'Accidents happen':
asserted
Accidents → happen → ?
What the Supreme Court has said about survivors of botched executions
Christa Pike's situation has similarities to a 1947 Supreme Court case.
asserted
situation → say → case
The remarkable survival of Christa Pike after an attempted execution in Tennessee poses equally remarkable legal questions about whether a second state attempt to kill her would violate the Constitution.
asserted
attempt → attempt → Constitution
Pike, 50, who is said to be "conscious" and "speaking" after receiving two doses of lethal injection, faces what her attorneys call a "long recovery" and the prospect she may return to the death chamber.
uncertain
she → say → chamber
Her attorneys say a second attempt at ending her life now would be "cruel and unusual punishment" under the 8th Amendment and are urging Gov. Bill Lee to commute her sentence to life without parole.
asserted
attempt → say → parole
So far, the Tennessee governor has publicly kept execution on the table.
asserted
governor → keep → table
"My responsibility is to uphold the sentences that Tennessee juries have handed down, even when it's difficult, and that is exactly what we intend to do in the days ahead," Lee said at a press conference last week.
asserted
Lee → uphold → conference
"The people of Tennessee have determined that the death penalty is the appropriate penalty for the most heinous crimes in the state.
asserted
penalty → determine → state
The people of Tennessee make that decision, and my job is to make sure then that those sentences are carried out."
Legal scholars say the case presents unprecedented circumstances, as Pike is the first person to have survived administration of pentobarbital, according to the Death Penalty Information Center.
uncertain
Pike → make → Center
However, it is not the first time an American has survived attempted execution and challenged a subsequent attempt on constitutional grounds.
asserted
American → survive → grounds
In 1947, the U.S. Supreme Court decided the case of 17-year-old Willie Francis, a black teenager who was sent to the electric chair but survived a botched electrocution.
asserted
who → decide → electrocution
After a Louisiana executioner threw the switch, Francis reportedly screamed "I'm not dying!" and "Take it off! Let me breathe!," according to court documents.
uncertain
me → throw → documents
Witnesses, in sworn affidavits, reported seeing Francis' lips puff out and swell, body tense and stretch, and the chair itself came off the ground.
asserted
chair → swear → ground
"This boy really got a shock when they turned that machine on," one said.
asserted
one → get → machine
The state insisted no electric current actually passed through Francis' body due to some mechanical difficulty.
asserted
current → insist → difficulty
At the time, it was the only known U.S. case of a condemned person surviving an attempted execution.
asserted
person → know → execution
Francis, who at age 16 had been convicted of murdering a former employer, challenged a second electrocution by arguing it would violate 14th Amendment due process rights, a 5th Amendment prohibition on multiple punishments, and amount to cruel and unusual punishment under the 8th Amendment.
asserted
it → convict → Amendment
Attorneys for Christa Pike could likely raise similar claims, legal experts say.
uncertain
experts → raise → claims
The high court in 1947, however, narrowly rejected them.
asserted
court → reject → them
In a 5-4 decision authored by Justice Stanley Reed, the Supreme Court concluded Francis' constitutional rights would not be violated by electrocuting him a second time (which Louisiana ultimately did).
asserted
Louisiana → author → which
"Accidents happen for which no man is to blame," Reed wrote in the decision.
asserted
Reed → happen → decision
"Even the fact that petitioner has already been subjected to a current of electricity does not make his subsequent execution any more cruel in the constitutional sense than any other execution," he wrote.
asserted
he → subject → execution
Reed rejected claims of added "psychological strain" on Francis because of the botched first attempt and the notion that a do-over would amount to "more severe punishment" than was originally imposed.
uncertain
over → reject → punishment
Justice Felix Frankfurter, concurring in the decision, added that states also have the right to administer justice as they see fit.
asserted
they → concur → justice
"This court must abstain from interference with state action no matter how strong one's personal feeling of revulsion against a state's insistence on its pound of flesh," he wrote.
asserted
he → abstain → flesh
In dissent, Justice Harold Burton argued that repeated electrocutions amounted to unconstitutional cruelty.
asserted
electrocutions → argue → cruelty
"It is unthinkable that any state legislature in modern times would enact a statute expressly authorizing capital punishment by repeated applications of an electric current separated by intervals of days or hours until finally death shall result," Burton wrote.
asserted
Burton → enact → days
He noted that Louisiana state law — as with most others that authorize the death penalty — call for methods that impose instantaneous and substantially painless death.
asserted
that → note → death
"If the state officials deliberately and intentionally had placed [Francis] in the electric chair five times and, each time, had applied electric current to his body in a manner not sufficient, until the final time, to kill him," Burton wrote, "such a form of torture would rival that of burning at the stake."
Burton concluded: "It was the statutory duty of state officials to make sure that there was no failure," he wrote dissenting.
Whether or not the faulty administration of lethal injection to Pike was an "accident" could be a key question in weighing a future legal challenge, if state officials decide to try to execute her again.
uncertain
officials → place → her
State officials have said publicly that they followed established protocol during the episode, even as it is now under independent review.
asserted
it → say → review
Pike's attorneys say they repeatedly pointed out in court documents that her unusually small veins would pose unique difficulty for executioners, and that childhood trauma from rape and sexual abuse would exacerbate mental anguish in the death chamber.
asserted
trauma → say → chamber
Her attorneys did not immediately respond to ABC News' request for comment.
asserted
attorneys → respond → comment
The Aporia
