Photo via Toronto Star

Lindsay Clancy set to return to court for first time since murder trial ended with deadlocked jury

Read the original at Toronto Star ↗
Cite

Casey, M. (2026, September 29). Lindsay Clancy set to return to court for first time since murder trial ended with deadlocked jury. Toronto Star. https://www.thestar.com/news/world/united-states/lindsay-clancy-set-to-return-to-court-for-first-time-since-murder-trial-ended-with-deadlocked-jury/article_0487723c-5aea-56d3-94cb-a6ecebaa18e4.html

Dated when The Aporia collected the article, usually within hours of publication. Check the original for its exact date and byline.

Toronto Star · collected 2026-09-29 · by Michael Casey

Quick Summary

Lindsay Clancy will appear in court Tuesday for a hearing that could determine whether she faces another trial after a mistrial was declared due to a 11-to-1 deadlock favoring acquittal on murder charges related to the deaths of her three children. Clancy’s defense team has filed motions requesting dismissal of the case and questioning the conduct of one juror who favored conviction, while prosecutors may decide whether to retry her or pursue lesser charges. The hearing will also address issues raised by Clancy's attorneys regarding jury fairness and procedural rules during deliberations.
Written by AI on 2026-10-02, from this article's own text only (the story summary below draws on all the coverage).
See how they differ ↓

AI analysis

Story summary

Judge William Sullivan denied Lindsay Clancy's defense motion to find her not guilty of murdering her three children, ruling that prosecutors presented sufficient evidence for a jury to determine she was criminally responsible despite suffering from mental illness. The judge noted that it is up to the jury to decide whether expert witnesses' testimony about her lack of criminal responsibility should be accepted or rejected. This decision leaves open the possibility of a retrial following the earlier mistrial due to a deadlocked jury. Clancy's lawyer argued there was insufficient evidence proving she committed the killings, but Sullivan disagreed, stating that any rational trier of fact could find her guilty based on the presented evidence. The case now remains unresolved with ongoing debate about criminal responsibility and mental health considerations in legal proceedings.

Written for “Lindsay Clancy Murder Case Hearing” on 2026-11-18, grounded in this article and the 29 other(s) covering the same event.

How they differ

15 outlets covered “Lindsay Clancy Murder Case Hearing”.

What each outlet says

One AI summary per outlet of its latest article on this story, written from that article alone and checked against it. Open the article for the outlet's own words.

Toronto StarThis outlet29 Sep

Lindsay Clancy will appear in court Tuesday for a hearing that could determine whether she faces another trial after a mistrial was declared due to a 11-to-1 deadlock favoring acquittal on murder charges related to the deaths of her three children. Clancy’s defense team has filed motions requesting dismissal of the case and questioning the conduct of one juror who favored conviction, while prosecutors may decide…

Lindsay Clancy set to return to court for first time since murder trial ended with deadlocked jury (this article)
CBS News1 Oct

Judge William Sullivan rejected Lindsay Clancy's attorney Kevin Reddington’s request for a not guilty verdict in her murder trial involving her three children who died in 2023. The judge ruled that despite the defense's claims of insufficient evidence, the prosecution had presented enough to warrant a jury decision, based on Clancy being the sole person home at the time of the killings as confirmed by GPS data and…

Judge denies Lindsay Clancy's long-shot bid for a not-guilty finding →6 articles from CBS News on this story
Fox News1 Oct

Judge William Sullivan in Plymouth, Massachusetts, denied Lindsay Clancy’s motion for a finding of not guilty weeks after her mistrial was declared on September 4, 2026. Defense attorney Kevin Reddington argued that the prosecution had insufficient evidence to prove Clancy's guilt beyond a reasonable doubt, but Judge Sullivan disagreed, stating there was enough physical and circumstantial evidence to support…

Lindsay Clancy's motion for a finding of not guilty denied weeks after mistrial →4 articles from Fox News on this story
The Independent1 Oct

Judge William Sullivan refused to declare Lindsay Clancy not guilty after her first trial ended in a mistrial with a jury split 11 to 1 in favor of acquittal. During a hearing on Tuesday, Clancy’s attorney Kevin Reddington argued that prosecutors did not provide sufficient evidence to prove Clancy killed her three children, describing the case as speculative. However, Judge Sullivan disagreed, stating there was…

Judge in Lindsay Clancy trial refuses to declare her not guilty after mistrial →4 articles from The Independent on this story
New York Post1 Oct

Judge Timothy Sullivan rejected Lindsay Clancy’s lawyer, David Reddington, when he tried to have the murder charges against her dismissed after she was found not guilty by an impasse jury earlier this month. The judge ruled that there was enough evidence presented during the six-week trial to sustain the charges of Clancy strangling her three young children with exercise bands in Duxbury, Massachusetts, on January…

Lindsay Clancy’s lawyer slapped down by judge after trying to get murder charges thrown out →3 articles from New York Post on this story
CBC1 Oct

Judge William Sullivan denied Lindsay Clancy’s defense request to declare her not guilty of murdering her three children in Massachusetts in 2023. The judge ruled that prosecutors provided sufficient evidence for a jury to determine if Clancy was responsible, despite defense arguments questioning the adequacy of the prosecution's case and suggesting lack of police investigation. The article details the first trial’s…

Judge denies defence request to declare Lindsay Clancy not guilty →2 articles from CBC on this story
Show 8 more outlets
Washington Examiner1 Oct

Judge William Sullivan in Lindsay Clancy’s murder trial rejected the defense's request for a not-guilty verdict based on lack of criminal responsibility due to mental illness. Six forensic experts agreed that Clancy was suffering from serious mental health issues, but disagreed on whether this negates her legal culpability. The judge ruled that despite evidence of severe mental illness, prosecutors presented…

Judge in Lindsay Clancy murder trial rejects defense’s not-guilty bid →2 articles from Washington Examiner on this story
Sydney Morning Herald29 Sep

Lindsay Clancy’s lawyer is now arguing there isn’t enough evidence to prove she killed her three children, shifting from the previous focus on her mental state during a trial where the jury was split 11 to 1 in her favor. The defense claims Clancy lacked memory and awareness due to postpartum psychosis at the time of the incident, while prosecutors maintain strong evidence against her, including testimony that she…

Lindsay Clancy’s lawyer now questions whether she killed her three children →
NPR29 Sep

Lindsay Clancy's lawyer, Kevin Reddington, now argues that there isn't enough evidence to prove she killed her three children in 2023. At a recent hearing following a deadlocked jury at her first trial, Reddington pointed out inconsistencies and lack of direct admission from Clancy, questioning the prosecution’s case. Prosecutor Shanan Buckingham counters this by citing numerous pieces of evidence presented during…

Lindsay Clancy's lawyer now questions whether she killed her 3 children →
BBC29 Sep

Lindsay Clancy appeared in court recently for her murder trial that ended in a mistrial due to a hung jury. Her lawyer, Kevin Reddington, argued that the case should be dismissed, citing insufficient evidence and claiming the prosecution failed to meet its burden of proof. Prosecutors countered by saying they presented ample evidence showing Clancy was mentally sound at the time she killed her three children and…

Lindsay Clancy appears in court as her lawyer pushes for murder case to be dismissed →
ABC News (US)1 Oct

Judge William Sullivan rejected Lindsay Clancy’s motion to dismiss her triple-murder case, ruling there was sufficient evidence presented by prosecutors to support a guilty verdict. The denial means Clancy’s case could proceed to a retrial if necessary.

Lindsay Clancy judge denies motion to force not guilty finding →
ABC News (AU)1 Oct

Judge William Sullivan denied Lindsay Clancy’s defense motion to find her not guilty of murdering her three children in Massachusetts in 2023. During a hearing, Clancy's lawyer Kevin Reddington argued there was insufficient evidence linking her to the killings. However, Judge Sullivan ruled that the physical and circumstantial evidence presented allows for a jury to conclude beyond reasonable doubt that she…

Judge denies Lindsay Clancy defence motion to find her not guilty →
The Straits Times1 Oct

Judge William Sullivan in Boston denied Lindsay Clancy’s lawyers’ request to declare her not guilty after a mistrial due to a hung jury in her murder trial. The judge ruled that prosecutors had presented enough evidence to support a conviction, despite defense arguments that she was suffering from postpartum psychosis at the time of the killings. The incident occurred on January 24, 2023, when Clancy strangled her…

US judge denies request to find Lindsay Clancy not guilty after mistrial →
Daily Mail2 Oct

Judge William Sullivan denied Lindsay Clancy’s motion to have her found not guilty of murdering her three children, ruling that the evidence presented by the prosecution was sufficient beyond reasonable doubt. This decision follows a mistrial declared earlier this month when jurors could not reach a unanimous verdict; one juror refused to find Clancy not guilty by reason of insanity due to severe postpartum…

Lindsay Clancy loses daring bid to have her found not guilty of murdering her three children after mistrial →

Where they agree and split

Agreed

AI · cited, from two or more outlets

  • The mistrial was declared due to the jury being split 11 to 1 in favor of acquitting Clancy.63
  • Clancy's attorney argued that there was insufficient evidence presented at trial for a rational jury to find her guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.23
Quoted from the coverage (4)

“This entire case is based on speculation,” attorney Kevin Reddington said in a striking turn after a lengthy trial that focused more on her mental state than on whether she took their lives.

6 outlets

There is, Reddington contended, not enough evidence “that this woman killed those children.”

6 outlets

Prosecutor Shanan Buckingham called his argument “laughable,” pointing to various evidence raised during the trial.

6 outlets

Clancy’s lawyer said she should not be held criminally responsible because of her postpartum psychosis, a rare mental illness linked to the stress, sleep deprivation and hormonal changes that follow childbirth.

5 outlets

Disputed

Picked by our model, which is sometimes wrong

  • CBS News states that Reddington argued there was no evidence Clancy killed her children, whereas other sources indicate he did not dispute the fact of the killings but rather the criminal responsibility and burden of proof.27

Framing

How the first headlines put it

  • The New York Post emphasizes the pivotal nature of the hearing in deciding the future of Clancy’s case, whereas CBS News highlights Reddington's argument about insufficient evidence.82
Stated as fact4
The headlines (4)

Lindsay Clancy's push to investigate holdout juror could be paused as defense, prosecutors agree to adjourn Fox News · stated as fact

Lindsay Clancy set to return to court for first time since murder trial ended with deadlocked jury Toronto Star · stated as fact

Judge could dismiss Lindsay Clancy murder case in court hearing today The Independent · stated as fact

Pivotal Lindsay Clancy hearing could decide fate of her triple murder case after mistrial New York Post · stated as fact

Words to watch (2)

Judge in Lindsay Clancy trial refuses to declare her not guilty after mistrial The Independent

Attorney says there's "no evidence" Lindsay Clancy admitted killing her kids CBS News

The full story: what happened, how it changed, and all 30 articles →

Compared with similar articles

This article reads unscored and hedges 24% of its claims. Each row says how that neighbour differs.
Fox News
Hedges 9 of 46 claims Outlet record 67/100
The Independent
Hedges 2 of 13 claims Outlet record 59/100
Washington Examiner
Hedges 2 of 19 claims Outlet record 67/100
BBC News
Hedges 2 of 21 claims Outlet record 65/100
CBS News
Hedges 0 of 3 claims Outlet record 67/100
Fox News
Hedges 1 of 13 claims Outlet record 67/100
“Article A discusses the defense of a holdout juror in Lindsay Clancy's mistrial, while Article B mentions Lindsay Clancy's return to court for a hearing regarding her possible retrial.”
Washington Examiner
Hedges 1 of 18 claims Outlet record 67/100
“The articles refer to different aspects of the case timeline: one discusses the holdout juror's stance, while the other announces Lindsay Clancy's upcoming court hearing after a mistrial.”
Fox News
Hedges 4 of 24 claims Outlet record 67/100
“Article A mentions an interview with the lawyer of Lindsay Clancy's holdout juror, while Article B discusses Clancy's return to court for a potential second trial hearing.”
Fox News
Hedges 1 of 19 claims Outlet record 67/100
“The articles describe different parts of the legal process: one focuses on the holdout juror's statement after the mistrial, while the other covers Lindsay Clancy's return to court for a new hearing.”
New York Post
Hedges 4 of 24 claims Outlet record 66/100

Story

Lindsay Clancy Murder Case Hearing
Crime & Law · 30 article(s) covering the same event. Compare every outlet's account →
How this article was measured signals, leaning charts, publisher record, byline, topics and claims

Signals How these are calculated →

Claims extracted
21
sentences that state something as happening or true
Uncertain
24%
5 of 21 hedged ("reportedly", "may", "according to")
Leaning
not political
takes no side on a contested political question
Publisher signals
64/100
Toronto Star's corrections and hedging, across everything collected from it. Not a measure of accuracy.
Outlets on this story
30
Crime & Law
Same framing elsewhere
1
articles that frame the event the way this one does
Analyzed 2026-09-29 · how these are computed

How this is being covered How these are calculated →

Article leaning vs. publisher reliability
Source leaning vs. consistency

Publisher

Toronto Star · 15734 article(s) · 31 correction(s) detected
Running correction rate · 31 correction(s)
2026-11-17
Correction
2026-10-26
Correction
2026-10-24
Correction
2026-10-07
Correction
2026-09-24
Correction

Who wrote this

Michael Casey
25 article(s) here · 1 carrying a prediction
In a May 2026 interview with The Associated Press, Johnson said he didn’t hear or see the attack.
During a May 2026 interview with The Associated Press, he said he neither saw nor heard the event.
Texts in late 2020, after she was pregnant, showed they argued over what role, if any, Farwell would play in the child’s life.
Clancy’s defense team had asked Judge William Sullivan to end the case based on an unusual argument that a mistrial shouldn’t have been declared in September when jurors were unable to reach a unanimous verdict.
Defense attorney Daniel Marx criticized the decision to prosecute in a statement, saying, "The DOJ never should have brought this highly unusual ‘smuggling’ prosecution against Kseniia Petrova, a talented scientist at Harvard," and adding, "Ms. Petrova only sought to advance medical research into aging that could benefit everyone, and her handling of scientific samples — inert, non-living, non-toxic, frog embryos — never posed any danger to anyone."
They argued that the government only filed criminal charges after it looked like she would win her immigration case.
Judge William Sullivan repeatedly intervened as Reddington publicly identified the juror and raised allegations involving potentially confidential information.
They could choose to retry her on first-degree murder charges or pursue lesser charges, including second-degree murder or manslaughter, or drop the case entirely.
In southwestern Colorado, officials in Pagosa Springs, a town in the Rockies located near ski resorts and known for its hot springs, warned in a Facebook post of potentially “catastrophic flooding” as the San Juan River was forecast to crest at more than 19 feet (5.8 meters) around 11:00 p.m. Sunday.
An expert brought in by federal authorities, Dr. William Smock, concluded Birchmore was strangled with a duffel bag strap and that she struggled before dying.
Also by Michael Casey
Nothing else under this byline is closely related to this article, so these are simply their most recent.
All 25 articles by Michael Casey →

Topics

Mass. PLYMOUTH Plymouth County U.S.

Subjects

Clancy PERSON · 10× Callan Clancy PERSON · 1× Cora PERSON · 1× Dawson PERSON · 1× Lindsay Clancy PERSON · 1× Mass. GPE · 1× PLYMOUTH GPE · 1× Plymouth County GPE · 1× Timothy Cruz PERSON · 1× U.S. GPE · 1×

Narrative

The livestreamed trial generated intense public interest and drew attention to maternal mental health after childbirth. Clancy’s lawyer said she should not be held criminally responsible because of her postpartum psychosis, a rare mental illness linked to the stress, sleep deprivation and hormonal changes that follow childbirth.
framing: mixed · carried by 1 article(s) · first seen 2026-09-29
Lindsay Clancy is set to return to court Tuesday for a hearing that could help decide whether she will face a second trial in the killings of her three children.

Claims (21 extracted, 5 hedged)

Lindsay Clancy is set to return to court Tuesday for a hearing that could help decide whether she will face a second trial in the killings of her three children. uncertain
she → set → children
It will be Clancy’s first return to the courthouse since her first trial ended Sept. 4 with a deadlocked jury. asserted
trial → end → jury
A judge declared a mistrial with the jury split 11 to 1 in favor of acquitting Clancy of murder charges. asserted
jury → declare → charges
Clancy, a former labor and delivery nurse, never disputed that she killed the children, but her attorney said she had a rare condition called postpartum psychosis and was delusional and not responsible for her actions. asserted
she → dispute → actions
Prosecutors acknowledged that Clancy had mental health problems that included months of treatment and a stay in a psychiatric hospital, but argued that she knew what she was doing when she strangled the children then tried to kill herself in 2023. asserted
she → acknowledge → 2023
This story includes discussion of suicide. asserted
story → include → suicide
If you or someone you know needs help, the national suicide and crisis lifeline in the U.S. is available by calling or texting 988. asserted
suicide → know → 988
___ Clancy’s attorneys have filed several motions that could be addressed Tuesday. uncertain
that → file → motions
They have asked the judge to take the unusual step of dismissing the criminal case, rather than putting on a new trial. asserted
They → ask → trial
Among other things, they have argued that the judge should have ousted the one juror who favored a murder conviction after the jury foreperson complained he was refusing to listen to the law on reasonable doubt. asserted
he → argue → doubt
The defense has also asked the judge to investigate the juror’s truthfulness on a questionnaire that prospective jurors filled out before the trial began, his truthfulness when jurors were questioned by the judge a day before the trial ended and also whether he broke court rules by using a cellphone during deliberations. asserted
he → ask → deliberations
Tuesday’s hearing could also reveal whether prosecutors will move to put Clancy on trial for a second time. uncertain
prosecutors → reveal → time
Prosecutors can choose to retry her on first-degree murder charges or seek to try her only on lesser charges, including second-degree murder or manslaughter, or drop the case entirely. asserted
Prosecutors → choose → case
After the mistrial was declared, Plymouth County District Attorney Timothy Cruz told reporters his goal was always “getting justice for those three little babies.” asserted
goal → declare → babies
Prosecutors said Clancy acted deliberately when she strangled 5-year-old Cora, 3-year-old Dawson and 8-month-old Callan Clancy with exercise bands. asserted
she → say → bands
They said she contrived to get her husband out of the house on Jan. 24, 2023, by sending him to pick up medicine for one of their children and dinner for the family. asserted
she → say → family
The livestreamed trial generated intense public interest and drew attention to maternal mental health after childbirth. Clancy’s lawyer said she should not be held criminally responsible because of her postpartum psychosis, a rare mental illness linked to the stress, sleep deprivation and hormonal changes that follow childbirth. asserted
that → livestreame → childbirth
Clancy remains charged with murder and is expected to stay at a psychiatric hospital until her case is resolved. asserted
case → charge → hospital
She is paralyzed from the waist down since jumping from a second-story window after strangling her children. asserted
She → paralyze → children
Clancy could have been sentenced to life in prison if convicted of murder. uncertain
Clancy → sentence → murder
If acquitted, the judge could have ordered her confined to a mental health facility. uncertain
her → acquit → facility
Give feedback · no sign-in needed

No sign-in needed for now. Your note is sent without a name, so it cannot be answered.

History Support