Will Ottawa really take Stelco to court?
asserted
Ottawa → take → court
Here's what happened last time
2009 was 'only time Ottawa has gone to court over commitments like this,' lawyer says
Stelco Holdings has days to share a plan to save hundreds of Ontario steel workers from layoffs already underway — or it risks legal action from the Canadian government.
The clock is ticking on what lawyers say is a test of how foreign investors are held to account as Prime Minister Mark Carney seeks to lure more of them to Canada amid a bitter trade war with the United States.
asserted
Carney → happen → States
And is it likely to save workers' jobs?
asserted
it → save → jobs
Here's what we know from the last time the federal government took the U.S. steelmaker to court.
2 decades since Ottawa fought ex-Stelco owner in court
In 2007, Pennsylvania-based U.S. Steel announced a deal to acquire Stelco, then a publicly-traded company, for about $1-billion US, and the company was renamed U.S. Steel Canada.
Major foreign investments must benefit the domestic economy, per the Investment Canada Act.
asserted
investments → know → Act
So, foreign buyers must give legally binding written commitments — called undertakings — to the federal industry minister to prove the deal provides a "net benefit to Canada."
asserted
deal → give → Canada
At the time, U.S. Steel agreed to several such undertakings, including a three-year commitments to maintain Canadian employment levels, and increase steel production in Canada by at least 10 per cent.
asserted
Steel → agree → cent
However, when the 2008 financial crisis sapped global demand, U.S. Steel closed most of Stelco's Canadian operations and laid off over 1,500 employees.
asserted
Steel → sap → employees
The Attorney General of Canada filed a lawsuit against U.S. Steel in July 2009.
asserted
General → file → July
"As far as the public record shows, it is the only time Ottawa has gone to court over commitments like this," Toronto-based business lawyer Nassira El Hadri told CBC News.
asserted
Hadri → show → News
According to a summary of court filings compiled by a lawyer at Toronto-based Torys LLP, Stelco argued the undertakings only required compliance at the end of their three-year term, not before.
uncertain
undertakings → accord → term
Stelco also said that per Industry Canada guidelines its investors should not be held accountable for factors beyond their control, like the unfolding financial crisis.
asserted
investors → say → crisis
Last legal battle ended in deal to keep making steel
The Attorney General of Canada formally withdrew the lawsuit in late 2011, ending in an out-court-settlement before the court could make a judgment.
uncertain
court → end → judgment
U.S. Steel agreed to keep production alive in Hamilton and Lake Erie, and to make $50 million in new capital investments by the end of 2015 to modernize its operations.
asserted
Steel → agree → operations
It agreed to new undertakings with Ottawa, but those did not include minimum worker headcount requirements.
asserted
those → agree → requirements
But before then, in 2014, U.S. Steel Canada filed for creditor protection, and the American parent company severed ties with its Canadian operations.
asserted
company → file → operations
In 2016, a New York-based private equity firm acquired the steelmaker.
asserted
firm → base → steelmaker
The Stelco name was revived when the company returned to the Toronto Stock Exchange the next year.
asserted
company → revive → Exchange
The dispute prompted updates to the Investment Canada Act in 2009 and 2012 to make settlement negotiations easier, and strengthen enforcement.
asserted
negotiations → prompt → enforcement
The government later raised daily non-compliance fines to $25,000, and tightened reviews for sensitive industries.
asserted
government → raise → industries
What's happening now at Stelco?
asserted
What → happen → Stelco
Flash forward to 2024, when Ottawa approved Ohio-based Cleveland-Cliffs' $3.4-billion cash-and-stock deal to buy Stelco.
asserted
Ottawa → flash → Stelco
The conditions included a promise to maintain at least the same number of unionized employees in Canada for five years, as well as the vast majority of non-unionized workers, according to a government statement at the time.
uncertain
conditions → include → time
Last week, Stelco announced a plan to idle certain production in Hamilton, resulting in up to 500 layoffs company-wide.
asserted
Stelco → announce → layoffs
The union says layoffs are already underway.
asserted
layoffs → say → ?
Cleveland-Cliffs CEO Lourenco Goncalves said the cuts are necessary and justified by the Canada-U.S. trade war, arguing that Stelco's ability to sell steel to the U.S. was an "underlying condition" of the deal.
But in a letter Monday to Stelco president Paul Simon, Industry Minister Mélanie Joly gave Stelco five business days to share a job plan, or face legal action.
And on Tuesday, Joly slammed Goncalves's public support of American steel tariffs.
asserted
Joly → say → tariffs
"He's in favour of these U.S. tariffs against steel," she said.
asserted
she → say → steel
"They cannot say that this is now an act of God or force majeure."
Will Stelco fight Ottawa in court again?
asserted
Stelco → say → court
El Hadri says the matter is "most likely going to end up in court."
asserted
matter → say → court
She points out that Joly's letter does not ask Stelco and Cleveland-Cliffs for an explanation about why they plan to lay off workers.
asserted
they → point → workers
It states the company's commitments "do not cease to apply simply because business strategy or market conditions have changed.
asserted
strategy → state → ?
"
"It may end up in a settlement as well, but it all depends on the economic conditions, like what's going on inside Stelco," El Hadri told CBC News.
The court has "wide powers" at its disposal, she said, including putting a business up for sale.
uncertain
she → end → sale
"We could end up with new commitments, which is what happened with Stelco in 2009."
uncertain
what → end → 2009
- Video
Joly: Stelco must provide plan to keep jobs within 5 days
- Video
Layoff uncertainty 'a roller-coaster' for Stelco workers
Sandy Walker, co-chair of the competition and foreign investment review group at the global law firm Dentons, says it's still possible that Stelco could reverse course on its full layoff plans to avoid going to court.
uncertain
Stelco → provide → court
"That depends on how effective the Canadian government’s threats are," she said told CBC News.
asserted
she → depend → News
"There are many reasons why [it] may not end up in court, but may end up with a variation of its undertakings, or otherwise settling with the Canadian government."
uncertain
it → be → government
At the same time, Walker says those Industry Canada guidelines on factors beyond a company's control may let Stelco "off the hook" to some extent.
uncertain
Stelco → say → extent
What does this mean for PM's agenda?
asserted
this → mean → agenda
Both Walker and El Hadri agree the timing is somewhat awkward, given Ottawa's push for $1-trillion worth of investments across the country over the next five years.
asserted
timing → agree → years
Last month, Carney hosted hundreds of deep-pocketed investors at an investment summit in Toronto in a bid to spur deals, and cut reliance on the United States.
asserted
Carney → host → States
"We are giving a signal to the world that ... you have to respect our rules," El Hadri said.
asserted
Hadri → give → rules
…and 2 more, not listed.
The Aporia
