FOLLOWING its submission for parliamentary approval, Turkish state broadcaster TRT Haber and other outlets have published the text of the Makkah Joint Defence agreement.
asserted
Haber → follow → agreement
The 16 articles of the trilateral defence agreement are reproduced here.
asserted
articles → reproduce → agreement
The Government of the Republic of Turkiye, the Government of the Islamic Republic of Pakistan, and the Government of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia (hereinafter referred to as a “party”, the “parties”, or the “core parties”).
Article 1: The “parties” shall cooperate to ensure and safeguard one another’s independence, sovereignty, territorial integrity, and the inviolability of their internationally recognised borders.
asserted
parties → refer → borders
If the territorial integrity, sovereignty, or internationally recognised borders of any of the “parties” are threatened or endangered, the “parties” shall use all necessary means to eliminate such threat(s) or danger(s).
asserted
parties → recognise → threat(s
Article 2: An externally originating armed attack against any of the “parties” shall be considered an attack against all the “parties.”
asserted
attack → originate → parties
If one of the “parties” is subjected to an armed attack or military aggression by another country or group of countries, the “parties” shall immediately assist the attacked “party,” making full use of all means of mutual assistance that they can provide to one another.
asserted
they → subject → one
For this purpose, to enable the exercise of the right of self-defence recognised by Article 51 of the Charter of the United Nations, the “parties” shall determine the scope and nature of the support to be provided following an objective assessment of the assistance required, and shall cooperate within the limits of their available resources, including military means and capabilities.
asserted
parties → enable → means
Article 3: Pursuant to Article 2 of this agreement, the “parties” shall cooperate closely in the fields of defence, defence industry, and security; develop relations among their Armed Forces; and carry out agreed activities aimed at strengthening cooperation in defence.
asserted
parties → cooperate → defence
Article 4: The “parties” shall hold regular consultations on international security matters.
asserted
parties → hold → matters
They shall continuously and effectively assist one another and cooperate in developing individual and joint measures based on common assessments, in order to protect their vital interests and national security and eliminate threats and dangers to their national security.
asserted
They → assist → security
Article 5: The “parties” shall strengthen existing cooperation and joint efforts, including at the operational level, in combating terrorism in all its forms and manifestations that adversely affect regional and international stability and security.
asserted
that → strengthen → stability
Article 6: In wartime and peacetime, the “parties” shall encourage reciprocal personnel exchanges among defence institutions, joint training programmes and exercises, and deployments and activities aimed at increasing the interoperability of the “parties’” armed forces, in order to develop their defence capabilities.
asserted
parties → encourage → capabilities
Article 7: To strengthen their defence capabilities, the “parties” shall, on the basis of mutual agreement, support technology sharing among defence-industry institutions, joint technology development, joint production, and cooperation among defence-industry organisations in the following areas:
a) Encouraging joint production in the field of defence;
b) Implementing defence innovation through joint research and development projects in technologies requiring specialised expertise;
c) Training personnel and supporting the military industry within the territories of the “parties” through experts from any “party”;
d) Sharing expertise and lessons learned in the fields of defence industry, defence research and development, and innovation;
e) Other areas of cooperation mutually agreed upon by the “parties”.
Article 8:
-
The “core parties” shall establish a “Strategic Political and Defence Committee”, comprising the Foreign Ministers, Defence Ministers, and Chiefs of General Staff of the “parties” to provide strategic direction for joint defence, develop defence and security cooperation among the “parties” and address obstacles that may arise during the implementation of this agreement.
uncertain
that → strengthen → agreement
The Committee shall meet twice a year, with hosting rotating among the “parties”.
asserted
hosting → meet → parties
The leaders of the “parties” may meet once a year if deemed necessary.
uncertain
leaders → meet → parties
-
The “Strategic Political and Defence Committee” may establish subcommittees if it considers this necessary.
uncertain
this → establish → subcommittees
-
Agreements or protocols shall, where necessary, be negotiated among the “parties” for the implementation of the areas of cooperation envisaged in this agreement.
asserted
Agreements → negotiate → agreement
-
The “Strategic Political and Defence Committee” shall be authorised, by consensus of the “core parties”, to determine and approve the procedures and principles governing the accession of other “parties” to this agreement.
asserted
Committee → authorise → agreement
-
A Secretariat headquartered in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia shall be established to serve the “Strategic Political and Defence Committee”.
asserted
Secretariat → headquarter → Committee
The Secretariat shall conclude a headquarters agreement with the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia.
asserted
Secretariat → conclude → Arabia
The procedures and principles governing the Secretariat’s functioning, organisational structure, and establishment shall subsequently be determined by consensus of the “core parties”.
asserted
procedures → govern → parties
-
The Secretariat shall be headed by a Secretary-General appointed for a three-year term on a rotational basis among the “core parties”.
asserted
Secretariat → head → parties
The first Secretary-General shall be a citizen of the Islamic Republic of Pakistan.
-
The provisions of this Article shall not prejudice the work of existing military cooperation committees among the “parties”.
Article 9: To deepen cooperation in intelligence and provide the necessary coordination in this regard, the “parties” shall share intelligence through mutually agreed secure channels, while observing information security, data protection and confidentiality.
asserted
parties → prejudice → security
Article 10: Subject to the availability and compatibility of logistical support services, the “parties” shall provide one another with logistical support in peacetime, wartime, and other emergencies, including weapons, ammunition, fuel, spare parts, and other equipment.
asserted
parties → provide → weapons
Article 11: Without prejudice to international law and the relevant domestic laws of the “parties”, the “parties” shall accept this agreement as the legal basis for implementing its provisions and shall propose additional legal measures where necessary.
asserted
parties → accept → measures
Article 12: This agreement shall not prejudice the rights and obligations of the “parties” arising from international agreements they have previously concluded.
asserted
they → prejudice → agreements
Article 13:
-
The “parties” shall respect the confidentiality of classified information and documents obtained under this agreement and shall respect national legislation.
asserted
parties → respect → legislation
-
Classified information and documents shall not be shared with any state, company, or person outside the “parties”.
asserted
information → share → parties
-
Access to classified information and documents shall be provided on a “need-to-know” basis and only to persons holding the appropriate level of security clearance.
Article 14:
asserted
Access → provide → clearance
Any dispute arising from the interpretation or implementation of this agreement shall be settled amicably through consultations and discussions among the “parties”.
asserted
dispute → arise → parties
Article 15: This agreement may be amended through consultations and unanimous agreement among the “core parties”.
uncertain
agreement → amend → parties
Article 16:
-
This agreement shall be ratified in accordance with the procedures applicable to each “party” and shall enter into force on the date on which the final instrument of ratification is deposited with the Secretariat of the “Strategic Political and Defence Committee”.
asserted
instrument → ratify → Committee
-
This agreement shall remain in force indefinitely.
asserted
agreement → remain → force
-
Any “party” may withdraw from this agreement after 10 years have elapsed from its entry into force, by giving the other “parties” written notification of its intention to withdraw through diplomatic channels at least three months in advance.
uncertain
years → withdraw → advance
-
Termination of this agreement or withdrawal from it shall not affect any ongoing activities or projects agreed upon by the “parties” before the date of termination or withdrawal.
-
The responsibilities of the “parties” concerning the protection of classified information and documents and the prevention of their disclosure shall continue after termination of this agreement or withdrawal from it.
asserted
responsibilities → affect → it
This agreement has been signed in three original copies in the Turkish, Arabic, and English languages, each text being equally authentic.
asserted
text → sign → languages
In the event of a difference in interpretation between the texts, the English text shall prevail.
asserted
text → prevail → texts
The Aporia
