multiple occasions.
asserted
he → praise → occasions
Last fall, CBC News reported that Carney raised the project with Trump, expressing his renewed interest in advancing Keystone XL.
asserted
Carney → report → XL
The project remains fully permitted by the Canadian government.
asserted
project → permit → government
By 2021, about 150 kilometres of pipe were installed in Alberta.
asserted
kilometres → instal → Alberta
Prairie Connector project
South Bow was created in 2024, when TC Energy spun off its oil pipeline business in a pivot toward natural gas.
asserted
Energy → create → gas
The company is currently working with Wyoming-based midstream firm Bridger Pipeline on a project called Prairie Connector using parts of the cancelled Keystone XL pipeline previously built on the Canadian side of the border.
asserted
company → work → border
If built, the Prairie Connector project could increase Canada's crude exports to the U.S. by more than 12 per cent.
uncertain
project → build → cent
"If this project were to be built, it adds substantial value," said former TransCanada executive McConaghy.
asserted
McConaghy → build → value
South Bow CEO Bevin Wirzba has touted brisk long-term U.S. demand for Canadian crude, citing the company’s recent open-season process for Prairie Connector.
asserted
Wirzba → tout → Connector
The company says this yielded 20-year binding commitments from nine customers, totalling 465,000 barrels of oil per day of firm transportation service from Hardisty, Alta., to South Bow’s U.S. delivery points.
asserted
this → say → points
South Bow has yet to issue a final investment decision on the project.
asserted
Bow → have → project
"Disruptions to global crude oil trade drove increased demand for connectivity to refining and export markets,” Wirzba told stock market analysts on a post-earnings conference call on Aug. 5.
asserted
Wirzba → drive → Aug.
"And we've consistently said that the demand in the Gulf Coast for Canadian crude into that refining market was and is and will be resilient for decades to come."
asserted
demand → say → decades
The Aporia
