Judges may face unprecedented decisions this election.
uncertain
Judges → face → decisions
A new guide seeks to help
asserted
guide → seek → ?
The idea of federal law enforcement seizing ballots in the middle of an active election would have once been considered impossible.
asserted
enforcement → seize → election
Now, as President Trump continues his unprecedented hunt for voter fraud, ballot seizures and search warrants are scenarios voting officials and the legal community are actively preparing for.
asserted
officials → continue → fraud
One state election official, who did not have permission to speak publicly, told NPR their office has led three separate statewide trainings this year to prepare for the possibility of law enforcement seeking to take possession of ballots or election materials while the election is ongoing.
asserted
election → have → ballots
And UCLA's Safeguarding Democracy Project released a guide Wednesday, shared first with NPR, to help judges navigate search warrant affidavits related to the voting process.
asserted
judges → release → process
"Lots of things that were off the table are now on the table," said Rick Hasen, the director of the Safeguarding Democracy Project, and the guide's lead author.
asserted
Hasen → say → Project
Trump has said he regrets not pushing harder for the federal government to seize election equipment after the 2020 election.
asserted
government → say → election
Already this year, two different search warrants, executed in Fulton County, Ga., and Riverside County, Calif., involved the seizure of ballots.
asserted
warrants → execute → ballots
All that has voting officials preparing for different worst case scenarios this fall.
asserted
officials → have → scenarios
"This is the thing we really fear," the state voting official, whose state has conducted the trainings, said in a previous interview with NPR.
asserted
state → fear → NPR
"[Say] we have really close races [in our competitive districts] then the DOJ, FBI come knocking on one of our county doors and they say, 'We believe there's hijinks going on, we're going to confiscate all the ballots so we can count them.'
asserted
we → say → them
"
If a warrant were served and ballots were seized before an election is certified, it's possible voting officials wouldn't be able to confidently know how many ballots were returned, or whether the ones that were seized were tampered with.
asserted
that → serve → ?
In elections, this is known as breaking the chain of custody.
asserted
this → know → custody
"They could do so much damage if they did that," the official said.
uncertain
official → do → that
Legal experts say it is still an extreme and unlikely scenario.
asserted
it → say → ?
Notably because there is a last line of defense that must sign off on any attempt to seize ballots: a judge.
asserted
that → be → ballots
"Right now, the judiciary writ large has their antennae up, anticipating what might be coming down the pike," said retired federal judge Philip Pro, who served as the chief judge for the District of Nevada.
uncertain
who → have → Nevada
"They're going to be prepared."
asserted
They → go → ?
The warrant executed at the elections office in Fulton County, Ga., was a wake-up call for the legal community not solely because it happened, but because how it was approved.
asserted
it → execute → community
"Eventually we got to see the search warrant and it confirmed some of our worst fears," said Hasen.
asserted
Hasen → get → fears
"It contained information about potential fraud in Georgia that was based on discredited conspiracy theories."
asserted
that → contain → theories
Magistrate judges, who are generally the ones dealing with warrant affidavits, are not experts in elections, Hasen said, which means this fall, they could also find themselves wading through dubious claims at a time when misinformation is rampant.
uncertain
misinformation → deal → time
Therefore, one of the UCLA guide's recommendations to judges is not to go it alone.
asserted
one → go → it
"One of our key recommendations is to bring election administrators into the conversation," Hasen said.
asserted
Hasen → bring → conversation
The process for requesting and granting warrants typically happens in secret, without public hearing or testimony, which limits the court's ability to scrutinize requests, said retired Judge Maureen O'Connor, who served as Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of Ohio.
asserted
who → request → Ohio
But in the case of an ongoing election, transparency should be prioritized, she said.
asserted
she → prioritize → election
"This isn't something that the judge has to just look the officer in the eye and say, 'yeah, I think I can trust him,'" O'Connor said.
asserted
O'Connor → have → him
"That deserves to be discussed in a courtroom on the record, with the judge asking questions of witnesses under oath and determining then, by the totality of the circumstances, whether there should be a warrant issued."
asserted
judge → deserve → circumstances
Both O'Connor, and retired Judge Pro of Nevada, are members of Keep Our Republic, a nonprofit organization aimed at supporting democracy and the rule of law, and one of the many civil society groups working to prepare for potential federal interference this year.
asserted
O'Connor → retire → interference
"[Judges] are going to be looking behind the curtain rather than simply relying on what is presented [in the affidavit] as being gospel," said Judge Pro.
asserted
Pro → go → affidavit
In putting out the guide, Hasen wanted to emphasize to judges the gravity of signing off on a warrant during an active election and breaking the chain of custody.
asserted
Hasen → put → custody
He pointed to a case in Michigan where the chain of custody was broken for just a few dozen ballots in 2025, and the result of that mayoral race — decided by 11 votes — is still in dispute.
asserted
result → point → dispute
Voting officials worry a controversy like that could escalate to chaos if it were in a House or Senate race that decides the balance of power in Congress.
uncertain
that → worry → Congress
"We want judges to understand you can't unscramble the egg," Hasen said.
asserted
Hasen → want → egg
"Once the ballots have been taken out of the custody of election officials, there are at least going to be conspiracy theories that ballots have been altered or added to or removed."
asserted
ballots → take → officials
The UCLA guide lays out a number of alternatives judges should consider if law enforcement requests access to ballots, including waiting until after certification to execute any warrant, considering whether copies or reproductions could satisfy the government's investigative needs, or allowing law enforcement to observe tabulation or a recount instead.
uncertain
enforcement → lay → tabulation
The guide also lays out procedures a court should follow if a warrant is granted, but Hasen said he hopes once a judge considers all their options, it doesn't come to that.
"Because
asserted
it → lay → that
, if that does happen," Hasen said, "are really second-best solutions."
asserted
Hasen → happen → ?
