Education Dept. renews an old fight
The U.S. Department of Education recently announced it was investigating Fayetteville Public Schools in Arkansas, much to the district's surprise.
The reason, according to a department press release: Teachers there "were directed to take students' racial identities into account when issuing discipline as part of an effort to bring about 'restorative justice' to address 'the disproportionality of discipline on students of color.'"
Superintendent John Mulford says the district received notice of the investigation roughly two hours before the department publicly named Fayetteville as a target in its national release.
"
uncertain
department → renew → release
We're a little shocked at this point and completely in the dark as to what this is even about," Mulford says.
asserted
Mulford → say → what
In the same announcement, the department's Office for Civil Rights (OCR) issued new federal guidance warning school leaders that they should not consider a student's race in discipline matters or they would risk being investigated.
asserted
they → issue → matters
"The hardest part to swallow," Mulford says, is that "ever since I've been here, we've done extensive work around the consistency of our discipline policy… so that it takes away any ambiguity at all."
asserted
it → swallow → ambiguity
And that, Mulford says, "aligns very well with [federal civil rights law]."
asserted
Mulford → say → law
That's why, he says, he's "a little taken aback."
asserted
he → say → ?
For now, he's left to wait for clarity from the department.
asserted
he → leave → department
The new guidance and the Fayetteville investigation reopen an old and bitter civil rights fight over discipline in the nation's K-12 schools — and what qualifies as discrimination.
asserted
what → reopen → discrimination
The potential for discrimination in school discipline
Multiple federal investigations have found that discrimination still plagues America's schools, even as it's been illegal for decades, thanks to federal civil rights law.
But what if a school policy seems neutral — until you dig into its impact on students?
asserted
you → find → students
data shows that the policy is disproportionately hurting one group?
asserted
policy → show → group
In 2014, the Obama administration issued guidance to the nation's schools arguing that discipline data — showing who was being suspended or expelled, for how long and how frequently — often revealed large, potentially discriminatory impacts on students of color.
asserted
who → issue → color
According to federal data at the time, the guidance said, African-American students represented just 15% of students overall but 35% of students suspended once and 44% of students suspended more than once.
uncertain
students → accord → students
(NPR has reported that this trend actually begins in preschool.)
asserted
trend → report → preschool
An American Psychological Association task force found no evidence that these disparities reflected differences in student behavior; instead, the APA said they "may be due to lack of teacher preparation in classroom management, lack of training in culturally competent practices, or racial stereotypes."
Reflecting on why she sent that 2014 memo, Catherine Lhamon, who ran OCR under Presidents Obama and Biden, tells NPR, given our nation's history, not looking carefully at school discipline rates through the lens of race would have been an abdication.
uncertain
looking → find → race
"The very first desegregation agreements that [OCR] was created by Congress to enforce included requirements that discriminatory discipline practices end," Lhamon says.
asserted
Lhamon → create → requirements
These practices, she says, are "a feature of discrimination.
asserted
she → say → discrimination
And it's something that we have seen persist in schools over decades.
asserted
we → see → decades
And so, as head of the department's civil rights enforcement unit, Lhamon warned school leaders that these disparities were not acceptable and "give rise to concerns that schools may be engaging in racial discrimination that violates the Federal civil rights laws."
In other words, they needed to look hard at their data to see if the numbers revealed meaningful racial disparities.
uncertain
numbers → warn → disparities
If so, they could be investigated by the U.S. government.
uncertain
they → investigate → government
Schools got the message.
asserted
Schools → get → message
In the years after that 2014 guidance, NPR reported that many school districts mounted a dramatic shift away from suspension and expulsion and toward the use of policies that kept students in school, including restorative justice, which emphasizes dialogue and mediation over punishment.
asserted
which → report → punishment
By 2018, NPR reported that the share of students suspended at least once had dropped from 5.6% to 4.7%, with Hispanic students seeing a 30% drop.
asserted
students → report → drop
Black students and students with disabilities also saw big drops, though suspension rates for both groups remained high.
asserted
rates → see → groups
Enforcement of this policy continued even into the first Trump administration.
asserted
Enforcement → continue → administration
In late 2018, OCR reached an agreement with Wake County Public School System in North Carolina after finding that, among other things, Black students being disciplined for their first offense were more likely to be suspended than similarly situated white students.
asserted
students → reach → students
The backlash
After the 2014 guidance, conservative critics accused Lhamon of heavy-handedness, arguing that districts began going easy on disruptive, perhaps dangerous students out of a fear that any difference in their discipline rates between student groups would be considered discrimination.
asserted
difference → accuse → groups
In 2018, conservative commentator Max Eden, who would go on to work in the second Trump administration, wrote that "school districts must never again be presumed guilty and unable to prove their innocence, and kids should never again be put in danger because of statistics."
asserted
kids → go → statistics
Eden argued that these relaxed discipline policies may also have made classrooms more disruptive.
In December 2018, a game of ping pong began: The first Trump administration issued new guidance formally rescinding Lhamon's.
uncertain
administration → argue → Lhamon
In 2023, after returning to lead the Biden-era OCR, Lhamon again advised schools that they could be held accountable if their discipline data revealed concerning disparities.
uncertain
data → return → disparities
But the backlash also continued, fueled by a COVID-driven spike in student misbehavior, which led to more classroom disruptions and stories of teachers feeling victimized by students.
asserted
which → continue → students
Classroom discipline even became a talking point in the 2024 presidential campaign.
asserted
discipline → become → campaign
The Republican platform pledged candidates "will support overhauling standards on school discipline [and] advocate for immediate suspension of violent students."
asserted
candidates → pledge → students
In April 2025, after Trump's return to the White House, he made good on that pledge and signed an executive order titled, "Reinstating Common Sense School Discipline Policies."
And finally, there's this month's guidance, signed by Kimberly Richey, the current head of OCR.
asserted
he → make → OCR
In an interview with NPR, Richey says that, today, "classrooms are less safe, they are more disruptive, and that is all a fruit of this policy.
asserted
that → say → policy
And that's why we're ending it."
asserted
we → end → it
The new guidance
The latest guidance from the Trump administration argues that, under the previous policy, "schools ignored or covered up — rather than disciplined — student misconduct to avoid any purported racial disparity in discipline numbers that might catch the eye of the federal government.
uncertain
that → argue → government
As a result, students who should have been suspended, expelled, or otherwise held accountable for dangerous or disruptive behavior remained in the classroom."
asserted
who → suspend → classroom
Richey argues the goal of OCR's previous approach was what she calls "racial balance": "To make sure that the number of African-American students [being disciplined], the number of Hispanic students, the number of white students, the number of Asian students — that it was equal across the board."
asserted
it → argue → board
But, Richey says, this idea that any difference in discipline rates is a sign of discrimination — "that everything has to be equal and, if it's not, it's inherently discriminatory…
asserted
it → say → discrimination
In the new guidance, Richey doesn't just warn schools against this kind of balancing.
asserted
Richey → warn → balancing
…and 20 more, not listed.
The Aporia
