In short:
Small business advocates say tax reforms that would see a 30 per cent minimum tax on discretionary trusts are a "kick in the gut" and another cost for tradies.
asserted
that → say → tradies
One expert says the way discretionary trusts are being used to offset tax bills is "bordering on a joke".
What's next?
If the bill passes, the reforms would come into effect in July 2028.
asserted
reforms → say → July
Small business advocates say it is a misconception that trusts are only used by wealthy families to minimise tax, but one expert says the current system is "bordering on a joke" and in urgent need of reform.
asserted
system → say → reform
On Wednesday, Treasurer Jim Chalmers introduced a bill that would impose a 30 per cent minimum tax on discretionary trusts starting July 2028 to try to discourage people and businesses from using the arrangement to minimise taxable income.
asserted
that → introduce → income
Discretionary trusts differ from other types of trusts as they allow the trustees to change beneficiaries and how much they receive each year.
asserted
they → differ → much
Associate Professor Dale Boccabella from the University of New South Wales's Business School of Accounting, Auditing and Taxation told The Business some trusts were being used to distribute income in a way to offset tax bills.
asserted
trusts → tell → bills
"It's bordering on a joke,"he said.
"
asserted
It → border → joke,"he
A 17-year-old beneficiary of a discretionary trust, not allocated anything for years and years, and all of a sudden they turn 18, this is a child of the parents, and they get $22,500.
asserted
they → allocate → 22,500
Now why do they get $22,500 allocated?
asserted
22,500 → get → ?
"In a discretionary trust, you can have a two-day-old baby born on the 28th of June being allocated $22,500.
asserted
baby → have → 22,500
I mean, you can see how silly it is."
asserted
it → mean → ?
He said in some cases, the income allocated did not get paid to the children and stayed with the parents.
asserted
income → say → parents
The treasurer said the reforms would affect less than 10 per cent of small businesses; however, Housing Industry Association managing director Jocelyn Martin said there were costs beyond the tax changes.
asserted
Martin → say → changes
"Even before they know whether that structure is going to impact them, they have to seek advice from their lawyer or their accountant, and our members are saying that that could cost anywhere between $10,000 and $25,000
uncertain
that → know → 10,000
," she said.
"
asserted
she → say → ?
It's not enough to say that these changes just impact a small proportion; they impact a large proportion.
asserted
they → say → proportion
Maybe the result might be that they don't have to restructure, but they need to do the work to find out whether that's what's going to happen or not."
uncertain
what → have → work
Growing number of trusts
More than 1 million trusts are operating in Australia, with about 84 per cent of them discretionary.
asserted
cent → grow → them
The number of discretionary trusts has doubled since 2001–02.
asserted
number → double → 2001–02
About one in six small businesses used discretionary trusts in 2022-23, the last year of available data, with Treasury analysis suggesting 140,000 businesses of an estimated 350,000 would not need to pay the new tax.
asserted
businesses → use → tax
Ms Martin said about three in five small businesses in the housing industry used a trust structure.
asserted
businesses → say → structure
"I think there's an assumption that a trust structure is just something that wealthy people use to avoid or minimise taxes," she said.
asserted
she → think → taxes
"What we see are small businesses that are using the legitimate structure of a trust to manage their business, manage the cycles, the cash flow cycles, to actually pay themselves in a lot of instances as well, because some of our members have said they will pay themselves in good times and not necessarily be able to in bad times," she said.
asserted
she → see → times
Questioned on how much tax tradies currently pay, given that the proposed change introduces a 30 per cent minimum, Ms Martin said the HIA's concern was that the change was an additional cost to residential construction.
asserted
change → question → construction
"Already we know that the tax that is paid by our residential businesses is extremely high," she said.
asserted
she → know → businesses
"But not just that, the cost that they pay to comply with some of these business measures is also escalating all the time.
asserted
they → pay → measures
"So I think our concern really when we say there's another tax on tradies is really it's just another kick in the gut.
asserted
it → think → gut
"
Asset protection or 'economic injustice'?
Dr Boccabella said other features promoted by accountants such as asset protection, flexibility and succession planning were not being changed as part of the government's plan, although he believed they probably should be overhauled.
asserted
they → say → plan
"The other thing with discretionary trusts is that you can set them up so that they have limited liability, a bit like a company," he said.
asserted
he → set → company
"If the small business and discretionary trust fails, you might actually end up with creditors not getting their payment.
uncertain
creditors → fail → payment
"You can call that asset protection if you want, but a lot of people would turn around and say, 'Well, isn't that economic injustice, someone not getting paid for their services and goods supplied?'"
asserted
someone → call → services
Property Council executive director of capital markets, Torie Brown, said the government had ignored the legitimate concerns raised by industry during an expedited consultation process.
asserted
government → say → process
"Industry was given almost no time to consider how these radical changes will affect their businesses.
asserted
changes → give → businesses
Despite the warnings from industry, the government had decided to push ahead and introduce this legislation anyway," he said.
asserted
he → decide → legislation
"Changes to trusts is incredibly complex — pulling one thread unravels another.
asserted
pulling → pull → another
The government announced these changes without considering the impacts they would have on small business and housing supply.
asserted
they → announce → supply
"
There are also concerns that restructuring trusts would incur stamp duty at a state or territory level, something the New South Wales government has promised to waive if re-elected next year.
asserted
government → be → level
The Australian Council of Social Services (ACOSS) welcomed the changes, with CEO Cassandra Goldie saying the current system was being exploited.
asserted
system → welcome → changes
"It is not fair that someone earning $200,000 or more, who would usually pay 47 per cent tax on extra income, can bring that rate down to 30 per cent or less by passing income through a discretionary trust to their adult children or a private company, while an average worker pays tax at a rate of 30 per cent of the next dollar earned," Dr Goldie said.
asserted
Goldie → earn → dollar
"This reform helps fix this severe unfairness in the system so people on higher incomes contribute according to their ability to pay."
uncertain
people → help → ability
The Aporia
