Reason Magazine
· collected 2026-09-04 · by J.D. Tuccille
Houses of worship are often targeted by people with murder on their minds.
asserted
Houses → target → minds
That's especially true of synagogues, which were disproportionately attacked even before October 7 and have since been on the receiving end of the "antizionist" reframing of hatred of Jews.
asserted
which → attack → Jews
But in Montgomery County, Maryland, officials recently renewed efforts to forbid the carrying of firearms within 100 yards of "places of public assembly," including churches and synagogues.
asserted
officials → renew → churches
Now, some security volunteers are defying the intrusive law as they await the outcome of courtroom pushback against the restrictions.
asserted
they → defy → restrictions
You are reading The Rattler from J.D. Tuccille and Reason.
asserted
You → read → Tuccille
Violating the First, Second, and Fourteenth Amendments
"Today, the Justice Department filed suit against Montgomery County, Maryland (County).
asserted
Department → violate → County
The complaint alleges that the County's newly enacted Bill 23-26 violates the Second Amendment by prohibiting law-abiding citizens from possessing firearms in daily life," the U.S. Department of Justice announced on August 3.
asserted
Department → allege → August
"Bill 23-26 prohibits carrying firearms at thousands of locations, and also creates an arbitrary 100-yard exclusion zone around each location.
asserted
Bill → prohibit → location
The law applies even if the person carrying a firearm is duly licensed and has the express consent of the property owner."
asserted
person → apply → owner
Separately, on behalf of the Silver Spring Jewish Center and along with Rabbi J. Menashe Shapiro, the New Civil Liberties Alliance is suing Montgomery County.
asserted
Alliance → sue → County
That lawsuit contends the law "violates the First Amendment right to free exercise of religion by prohibiting synagogue members from acting according to their beliefs.
uncertain
law → contend → beliefs
It also violates the First Amendment's Establishment Clause by making decisions in place of religious leaders.
asserted
It → violate → leaders
The law denies the Second Amendment right to keep and bear arms, and deprives the Jewish community and others of equal protection under the law by discriminating on the basis of religion, a Fourteenth Amendment violation."
asserted
law → deny → violation
The lawsuits against Montgomery County come after the July passage of Expedited Bill 23-26.
asserted
lawsuits → come → Bill
In a press release, county officials boasted, "the legislation maintains the County's prohibition on carrying firearms within 100 yards of many sensitive public places, including schools, parks, libraries, polling places, houses of worship, and legislative assemblies, while removing or modifying provisions that the Court determined the State must regulate."
asserted
State → boast → provisions
Primarily sponsored by Democratic Councilmember Dawn Luedtke, Bill 23-26 restates, in revised form, a 2022 ban on carrying firearms near public places.
asserted
Bill → sponsor → places
That ban was subject to an injunction after it was challenged and then found overbroad by the Maryland Supreme Court.
asserted
it → challenge → Court
Keeping 'Guns Out of Sensitive Community Spaces' No Matter What People Want
By email, I asked Luedtke about "any thought given to consulting with places of public assembly, including houses of worship, to learn if they prefer to make their own rules regarding the carrying of firearms rather than have them set by the county?"
asserted
them → keep → county
The councilmember responded that "the ban on firearms in houses of worship was in place before County Bill 23-26E" and that her legislation "was simply to conform the County's law with the Supreme Court of Maryland's decision earlier this year."
asserted
legislation → respond → decision
It's true that, as mentioned above, the ban on carrying firearms in and near "places of public assembly" was in place as of 2022.
asserted
ban → mention → 2022
But Luedtke and her colleagues were under no obligation to restate the ban after it was overruled by the courts, nor to—as she did in the press release—tout her efforts to "keep guns out of sensitive community spaces" without letting managers of those spaces decide for themselves.
asserted
managers → restate → themselves
A Congregation That Defends Itself by Necessity and by Choice
According to the Silver Spring Jewish Center lawsuit, the synagogue has always permitted congregants to carry personal weapons but implemented a security plan based on trained volunteers after antisemitic incidents became more common in the wake of Hamas' October 7 terrorist attack on Israel.
uncertain
incidents → defend → Israel
The law makes it impossible "to continue to implement its security plan and to use its volunteer Security Team, as the Ban forbids even members who are licensed to carry a firearm from doing so in the synagogue," the lawsuit claims.
uncertain
lawsuit → make → synagogue
It further points out that while the law makes exceptions for licensed security guards, it would be "prohibitively expensive" for the synagogue to hire armed guards.
asserted
synagogue → point → guards
The synagogue also prefers to rely on community volunteers as prescribed by the congregation's faith: "Talmudic and later religious sources command Jews to proactively provide their own security and the security of other Jews."
asserted
sources → prefer → Jews
Montgomery County lawmakers may prefer that it be illegal to carry guns near houses of worship.
uncertain
it → prefer → worship
But at least some clergy members and congregants think they would be much better off if allowed to make their own decisions about armed self-defense.
asserted
they → think → defense
(Note that I volunteer as an armed synagogue security guard.)
asserted
I → note → guard
The challenge to Montgomery County's restrictive gun laws comes as antisemitic incidents have surged in a county where 9.3 percent of the population is Jewish (the comparable percentage for the whole country is 2.3 percent).
asserted
percentage → come → country
All "places of public assembly" face security concerns, but that's especially true for houses of worship, and particularly for Jewish groups.
asserted
that → face → groups
Citing Montgomery County police statistics on hate crimes, a June 2026 letter to county officials from the Washington, D.C., Maryland, and Virginia chapter of EndJewHatred.com pointed out that "incidents against Jews—even a year before the Gaza war—were No. 1, and have steadily increased."
That has many Jewish groups are on high alert.
asserted
groups → cite → alert
Importantly, a May attack on Temple Israel in West Bloomfield, Michigan, was thwarted by the synagogue's security team.
uncertain
attack → thwart → team
In response to my questions, Councilmember Luedtke told me: "We are working to protect synagogues and Jewish members of our community from rising antisemitism and hate.
asserted
We → tell → antisemitism
In addition to our local laws, the County has a Nonprofit Security Grant Program, which has awarded more than $6.5 million over the last five years to enhance security measures for houses of worship and nonprofit organizations.
asserted
which → have → worship
But it won't do much for those who believe it wiser and even religiously necessary to provide for their own defense rather than rely on the authorities.
asserted
it → do → authorities
J. Menashe Shapiro, the center's rabbi, "holds the sincere religious belief that Jewish law requires him to carry a firearm for personal, family, and communal protection," according to a court filing.
uncertain
law → hold → filing
For now, some congregants say they're ignoring the law and continuing to bring weapons to services.
asserted
they → say → services
"We are still carrying," said a Jewish security volunteer in Silver Spring.
asserted
volunteer → carry → Spring
"That remains true, despite Montgomery County's best efforts."
asserted
That → remain → efforts
Montgomery County residents defying the restrictive gun law choose a course of action that seems sensible to them.
asserted
that → defy → them
…and 1 more, not listed.
