To be fair to Andy Burnham, no one can say they don't know what he stands for anymore.
asserted
he → say → what
Appearing on the BBC's Laura Kuenssberg show, the Prime Minister made the boldest commitment of his premiership by announcing the establishment of a National Care Service, free at the point of use, paid for by everyone.
asserted
Minister → appear → everyone
Speaking passionately, and at times even emotionally, Burnham declared: 'Some in the political world will be saying watching this, Oh my goodness, what a hostage to fortune, that's a rod for his own back.
asserted
that → speak → back
But do you know what, I am not going to do politics as usual.
asserted
I → know → politics
Watching the broadcast, in which he talked eloquently about the national scandal of inadequate provision for our most vulnerable citizens, it was easy to see why Labour's new leader is enjoying a polling bounce.
asserted
leader → watch → bounce
Whatever your views of him and his government, he speaks human.
asserted
he → speak → him
Which represents a refreshing and notable change from his immediate predecessors.
asserted
Which → represent → predecessors
He has indeed saddled himself and his party – and potentially the entire country – with an enormous hostage to fortune.
asserted
He → saddle → fortune
One that could literally cost every one of us dear.
uncertain
that → cost → dear
Burnham is right when he says the current care system is in crisis.
asserted
system → say → crisis
But the sheer scale of that crisis simply reinforces just how much hardship could be placed on the shoulders of the British taxpayer if his new scheme is implemented.
uncertain
scheme → reinforce → taxpayer
The Prime Minister challenged estimates that it would cost a staggering £18.5billion.
asserted
it → challenge → 18.5billion
But whatever the bill, by Burnham's own candid admission, it will add significant weight to the tax millstone already hung around the neck of every working man and woman in the country.
asserted
it → add → country
On Saturday Angela Rayner broke cover – and collective cabinet responsibility – by lambasting Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood for her proposed new policies on permanent residency
Appearing on the BBC's Laura Kuenssberg show, the Prime Minister announced the establishment of a National Care Service, free at the point of use, paid for by everyone
His calculation is they are willing and able to bear that weight.
asserted
they → break → weight
But that was the assumption Theresa May made at the start of her catastrophically ill-fated 2017 election campaign.
uncertain
May → make → campaign
Like the current Prime Minister, she started that election by pledging a radical transformation of social care.
asserted
she → start → care
And ended it by pleading 'nothing has changed!'
asserted
nothing → end → it
On Friday, the Prime Minister categorically ruled out going to the polls before 2029.
asserted
Minister → rule → 2029
But an hour after Sunday's social care announcement I received a text from a close ally.
asserted
I → receive → ally
'I think it will be in May,' it read.
uncertain
it → think → May
Downing Street's strategy of getting Burnham to rule out a snap election was to avoid endless speculation that he was going to call one, then being forced to confront a series of headlines accusing him of 'bottling it' if he opted to postpone.
asserted
he → get → it
But yesterday's social care pledge has now boxed him in even more tightly.
asserted
pledge → box → him
The Prime Minister was clear he was unable to implement the policy immediately because he was constrained by the commitments given in the last Labour manifesto.
asserted
he → implement → manifesto
It would, he vowed, be in the next one.
asserted
he → vow → one
So what is Burnham expected to do for the next three years?
asserted
Burnham → expect → years
Say to the country, 'I've identified a raft of critical problems, like the social care crisis.
asserted
I → say → crisis
I think I've found some solutions.
asserted
I → think → solutions
You'll all have to sit around and wait for another three years before I get on and deal with them'?
asserted
I → have → them
That stance is especially untenable given the strategy recently unveiled by Kemi Badenoch and the Conservatives.
asserted
stance → give → Badenoch
In the Tory leader's final PMQs exchange with Burnham, she deployed a new line of attack.
asserted
she → deploy → attack
Castigating him for his failure to set out a clear plan for implementing welfare cuts, increasing defence spending, or reversing Sir Keir Starmer's decision to cede sovereignty of the Chagos Islands, she charged: 'He is pretending that he is the change candidate, but the fact is he is still failing to cut welfare, he is still paying to hand over a sovereign territory, and he is still not funding defence.
asserted
he → castigate → defence
On the issues that really matter, is he not just Continuity Keir?
asserted
he → matter → issues
If the Prime Minister plans to honour his pledge to wait until 2029 to seek a mandate for serious national renewal, that charge will rightly stick.
asserted
charge → plan → renewal
As Badenoch correctly points out, he cannot spend three years claiming to be the agent of change, whilst simultaneously telling the voters there is nothing to be done because his hands have been tied by his predecessor.
asserted
hands → point → predecessor
And even if Andy Burnham wanted to engage in 36 months of political procrastination, it's already becoming doubtful his fractious party will let him.
asserted
party → want → him
One of the charges laid at Burnham's door by his opponents is he has no mandate from the electorate.
asserted
he → lay → electorate
But within Labour's ranks there are already mutterings about the fact he also has no mandate from his own movement.
asserted
he → be → movement
On Saturday Angela Rayner broke cover – and collective cabinet responsibility – by lambasting Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood for her proposed new policies on permanent residency.
asserted
Rayner → break → residency
The day before, it was announced that Sir Keir Starmer ally Darren Jones had established a new parliamentary faction aimed at ensuring Andy Burnham remained 'fiscally responsible'.
asserted
Burnham → announce → faction
'The fact there was no contest is a problem for him,' one said, 'the view of some people is that if Andy didn't have to play by the rules to get where he wanted to be, why should they?'
Which in turn plays into concern over his dramatic social care announcement.
asserted
Which → be → announcement
…and 11 more, not listed.
The Aporia
