Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito discusses his concerns about threats to religious liberty in a new book titled "So Ordered," which includes speeches he delivered starting in 2018 at Catholic University of America and later to the Magnificat Foundation. In these addresses, Alito argues that the landmark Obergefell v. Hodges decision legalizing same-sex marriage was pivotal in shifting attitudes against religious freedom, leading to a surge in cases involving conflicts between religious beliefs and government regulations or public policy requirements. He cites examples such as businesses refusing service for gay weddings and faith-based organizations challenging health care mandates, asserting that these disputes have increasingly come before the Supreme Court, which has largely sided with religious entities in these cases.
Written locally by qwen2.5:14b on 2026-10-06,
using this article's own text rather than the other coverage of the
same event (that is the story summary below).
Seeing threats to religious liberty, Alito calls same-sex marriage a 'decisive' turn
In a new book, the Supreme Court justice reflects on his "pet issue" of faith.
asserted
justice → see → faith
Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito, the devout Catholic conservative who has long warned of animus against religion in America, says in a new book that he believes the court's landmark decision extending marriage rights to same-sex couples was "perhaps the decisive point in our nation's turn against religious liberty."
asserted
decision → warn → liberty
Alito, who dissented sharply in the 2015 case, made the claim at Catholic University of America three years after Obergefell v Hodges in a speech that was not open to the public or widely covered at the time.
uncertain
that → dissent → time
The remarks were published this month in "So Ordered," a collection of Alito speeches that he says reflect his judicial philosophy and outlook on the country.
asserted
he → publish → country
"In dissent from that ruling," he said in the 2018 address, "I expressed my worry that equating the expression of certain views with bigotry -- or, if you like, with dignitary harm -- would drive believers out of public life."
asserted
you → say → life
Alito suggests that his prediction has come to pass.
uncertain
prediction → suggest → pass
"Quite suddenly, religious liberty has become controversial," Alito said in a newly published 2022 speech to the Magnificat Foundation, a nonprofit group dedicated to promoting Catholic culture and traditions.
asserted
Alito → become → culture
Throughout the book, the justice cites a string of lawsuits to reach the Supreme Court in recent years as evidence that "support for religious liberty has cratered."
The cases involve businesses threatened with punishment for refusing to provide services for gay weddings and faith-based organizations harmed by government health or employment regulations without any religious exemption.
asserted
cases → cite → exemption
"What we see in these and other cases," Alito says in the 2022 speech, "is a refusal to live in peace with those who violate the new moral code."
asserted
who → see → code
He says the dynamic will "virtually guarantee that the Supreme Court will continue to see a steady stream of religious-liberty cases.
asserted
Court → say → cases
"
Court sided with religiously affiliated parties
In nearly all the cases Alito cites as examples of religious animus, the court ultimately sided with the religiously affiliated parties over their opponents.
asserted
court → side → opponents
The court ruled in favor of a Colorado baker who was sued for refusing to create a wedding cake for a gay couple and later defended a Christian wedding website designer who objected to creating sites for same-sex ceremonies.
asserted
who → rule → ceremonies
When the Affordable Care Act mandated that employers provide insurance plans with no-cost contraceptive coverage, the high court ruled that some private employers can opt-out as a matter of faith and that federal agencies must be allowed to exempt religious employers from the rule.
asserted
agencies → mandate → rule
The court recently ruled that states must allow religiously affiliated private schools to participate in state-funded private tuition programs and tax credit initiatives.
asserted
schools → rule → programs
Last year, it gave parents the right to opt-out their kids from teachings that conflict with sincere religious beliefs.
asserted
that → give → beliefs
The conservative majority blocked a bid by the city of Philadelphia to exclude Catholic Social Services from its foster care program over LGBT discrimination and later effectively struck down state laws banning LGBT conversion therapy, which some religious advocates said amounted to a gag order against Christian teaching about human sexuality.
Recent decisions have also expanded protection for religious exercise on the job -- siding with a former public school football coach who had been disciplined for praying at midfield after games -- and mandated broader employer accommodations for the faithful who need to skip work to attend worship services.
asserted
who → block → services
Alito joined the majority in all of those cases and has voted in favor of faith-based interests in many others over his 20 years on the high court.
asserted
Alito → join → court
Same-sex marriage remains a flashpoint
The issue of same-sex marriage rights, which was narrowly decided 5-4, remains a flashpoint.
asserted
which → remain → rights
In 2025, Alito said publicly that while he strongly opposes the ruling, he is "not suggesting that the decision should be overruled," even as fellow conservative Justice Clarence Thomas has openly urged his colleagues to do so.
asserted
Thomas → say → colleagues
Nevertheless, Alito suggests in his book that the marriage decision has effectively silenced Americans whose sincere religious beliefs favor limiting unions to one man and one woman, likening them to Catholics who were sidelined in post-Reformation England.
They "had been so beaten down that they were 'a people who shunned the light of day.'
uncertain
who → suggest → day
They were 'found in corners, and alleys, and cellars, and the housetops, or in the recesses of the country,'" he said in a newly-published speech delivered in 2021 at Thomas Aquinas College.
asserted
he → find → College
"What I predicted in my dissent is coming to pass," Alito said of same-sex marriage opponents.
asserted
Alito → predict → opponents
Some advocates see differently than Alito
asserted
advocates → see → Alito
While many religious liberty advocates openly share Alito's concerns, some have voiced a different view of the current state of affairs.
asserted
some → share → affairs
"We continue to win unparalleled court victories at every level of the judiciary furthering the religious liberty of all Americans, resulting in more religious freedom today than at any other time in our lives," wrote Jeff Mateer, executive vice president and chief operating and legal officer of First Liberty Institute in the group's 2025 annual report.
asserted
Mateer → continue → report
The nonprofit group calls itself the "nation's largest legal advocacy firm dedicated to defending religious liberty" and frequently brings cases to the high court.
asserted
group → call → court
The Becket Fund for Religious Liberty, another high profile nonprofit religious advocacy group, says in its 2025 report on religious freedom in America that "faith in the public square is on the rise."
asserted
faith → say → rise
"Americans are moving away from a timid, behind-closed-doors view of religious freedom," Becket found.
asserted
Becket → move → freedom
One of six Catholic justices on the current court, Alito, who calls freedom of religion a "pet issue," concedes the legal victories for religious exercise rights but maintains a critical view of threats to people of faith.
asserted
who → call → faith
"It says a lot that the parties whose free-exercise rights were violated had to take their claims all the way to our Court," he said at the 2021 event.
uncertain
he → say → event
The book also highlights the justice's views on originalism and textualism; the role of judges in American life; and what he calls "threats" to the Constitution.
asserted
he → highlight → Constitution
The Aporia
