What Cornell's alleged rape case and the Hockey Canada trial's striking parallels reveal
Prosecutors have reopened Cornell investigation after lawsuit filed by Jane Doe
asserted
Prosecutors → allege → Doe
This article references sexual assault and may affect those who have experienced sexual violence or know someone affected by it.
uncertain
who → reference → it
A group message that invites other men to join.
asserted
that → invite → men
If it feels like you've heard this story before, it's because you likely have.
asserted
you → feel → story
Several legal experts note there are some striking similarities between the alleged gang-rape case unfolding at Cornell University this week, and last year's Hockey Canada sexual assault trial in London, Ont., which saw all five players acquitted.
"It just seemed like yet another example of a group exploiting a vulnerable person," lawyer Karen Bellehumeur, who represented the survivor known as E.M. in the 2025 Hockey Canada trial, told CBC News about the Cornell case.
asserted
who → note → case
"When a group is involved, it's particularly abhorrent."
asserted
it → involve → ?
What to know about Cornell's alleged frat house gang-rape case and the 'Cornell 7'
- HOCKEY CANADA TRIAL
What happens after Hockey Canada sex assault trial ended in not guilty rulings?
asserted
trial → know → rulings
Some key questions answered
asserted
questions → answer → ?
The Cornell case recently came under the spotlight after the victim, known in court documents as Jane Doe, filed a civil lawsuit on Sept. 16 alleging the Ivy League university protected the seven men, now dubbed "the Cornell 7."
asserted
university → come → men
Jane Doe alleges they plied her with ketamine and assaulted her over several hours at a frat house in October 2024, and that one of the frat brothers sent a Snapchat message inviting other members to join them.
asserted
one → allege → them
None of the fraternity members have been criminally charged, and the lawsuit claims the accused only faced temporary suspensions and "were afforded the opportunity to mitigate their conduct by submitting essays" to the university — an allegation Cornell denies.
uncertain
Cornell → charge → university
Cornell also says some of the students were expelled after an internal disciplinary investigation.
asserted
some → say → investigation
On Monday, after intense backlash, the Tompkins County district attorney announced he was reopening the investigation.
asserted
he → announce → investigation
By Thursday evening, New York Gov. Kathy Hochul said she’d lost faith in the Tompkins County district attorney's ability to handle the case and was appointing a special prosecutor to oversee the investigation.
asserted
she → say → investigation
Hochul said she had signed an executive order giving the office of New York Attorney General Letitia James responsibility for the investigation.
asserted
she → say → investigation
In the 2025 Hockey Canada sexual assault trial, five former World Junior hockey players were charged with sexually assaulting a woman, known as E.M. due to a publication ban, in a hotel room in June 2018.
asserted
players → charge → June
One of the men sent a text message to the team inviting them to come to his room to "be in a 3-way quick."
asserted
One → send → quick
All of the so-called "Hockey Canada 5" were found not guilty.
asserted
All → call → Canada
The NHL reinstated them.
asserted
NHL → reinstate → them
One was recently signed by the Edmonton Oilers.
asserted
One → sign → Oilers
The broader themes in the two cases are "strikingly significant," said Melanie Randall, an associate professor of law at Western University in London, Ont., who researches gender-based violence.
asserted
who → say → violence
"Institutional failures, inadequate investigations, an inappropriate focus on what she did and not what they did, misunderstandings of consent — it's all there," Randall told CBC News.
asserted
Randall → do → News
Not a coincidence, lawyer says
The parallels between the two cases are more than a coincidence, Toronto lawyer Gillian Hnatiw, a legal expert in gender-based violence and sexual assault, told CBC News.
asserted
Hnatiw → say → News
Both cases involve exclusive organizations of men — a fraternity at a prestigious university and an elite hockey team — where it's alleged that no one stepped in to stop a woman from being harmed, Hnatiw said, calling it "a continuation of locker room culture."
"The fact that there are these communities where as men they feel comfortable not just speaking in this way but inviting their friends to participate in this event, raises serious cultural concerns for me," Hnatiw said.
asserted
Hnatiw → involve → me
"This strikes with Hockey Canada as well, that it seems like not an exceptional thing that one of their teammates sent out a group chat saying come to this room, there's a girl you can have sex with."
asserted
you → strike → sex
The Cornell lawsuit, filed in New York Supreme Court and viewed by CBC News, alleges the assault happened on campus at the Chi Phi fraternity house.
asserted
assault → file → house
It included an image of an alleged Snapchat message sent at 1:42 a.m. to members of the fraternity, claiming there was "free pussy."
asserted
It → include → fraternity
It also included some of the purported responses from the accused, including, "like you can walk in and whip it out."
asserted
you → include → it
CBS further reports that later on, one of the fraternity brothers texted the chat to ask "Shop still open?" and the response was "Yea."
asserted
response → report → chat
"The texts … speak volumes to the kind of misogynist mentality that saw her body as something they had a right to access," Randall said.
And it's the same mentality and the same idea as what we saw with the Hockey Canada texts, she added.
asserted
she → speak → texts
This is the message that went from one man to the rest."
Misunderstood trauma responses
Another root problem both these cases share is how little people understand trauma responses, said Bellehumeur, the lawyer who represented E.M. in the Hockey Canada trial.
asserted
who → go → trial
"My concern for Jane Doe is that it appears there was an initial statement taken by her, and it's different than what she said later and in her civil lawsuit, and I think much is going to be made of that difference," Bellehumeur said.
asserted
Bellehumeur → appear → difference
On Monday, Tompkins County district attorney Matthew Van Houten said the original investigation in 2024 didn't result in criminal charges in part because Jane Doe did not, in her initial sworn statement to campus police, make any allegations of being gang-raped or drugged.
asserted
Doe → say → allegations
"On the contrary, Jane Doe’s statement described her participation in drug use and sexual conduct as voluntary, conscious and consensual," he said.
asserted
he → describe → use
Jane Doe's lawyer has since disputed Van Houten's claim that she did not report the incident as a rape.
uncertain
she → dispute → rape
This was also an issue in the Hockey Canada trial, where E.M. was scrutinized for her differing statements and for acting permissive and compliant in the hotel room, with defence arguing the men couldn't have known she didn't consent.
asserted
she → scrutinize → room
Survivors often initially don't understand their own trauma reactions, Bellehumeur said.
asserted
Bellehumeur → understand → reactions
Any time there's a perceived lack of control and fear, the brain automatically causes involuntary reactions the victim herself may not understand, she added.
uncertain
she → be → reactions
"She may ask herself, 'Why didn't I leave? Why did I acquiesce?'" Bellehumeur said.
uncertain
Bellehumeur → ask → herself
Researchers have explained trauma responses can include: fight, flight, freeze and fawn.
asserted
responses → explain → fight
…and 15 more, not listed.
The Aporia
