As much as a candy bar, claims lawsuit
U.S. lawsuit says coffee chain falsely advertised eight protein beverages as 'sugar-free'
It's fair to say you probably have some idea what you're in for, sugar-wise, when you order a pumpkin spice latte or caramel macchiato from Starbucks.
uncertain
you → claim → Starbucks
But what should you expect if you're ordering a drink that's labelled "sugar-free?"
asserted
that → expect → drink
That's the question behind a proposed U.S. class-action lawsuit that claims the coffee chain falsely advertised eight protein beverages as "sugar-free," when they actually contain between 13 and 21 grams of sugar per venti-size serving due to the naturally occurring sugar in milk.
uncertain
they → propose → milk
The lawsuit, filed Friday in a Seattle federal court and viewed by CBC News, accuses Starbucks of trying to capitalize on "the protein craze" and nutritional preferences of customers.
asserted
lawsuit → file → customers
"By naming its beverages 'Sugar-Free,' Starbucks makes a specific, quantitative and verifiable claim about the nature of these beverages.
uncertain
Starbucks → name → beverages
Consumers rely upon such claims when deciding to purchase such products," the lawsuit says
"The 21 grams of sugar contained in a venti Sugar-Free Caramel Protein Matcha is roughly equal to five teaspoons of sugar.
uncertain
grams → rely → sugar
This is almost as much total sugar as is contained in a standard Kit Kat bar."
asserted
This → contain → bar
A screen grab of an Instagram post by Starbucks from Oct. 23, 2025, that advertises some protein beverages as sugar-free.
asserted
that → advertise → beverages
A spokesperson for Starbucks told CBC News Wednesday they believe the lawsuit's claims have "no merit."
"
uncertain
claims → tell → merit
Starbucks has consistently and clearly provided information about its protein beverages, sugar-free options, customization choices and nutritional content ... and we intend to vigorously defend ourselves," the spokesperson said.
asserted
spokesperson → provide → ourselves
Let's take a closer look at the lawsuit and what we know.
asserted
we → let → what
The lawsuit lists eight protein beverages that Starbucks labels as sugar-free:
- Sugar-free vanilla protein latte.
- Sugar-free caramel protein latte.
- Sugar-free vanilla protein matcha.
- Sugar-free caramel protein matcha.
- Iced sugar-free vanilla protein latte.
asserted
Starbucks → list → latte
And while the eight drinks are listed under a "no added sugar options" heading, each beverage currently has "sugar-free" in its title.
asserted
beverage → list → title
Starbucks launched the beverages in September 2025, citing statistics claiming that "71 per cent of Canadian consumers want to eat more protein."
asserted
cent → launch → protein
In a news release at the time, Starbucks noted its new protein drinks will be "available unsweetened or sugar-free and are designed to support customers looking to add protein to their order.
asserted
drinks → note → order
No, each beverage contains sugar — anywhere between 13 and 21 grams per venti-size serving.
asserted
beverage → contain → serving
At the higher end, that's about equivalent to the grams of sugar in a KitKat or Coffee Crisp chocolate bar, according to Health Canada.
uncertain
that → accord → Canada
When you click through the individual drinks on the company website, Starbucks lists nutritional information for each "sugar-free" protein beverage, including the grams of sugar by size.
asserted
Starbucks → click → size
A venti iced sugar-free vanilla protein latte, for instance, is listed as containing 13 grams of sugar, and a venti sugar-free caramel protein matcha has 21 grams of sugar.
asserted
matcha → list → sugar
As the lawsuit points out, "the sugar-free products all contain milk, which contains lactose, a naturally occurring sugar.
asserted
which → point → lactose
"
Whey up: Protein powder prices soar as global demand grows
asserted
demand → whey → ?
Is it unprofessional to bring iced coffee to a job interview?
asserted
it → bring → interview
Gen Z is being dragged for it
If it's natural sugar, what's the issue?
asserted
issue → drag → it
The issue isn't where the sugar comes from, but the sugar-free labelling, the lawsuit argues.
asserted
lawsuit → come → where
"Despite knowing that Sugar-Free products contain milk, and knowing that this milk contains lactose, and knowing that this lactose is a sugar, and despite actually classifying this lactose as a sugar, Starbucks nonetheless calls these beverages 'Sugar-Free,'" the lawsuit says.
"Starbucks calls these beverages 'Fugar-Free' because it knows that consumers rely on such representations when deciding what products to purchase."
What are the consumer protection laws?
U.S. federal law prohibits Starbucks from using "sugar-free" to describe beverages containing more than 0.5 grams of sugar per 12-ounce serving, the complaint said.
asserted
complaint → know → serving
Even if the sugar comes from milk.
asserted
sugar → come → milk
Similarly, in Canada, for something to be labelled as sugar-free, the food must contain less than 0.5 grams of sugars per reference amount and serving of stated size, according to the Food and Drug Regulations.
uncertain
food → label → Regulations
In both countries, there's a difference between labelling something as "sugar-free," like Starbucks has done with the protein drink names, or as having "no added sugars," which is how Starbucks also describes the drinks in the nutritional information because it uses sugar-free syrups.
asserted
it → be → syrups
Lactose is listed as a sugar in both Canada and the U.S.
Food producers are regularly sued for alleged false advertising, including in dozens of recent cases challenging "sugar-free" or "zero sugar" claims for products containing a sugar substitute known as allulose.
uncertain
producers → list → allulose
What happens next?
asserted
What → happen → ?
The complaint seeks unspecified damages for false advertising and violations of various state consumer protection laws.
asserted
complaint → seek → laws
It also seeks to have the lawsuit certified as a class action and demands a trial by jury "on all issues so triable."
asserted
lawsuit → seek → issues
The lawsuit was filed on behalf of three individual consumers who bought Starbucks's sugar-free protein drinks in California, New York and Washington.
asserted
who → file → California
Consumers avoid sugar for various reasons, including health-related issues such as diabetes, Steve Berman, a co-founder and managing partner of the Seattle-headquartered firm that filed the lawsuit, said in a news release.
"And for many, a staunch mislabeling like this is significant," Berman said.
asserted
Berman → avoid → this
“Beverages with this much sugar are like drinking a candy bar.”
asserted
Beverages → drink → bar
The Aporia
