Do school cellphone bans work?
asserted
bans → work → ?
New study says yes – but it's complicated
Do school cellphone bans work?
asserted
bans → say → ?
New study says yes – but it's complicated
asserted
it → say → ?
The rise of smartphones in the U.S. coincided with a dramatic slide in K-12 students' reading and math achievement.
asserted
rise → coincide → achievement
Now, new research suggests putting students' phones in locked pouches during the school day may help restore some of those historic losses.
uncertain
putting → suggest → losses
"Around 2013, U.S. students started losing 2-3 weeks of learning each year," says Harvard University's Tom Kane, one of the new study's co-authors.
asserted
Kane → start → authors
"It's been a slow leak that, over time, has put U.S. 8th graders almost a year behind.
asserted
that → put → graders
Strict cellphone bans seem to plug about half of that leak.
asserted
bans → seem → leak
That's a small but, according to Kane, statistically significant improvement.
uncertain
That → accord → Kane
"That could add up over time, just as the initial declines did," adds Dartmouth College's Douglas Staiger, another co-author.
uncertain
Staiger → add → time
The study's authors say it is the first nationwide analysis of student-level test scores in math and reading both before and after schools enforced locked-pouch cellphone bans.
asserted
schools → say → bans
Kane, Staiger and their teams analyzed a nationwide sample of more than 3 million elementary-, middle- and high-school students over the past five school years, comparing the test scores in schools that adopted phone pouches to the scores at similar schools that did not.
asserted
that → analyze → schools
Not only did strict cellphone bans appear to trigger small learning gains, the researchers say, those gains didn't seem to fade out after the first year of implementation.
asserted
gains → appear → implementation
Instead, Kane says, the gains appeared to continue, year after year – at least up to three years after adoption.
asserted
gains → say → adoption
Research on phone bans is mix
Tuesday's headline finding, that locking phones during the school day led to small but statistically significant improvements in math and reading scores, comes with an important caveat:
A separate study, from April, found that these pouches had "close to zero" impact on student test scores – and if there was a benefit, it was not statistically significant.
"Overall, we didn't find evidence of meaningful achievement gains," says Brian Jacob, a co-author of that April study and a professor of education policy at the University of Michigan.
asserted
Jacob → lock → Michigan
What should we make of these seemingly contradictory results?
asserted
we → make → results
Both are large-scale studies by well-respected teams of researchers.
asserted
Both → respect → researchers
The April study has been peer-reviewed; the more recent study has not.
asserted
study → review → ?
Both studies similarly focused on schools' adoption of lockable pouches made by the for-profit company Yondr.
asserted
studies → focus → company
According to Tuesday's paper, more than 3,300 schools nationwide began using the pouches between the '19-'20 and '25-'26 school years.
uncertain
schools → accord → years
Typically, schools that use the pouches require that students put their phones in them at the beginning of the day and don't get them back until the end of the school day, when the pouches are unlocked by a school administrator with a special magnetic device.
asserted
pouches → use → device
But the two studies also differ in key ways.
asserted
studies → differ → ways
The April study pooled school-level mean test scores at several thousand Yondr-adopting schools, while Tuesday's study used student-level scores at the 844 schools that use both Yondr pouches and tests administered by NWEA.
asserted
that → pool → NWEA
Simply put, the study released Tuesday had more fine-grain, student-level data, but the study released in April was able to examine a much larger sample of schools.
asserted
study → put → schools
But the two studies' findings also aren't as different as they may seem.
uncertain
they → seem → ?
Jacob and his co-authors did find statistically significant gains with Yondr pouches in high school math.
asserted
Jacob → find → math
It's just that those gains were offset by ban-related learning losses in middle school.
asserted
gains → offset → school
Overall, Jacob says, the new study "is encouraging.
asserted
study → say → ?
And if [the benefit] really persists and accumulates over time, it really could be a meaningful benefit.
uncertain
it → persist → time
I think we'll just have to wait and see if that happens."
asserted
that → think → ?
Another co-author of that April study, Tom Dee, a professor at Stanford University's Graduate School of Education, says of Tuesday's findings, "I hope they are right that these very small test score gains will aggregate and add up over time.
asserted
gains → say → time
However, I'm not comfortable making that extrapolation from estimates that are small, sensitive and based on just a few years of phone bans."
asserted
that → make → bans
Taken together, Dee says, he considers the results from these early studies into cellphone bans "largely disappointing," and insists "we need continued study on this topic."
Kane sees the results differently.
asserted
Kane → take → results
Even if the benefit is small, he argues, relative to the cost – roughly $25 per student – these pouches still make financial sense for schools.
asserted
pouches → argue → schools
"That's still a lot less than having to pay teachers for an extra week or two of instruction.
asserted
That → have → instruction
When it all went wrong
For nearly a quarter-century, from 1990 to 2013, math achievement among fourth- and eighth-graders rose steadily.
asserted
achievement → go → graders
Reading scores also improved.
asserted
scores → improve → ?
Then around 2013, student test scores began a sustained tumble that continued through the COVID-19 pandemic and has only recently begun to slow.
asserted
that → begin → pandemic
For years, politicians and pundits blamed pandemic-era school closures for the losses, but the data tells a different story.
asserted
data → blame → story
"Particularly in reading, test scores were going down for four to six years before the pandemic," Stanford University researcher Sean Reardon told NPR earlier this year.
asserted
Reardon → go → NPR
…and 10 more, not listed.