I held off weighing in on The Seattle Times’s latest effort to erase biology, so certain was I that a retraction or, at the very least, an editor’s note, was forthcoming, rendering my voice unnecessary.
asserted
voice → hold → least
For reasons known only to them — multiple editors at the newspaper to whom I reached out by email for clarification failed to respond — the newspaper that “enlightens, informs and engages with storytelling that is as dynamic and vibrant as our region” is standing by an entirely baseless assertion, made in a whopper of a story last weekend attempting to make sense of why Washington voters passed Initiative 638, which bars biological males from girls sports, from kindergarten through 12th grade:
“There is no serious scientific evidence that trans girls or women are better athletes than cisgender girls or women.
asserted
girls → know → girls
A few transgender girls have won at the high school level, but across the US, just a few trans women have competed a elite college or professional levels, and none have dominated their sport.
asserted
none → win → sport
My old shop, the Seattle Times, actually published a piece claiming there’s “no serious scientific evidence” trans women are better athletes than biological women.
asserted
women → publish → women
It’s another example of a paper that has abandoned journalistic integrity for activism.
asserted
that → ’ → activism
The paragraph could only have been written by journalists who played with anatomically incorrect Ken dolls as children.
uncertain
who → write → children
Meantime, back in the real world, there’s an abundance of evidence proving beyond a shadow of a doubt that biological boys at any age are physiologically equipped to perform better in sports than biological girls.
asserted
boys → ’ → girls
Let’s look at my favorite sport, swimming.
asserted
’s → look → sport
Being a time-based sport, it contains a treasure trove of documented evidence to show that at every age the best boys are faster than the best girls.
asserted
boys → base → girls
It’s contained in something called a record book.
asserted
It → contain → something
A quick glance at the long-course national age-group records for boys and girls aged 10 and under shows that in nine of the 11 individual events, the boys’ mark is faster – by an average of 0.70 seconds in the 50-meter events, 0.90 in the 100s, 2.60 seconds in the 200s and 7 seconds in the 400-meter event.
asserted
mark → age → event
In the 100 breaststroke, Meaghan Lynch in 2014 went 0.82 faster than the fastest-ever boy.
asserted
Lynch → go → boy
Interestingly, by the time swimmers hit the next age-group level, 11-12, the boys are significantly faster in every event.
asserted
boys → hit → event
“Boys start growing then,” Sheehan, now a senior on the Arizona State women’s swim team, said Friday by telephone.
asserted
Sheehan → grow → telephone
“Sometimes girls can start growing a little earlier.”
asserted
girls → start → ?
Sheehan described her 50 butterfly time as a 10-year-old as “a big flex for me.”
asserted
Sheehan → describe → me
Asked what would happen now if she raced against the butterflyers on the men’s team, Sheehan said, “Oh, gosh, I definitely would be slower than the slowest boy.”
asserted
I → ask → boy
That’s how biology rolls.
asserted
biology → ’ → ?
Sheehan’s career-best in the 50-meter butterfly of 26.56 is the 83rd-fastest performance in history by a woman affiliated with a United States Swimming club.
asserted
best → affiliate → club
Four men are tied for the 82nd-fastest performance at 23.59.
asserted
men → tie → 23.59
In researching this topic, I stumbled upon the X account of Matt Marshall, a Washington state representative who filleted The Seattle Times’ argument like a Michelin chef.
asserted
who → research → chef
He quoted The American College of Sports Medicine, which in 2023 released a consensus statement stating the obvious: males typically outperform females by 10 to 30 percent in endurance, strength, speed and power events, with the performance gap tied to male puberty.
asserted
gap → quote → puberty
The Seattle Times says there is “no serious scientific evidence” that trans girls or women are better athletes than girls and women.
asserted
girls → say → girls
I’m a WA licensed medical provider who specializes in sports medicine, so I’ll be blunt: that sentence is false, and the Times doesn’t name one study to back it up.
asserted
Times → ’m → it
No expert said it.
asserted
expert → say → it
The reporters just wrote it.
asserted
reporters → write → it
Here’s what they left out:
asserted
they → ’ → what
• The American College of Sports Medicine’s 2023 consensus statement: males typically outperform females by 10–30% in endurance, strength, speed and power events, and the gap is tied to male puberty.
asserted
gap → outperform → puberty
• A 2021 British Journal of Sports Medicine review of 24 studies: strength, lean mass and muscle size stayed above female levels even after 36 months of hormone treatment.
asserted
strength → stay → treatment
• U.S. Air Force fitness records: after two years of treatment, trans women still ran the 1.5-mile test 12% faster than the female average.
asserted
women → run → average
And I-638 covers K-12 kids, most of whom aren’t on any hormones at all.
asserted
most → cover → hormones
Ask the Camas cross-country girls who walked off the course in October whether this advantage is “serious.”
asserted
advantage → ask → October
More than 1.25 million Washingtonians, 56.6%, voted to protect girls’ sports.
asserted
Washingtonians → vote → sports
Now the Times is trying to talk them out of what they saw with their own eyes, while Seattle’s school board and mayor go to court to undo their vote.
asserted
board → try → vote
I-638 takes effect Dec. 3.
asserted
I-638 → take → effect
With a House supermajority that can now amend initiatives, I’ll fight any attempt to gut it, and I’ll keep correcting the record every time the Seattle Times won’t.
asserted
Times → amend → record
— Matt Marshall (@Matt4_Liberty) November 13, 2026
Marshall also quoted a 2021 British Journal of Sports Medicine review that concluded that strength, lean mass and muscle size stayed above female levels after three years of hormone treatment.
asserted
strength → quote → treatment
He highlighted a US Air Force review of fitness records, which showed that after two years of hormone treatment, trans women were 12 percent faster than the female average in the timed one-and-a-half mile run.
asserted
women → highlight → run
Fundamental right of Title IX
As a child of Title IX, even a single biological male in female sports is infuriating because, at the end of the day, the athlete born with the penis is not really at the heart of the issue.
asserted
athlete → bear → issue
It’s about the fundamental right granted to biological women by Title IX to have female-only sports.
asserted
It → ’ → sports
…and 15 more, not listed.