Reason
· collected 2026-10-04 · by Jonathan H. Adler
Associate Justice Samuel Alito sat down for multiple interviews with Jan Crawford of CBS News in advance of the opening of the Supreme Court's term and the release of his book, So Ordered: An Originalist's View of the Constitution, the Court, and Our Country.
asserted
Alito → sit → Constitution
Video clips from the interviews were released yesterday, as I noted here.
asserted
I → release → interviews
An extensive article based upon the interviews, and Crawford's reporting, is now up on CBSNews.com.
asserted
article → base → CBSNews.com
It notes that Justice Alito is "one of the most influential Supreme Court justices of our time."
asserted
Alito → note → time
Crawford writes:
The current Supreme Court is referred to as the "Roberts Court," after Chief Justice John Roberts, and Roberts is typically the justice most often in the majority.
asserted
Roberts → write → majority
His legal positions going back years on abortion, affirmative action, voting rights and religious liberty now are law of the land.
asserted
positions → go → land
Among the nine, Alito is especially skilled in bringing together five justices for a majority on some of the Court's most difficult and contentious issues.
asserted
Alito → bring → issues
That includes his 5-4 majority decision in Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization, which overturned Roe v. Wade and sent the issue of abortion back to the states.
asserted
which → include → states
That may seem a contradiction: The justice often publicly portrayed as unyielding and inflexible is, behind the scenes, the conservative who is uniquely adept at finding common ground on the most divisive issues.
uncertain
who → seem → issues
It's a skill formed on the fields and classrooms of Hamilton Township: His focus and attention to detail, his loyalty, his quiet leadership style, and his ability to survey the playing field and adjust, all to make the winning play.
asserted
It → form → play
Justice Alito's critics may think he is motivated by grievance and conservative resentment.
uncertain
he → think → grievance
What Crawford's reporting reveals is that Justice Alito is quietly effective with his colleagues.
asserted
Alito → reveal → colleagues
Outside the Court, few understand Alito's powerful role within it.
asserted
few → understand → it
Assembling and keeping together a majority is the whole ball game.
asserted
Assembling → assemble → majority
Liberal icon William Brennan used to say the most important thing for a Supreme Court justice to know is how to count to five, and he was able to build coalitions with his legendary gift of personal persuasion and strategic compromise.
asserted
he → use → persuasion
Alito, reserved and unassuming, has a very different approach.
asserted
Alito → have → approach
His influence is not through force of personality, but in his ability to thread the needle and find the rationale a majority will agree with.
asserted
majority → thread → rationale
Those skills allow him to forge consensus for an opinion that moves the law as far as is practicable at the time.
asserted
that → allow → time
But while Justice Alito has been quite effective at crafting majority opinions that hold five votes, he does not believe he has had to compromise his principles or embrace reasoning he does not embrace.
asserted
he → craft → reasoning
"The most important thing to know is to be true to the Constitution.
asserted
thing → know → Constitution
Getting to five is important.
asserted
Getting → get → five
But you should not try to get a majority opinion if that means sacrificing something that is important," he said.
asserted
he → try → something
"I will never adopt a legal rule that I think is wrong, or say something that I think is wrong.
asserted
I → adopt → something
But without doing that, there are ways of trying to keep a majority together." . . .
"I have a theory about how the Constitution should be interpreted.
asserted
Constitution → do → theory
I believe it has a fixed meaning.
asserted
it → believe → meaning
And it still means today what it was understood to mean when it was adopted.
asserted
it → mean → what
And I will not depart from that," he said.
asserted
he → depart → that
"But it is not necessary in every case to go as far as one might want to go if you were just writing the opinion for yourself.
uncertain
you → go → yourself
Crawford's take on the Court, and Justice Alito's role within it, is worth heeding.
asserted
take → heed → it
Her book, Supreme Conflict, chronicled the making of the Roberts Court, and her reporting tends to carry more insight into the current Court than that of her competitors.
asserted
reporting → chronicle → competitors
Among other things, she was the first reporter to grasp how much Justice Thomas's commitment to originalist jurisprudence was influencing his colleagues, including the late Justice Scalia.
asserted
commitment → grasp → Scalia
Justice Alito apparently sat for several hours of interviews in his New Jersey hometown and at the Supreme Court.
asserted
Alito → sit → Court
Among the subjects discussed were his approach to the law, his decision-making, whether he thinks about retirement, and the leak of his draft Dobbs opinion.
asserted
he → discuss → opinion
Hearing during a collegial lunch that a draft opinion had leaked for the first time in Court history was difficult for the justices to process.
asserted
justices → hear → history
Alito said he was "stunned.
asserted
he → say → ?
"It was quite a shock," Alito said.
asserted
Alito → say → ?
"But within a relatively short period of time, the thought occurred to me, and I think to the others in the majority, that this would endanger us.
asserted
this → occur → us
And it made us targets for assassination." . . .
The leaker remains unknown.
asserted
leaker → make → assassination
After Politico published its piece in early May, one theory was that a conservative had leaked the draft to keep the five votes in place, in case any of the justices in the majority were wavering.
uncertain
any → publish → majority
"It's implausible that any of us would have done that for exactly the reason I've mentioned, because this pinned a target on our backs," Alito said.
asserted
Alito → do → backs
…and 25 more, not listed.
The Aporia
