The Seattle Times wasted little time.
asserted
Times → waste → time
The morning after independent journalist Nick Shirley retracted his allegation that Lam's Seafood Asian Market — a staple of Seattle's International District — had engaged in EBT fraud, the newspaper published a story about it.
asserted
newspaper → retract → it
It was exactly the kind of article the Times should have been writing, as Shirley's dubious claims threatened the livelihood of the family that owns the business, which maintained it had been wrongly accused.
uncertain
it → write → business
Holding journalists accountable for their mistakes is precisely what newspapers are supposed to do.
asserted
newspapers → hold → what
But what happens when it's The Seattle Times making the dubious claims?
uncertain
it → happen → claims
Seems the same standards don't apply.
asserted
standards → seem → ?
On Nov. 8, the Times published a story examining why Washington voters overwhelmingly supported Initiative 638, which would prohibit biological males from competing in girls' K-12 sports.
asserted
which → publish → sports
And as I've said before, the paper deserves credit for including voices on both sides of the issue.
asserted
paper → say → issue
But midway through the piece came a paragraph that made me wonder how many editors had actually read it.
asserted
editors → come → it
"There is no serious scientific evidence that trans girls or women are better athletes than cisgender girls or women.
asserted
girls → be → girls
A few transgender girls have won at the high school level, but across the U.S., just a few trans women have competed at elite college or professional levels, and none have dominated their sport.
asserted
none → win → sport
Since then, a slew of writers have challenged the Times' assertion, pointing to scientific research that suggests otherwise.
Seattle Red radio host Jason Rantz cited a 2020 study of U.S. Air Force personnel showing that transgender women were still 12% faster than biological females in a 1.5-mile run after two years of hormone therapy.
Investigative journalist Benjamin Ryan, meanwhile, reposted an old Substack essay that linked to a 2025 scientific paper finding that substantial advantages in strength, power, size and aerobic capacity can remain after testosterone suppression.
uncertain
advantages → challenge → suppression
He also cited a 2020 review showing that transgender women typically lose just 5% of their muscle mass after a year of hormone therapy.
asserted
women → cite → therapy
Then there was former New York Times and current Sport and State writer Karen Crouse, who cited a 2021 review finding that strength, lean mass and muscle size remained above female levels even after three years of hormone treatment.
asserted
strength → be → treatment
She also pointed to a 2023 American College of Sports Medicine consensus statement documenting the performance advantages males typically develop during puberty.
asserted
males → point → puberty
That's a lot of scientific evidence for something the Times says doesn't exist.
asserted
Times → say → something
Ryan showed me a screenshot of one of the story's reporters thanking him for his feedback before saying, "I've shared this with our team."
asserted
I → show → team
Krouse wrote that she reached out to multiple editors for clarification but received no response.
asserted
she → write → response
Monday, I emailed the Times' executive editor, managing editor and PR representative for comment but did not hear back.
asserted
I → email → comment
Included in my email were links to the aforementioned writers' critiques followed by this question: "Could it be that the Times doesn't consider this evidence to be 'serious'?
uncertain
evidence → include → question
"
What would worry me, if I were the publisher, is whether fewer and fewer people are viewing that paper as serious.
asserted
people → worry → paper
To publish a claim contradicted by peer-reviewed research and then leave repeated requests for clarification unanswered is a study in either pride or cowardice.
uncertain
publish → publish → pride
Journalists make mistakes.
asserted
Journalists → make → mistakes
I've made plenty myself.
asserted
I → make → plenty
But those mistakes should be followed by accountability, not avoidance.
asserted
mistakes → follow → accountability
What do you think of the Seattle Times' handling of the criticism?
asserted
you → think → criticism
Let me know at Matthew.calkins@outkick.com
asserted
me → let → Matthew.calkins@outkick.com