This week, the Trump administration announced it's expanding its stake in semiconductor manufacturer GlobalFoundries.
asserted
it → announce → GlobalFoundries
This brings the government's share of the company to over $2 billion, according to President Donald Trump, and it's only one of roughly three dozen companies in which this White House has acquired a piece of the action.
uncertain
House → bring → action
This is a disturbing development for Americans who favor free enterprise and don't want the government to control the means of production.
asserted
government → favor → production
While it may be a while before the opportunity arises to roll back state intervention in the economy, given the drift of both major parties away from faith in the marketplace, the Cato Institute has launched a project to get the process started.
uncertain
process → arise → project
You are reading The Rattler from J.D. Tuccille and Reason.
asserted
You → read → Tuccille
$2 Billion Government Stake in One of 35 Once-Private Firms
"The U.S. Department of Commerce will receive equity in GF of approximately four percent, further enabling the American public to share in GF's growth," GlobalFoundries announced Monday in a press release about a U.S.–Japanese initiative to open two new semiconductor manufacturing facilities.
asserted
GlobalFoundries → receive → facilities
"This brings our total Investments to 1.63 Billion Dollars, and now, the U.S. Government's stake is worth over 2 Billion Dollars," Trump confirmed on Truth Social.
asserted
Trump → bring → Social
The announcement's triumphant tone isn't necessarily shared by people who wonder what the government's ownership stake in one company will do to regulation and investment in the industry.
asserted
stake → share → industry
Will fully private firms challenging a state-backed player experience an even playing field?
asserted
firms → challenge → field
In a July CNBC survey of 1,000 U.S. voters, 49 percent of respondents said it is "not appropriate for the federal government to own a portion of a U.S.-based company."
asserted
government → say → company
Nineteen percent considered it appropriate, and 32 percent had no opinion.
asserted
percent → consider → opinion
"Washington's expanding involvement in the businesses it regulates threatens the competition and innovation that underpin American prosperity," warns the Cato Institute's Tad DeHaven on the launch of the Restoring Free Enterprise project.
asserted
DeHaven → expand → project
"Our project will examine the consequences of that involvement and chart a path toward getting Washington out of the boardroom."
Restoring Free Enterprise's Government Ownership Dashboard shows the U.S. government owning shares in 35 companies.
asserted
government → examine → companies
The recent deal with GlobalFoundries comes on top of an earlier equity stake, giving the government 7 percent ownership of the firm.
asserted
deal → come → firm
Other big deals include an 8.4 percent stake in Intel, a claim on 20 percent of distributions above $17.5 billion in Westinghouse, and an arrangement granting the U.S. government the right to appoint a director for U.S. Steel and to veto decisions over matters including investment and production.
uncertain
deals → include → investment
When Government Enters the Market, Competition Is Undermined and Decisions Politicized
asserted
Decisions → enter → Market
In an analysis for the Center for Strategic and International Studies, Sujai Shivakumar, Charles Wessner, and Christina Tutino cautioned that direct government ownership could create "conflicts between the role of the government as an investor in a particular company and its role as a regulator (e.g., regarding export controls) of firms across the wider industry."
uncertain
ownership → caution → industry
They added that preferential treatment for state-linked forms could "distort competition, stifle innovation, and potentially lead to monopolies or market concentration in strategic sectors.
uncertain
treatment → add → sectors
"
"Once government crosses the line into equity ownership, the game changes," agreed economist Vance Ginn in a 2025 piece for the American Institute for Economic Research.
asserted
Ginn → cross → Research
"It's no longer about setting fair rules of the road—it's about Washington joining the race as a participant.
asserted
Washington → set → participant
That undermines competition, politicizes corporate decisions, and exposes taxpayers to risks they never agreed to take."
Basically, when the government gets involved in any industry, it complicates matters for the companies in which shares are held, for competitors who must worry that regulators will put their thumbs on the scale to help favored firms, and for the market in general.
asserted
regulators → undermine → market
Overall, government interference of any sort in market transactions does more harm than good, and direct ownership makes things even worse.
asserted
things → do → harm
"Federal rate controls, excessive taxes, barriers to restructuring, and rigid labor rules weakened private railroads in the mid-20th century, just as automobiles, buses, trucks, and airlines were intensifying competition," Cato's Chris Edwards points out in a case study for the Restoring Free Enterprise Project.
asserted
Edwards → weaken → Project
Congress then created Amtrak to maintain the passenger train service its red tape had helped strangle, but despite plans for the railroad to be self-sufficient, "it has never earned a profit and has received tens of billions of dollars in subsidies."
asserted
it → create → subsidies
The project acknowledges the Trump administration's intention to encourage U.S. manufacturing and to meet strategic defense goals.
asserted
project → acknowledge → goals
But it points out that private, profit-seeking firms are what made the U.S. prosperous and dominant in so many fields to begin with.
asserted
U.S. → point → fields
The government should get out of the way of the market if it wants the country to continue to thrive.
asserted
country → get → market
As alternatives to state ownership of companies, Restoring Free Enterprise proposes permitting and regulatory reforms that "shorten reviews, remove unnecessary requirements, reform the Jones Act, and recognize out-of-state licenses" for workers.
asserted
that → restore → workers
The project also recommends free trade agreements that reduce barriers to international commerce, the removal of export and procurement barriers, tax reforms involving expensing, and immigration reforms that simplify processing and make it easier for foreign-born college graduates to remain in the U.S.
The obstacles to implementing these reforms are substantial.
asserted
obstacles → recommend → reforms
The administration, while criticizing the Democratic Party's growing affection for socialism, itself embraces government ownership of companies, mercantilism, and heavy state intervention in economic decisions and activities.
asserted
administration → criticize → decisions
The Democratic Party has long been less market-oriented than the Republicans, and despite the GOP's transformation, a growing share of Democrats are openly socialist advocates for state control.
asserted
share → orient → control
"American political leaders on the left and right are rebelling against the market-first consensus that dominated Washington for four decades," concluded Axios's Courtenay Brown and Neil Irwin in July.
asserted
Brown → rebel → July
"It's evident in everything from the Trump administration taking government stakes in dozens of private companies to socialist candidates winning Democratic primaries promising a more active government role in the economy.
asserted
administration → take → economy
U.S. politicians are happily adopting damaging policies that are at odds with the country's prosperity-building tradition of free markets.
asserted
that → adopt → markets
The Restoring Free Enterprise project would reverse that unfortunate trend, but it's not obvious that many people in D.C. are interested in joining the fight.
asserted
people → restore → fight
The Aporia
