Alberta referendum tallies reveal rural-urban divide on ‘the 9’
Support for immigration, constitutional questions stemmed mostly from rural ridings
Elections
asserted
Support → reveal → ridings
Alberta officials are finishing counting referendum ballots, but the results so far suggest Albertans in rural areas seem to hold different views on immigration and constitutional fights than those living in urban areas.
asserted
Albertans → finish → areas
The agency confirmed its unofficial count Saturday night.
asserted
agency → confirm → count
Results suggest more Albertans overall support the proposals in questions 1 to 5, which focused on immigration and access to services for non-permanent residents, and oppose the proposals in questions 6 to 9, which pertained to various constitutional issues.
asserted
which → suggest → issues
Most support for any of the questions that have come to be known as “the nine” — because so much focus was on Question 10, which asked about Alberta’s place in Canada — came from rural ridings, while voters in Calgary and Edmonton were more divided, if not firmly against them.
“We've long seen urban-rural divide over things like immigration, and that partly tracks with the fact that … rural places tend to be more conservative than urban places,” Feodor Snagovsky, an associate professor of political science at the University of Alberta, told CBC News, adding that those on the political right tend to have “more restrictive views” on immigration.
asserted
those → come → immigration
Follow all of our Alberta referendum coverage
Smith scores slim majority on immigration questions, Albertans reject constitutional changes
The immigration questions focused on ideas like requiring voters to prove their Canadian citizenship to cast ballots in provincial elections, the provincial government taking more control of immigration — more of a federal responsibility, historically — and imposing conditions on non-permanent residents’ access to services like health care and education.
asserted
government → follow → care
The constitutional questions regarded issues like provinces — not the feds — being able to make judicial appointments and trying to abolish the federal Senate.
asserted
provinces → regard → Senate
Given the results so far, political analysts suggest Premier Danielle Smith’s government did not get a strong mandate on the proposals it put forward in the referendum.
asserted
it → give → referendum
During an interview with CBC podcast West of Centre Friday, Smith said she believes voters told her government to proceed with caution, but that there is a desire to get more control over economic migration.
asserted
voters → say → migration
The referendum was worth holding, she said, and it showed her that Albertans are more concerned about immigration policy than pursuing constitutional change — and her government will prioritize taking action on those proposed measures.
asserted
government → hold → measures
“People want to be fair, they want to be generous, but we can solve a lot of the problems by focusing our newcomer population on the jobs that are available,” Smith said, adding that someone landing in the province with a well-paying job probably relies less on social services.
asserted
someone → want → services
“When somebody makes a commitment to being a permanent taxpayer, as a permanent resident, they’ll get the same programs as everyone else.
asserted
they → make → everyone
If we can fix that part, then I think it will reduce some of the stress on our health-care and education and other systems.”
asserted
it → fix → care
When asked about the dissension in Alberta’s two largest cities, Smith argued that most of the jobs that the province needs to attract people from elsewhere to fill are located outside of those centres, thus rural voters might have felt more strongly about immigration.
uncertain
voters → ask → immigration
Opposition to immigration in rural areas, at least in part, stems from concerns about Canada’s Temporary Foreign Worker Program, Snagovsky said, adding he believes there is room for a conversation about ensuring employers are using that appropriately.
asserted
employers → stem → that
Moving forward, however, the referendum’s apparent rural-urban divide forces Smith to walk a political tightrope, said Lisa Young, a University of Calgary political science professor.
asserted
Young → move → Calgary
Most MLAs for the governing United Conservative Party represent rural ridings, but 11 of them represent Calgary ridings.
asserted
11 → govern → ridings
Edmonton’s districts are all represented by the Opposition NDP.
asserted
districts → represent → NDP
Data suggests Question 5 — about proving Canadian citizenship to vote in provincial elections — was the only one of “the nine” that a majority of voters supported across all UCP-held ridings.
uncertain
majority → suggest → ridings
But for the rest, some of the UCP’s Calgary ridings — including those held by cabinet ministers like Demetrios Nicolaides and Mike Ellis — either objected to, or narrowly supported, the proposals that were put forward.
asserted
that → include → proposals
“The results of the referendum suggest that [Smith’s] hold on Calgary seats is maybe not as strong as it was in the past, so the viability of her coalition strategy now is in question,” Young said.
asserted
Young → suggest → question
The next general election is set for October 2027.
asserted
election → set → October
For the governing UCP to hold on to power, Young said, the premier must figure out how to maintain rural support, while also appealing to at least some urban Albertans.
asserted
premier → govern → Albertans
Elections Alberta is set to release its official referendum results Thursday, two days after the fall session gets underway in Alberta’s legislature.
asserted
session → set → legislature
The provincial government issued a news release Friday that listed multiple issues about which it intends to propose legislation.
asserted
it → issue → legislation
Young said she assumes the government has already drafted legislation related to the referendum issues.
asserted
government → say → issues
She said she will be watching for whether the government hesitates to introduce anything because of the referendum results, and if it uses Section 33 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedom — the notwithstanding clause — to pass certain items.
asserted
it → say → items
“It’s going to be telling whether this legislation now comes forward — and in what form,” Young said.
asserted
Young → go → form
The Aporia
