Tiny, beautiful species are going missing from restored forests and wetlands
When larger animals and plants return, minuscule algae, mosses and lichens may not
A regrown forest can look tall, lush and green.
uncertain
forest → go → forests
Restored wetlands can buzz with insects and flutter with birds.
asserted
wetlands → restore → birds
But scientists looking more closely are finding that some of their smallest inhabitants — including certain mosses, lichens, algae and fungi — are often still missing.
asserted
some → look → mosses
Restoring habitats such as forests and wetlands can save declining species of animals and plants and help their populations bounce back.
asserted
populations → restore → animals
But recent research shows they don't all return at the same rate.
asserted
they → show → rate
Some of the smallest, least noticeable inhabitants can remain rare or absent for decades — with potential consequences for other species.
asserted
Some → remain → species
Ellen Macdonald, a University of Alberta botanist, has spent her career studying forests — but not so much the trees.
asserted
Macdonald → spend → forests
She focuses instead on the tiny flowers, mosses, liverworts and lichens that grow in their shade, among their roots or on the textured surfaces of their bark.
asserted
that → focus → bark
"There's way, way, way, way, way more species there than there is a tree species," said Macdonald.
asserted
Macdonald → be → ?
To the average person, Macdonald said, a regrown forest a few decades after logging might look much like one that had never been cut, full of tall trees, birds and insects.
uncertain
that → say → trees
But Macdonald recalled walking through regrown coniferous boreal forests and sensing that something was not quite right, even if she could not immediately identify what.
uncertain
she → recall → forests
"To really notice what was maybe missing, you'd have to be collecting data," she said.
asserted
she → notice → data
Macdonald did just that, combining her own research with data from around the world to examine how long it takes plants and animals to return as boreal forests regrow after clearcutting.
asserted
forests → do → clearcutting
The study, published recently in the journal Nature Sustainability, found that birch and aspen forests and their inhabitants appeared to recover within 25 years, while conifer forests took far longer.
asserted
forests → publish → years
In conifer forests, understory plants — especially lichens, mosses and liverworts — took 85 years or more to return, and in some cases had not recovered during the century of available data.
asserted
plants → take → data
'They may not come back easily'
uncertain
They → come → ?
Scientists studying wetlands and other restored habitats have also found that places can look healthy while some of their less visible species remain absent.
asserted
some → study → species
Years ago, CBC News spoke with German botanist Michael Melkonian about research into how plants evolved to live on land.
asserted
plants → speak → land
He described wetlands near his home in the village of Jexmühle, in southern Germany, that teemed with carnivorous plants, sphagnum mosses, frogs and dragonflies.
asserted
that → describe → plants
The bogs "superficially looked very nice," Melkonian said in a more recent interview.
asserted
Melkonian → look → interview
They had been restored and replanted decades after being drained for industrial activities such as logging, providing wildlife habitat and storing carbon to fight climate change.
asserted
They → restore → change
But beneath the water, Melkonian expected to find hundreds of species of the varied desmid algae he studies.
asserted
he → expect → algae
"The diversity of algae was not there," he said.
asserted
he → say → algae
Viktoria Wagner, an associate professor in the Department of Biological Sciences at the University of Alberta, describes this kind of decline as "a silent form of loss."
asserted
Wagner → describe → loss
Species do not necessarily go extinct entirely, she said, but disappear from many places where they once lived, reducing the number of species found at individual sites.
asserted
they → go → sites
Wagner describes this as "dark diversity" and has found evidence of it among plants in habitats around the world.
asserted
Wagner → describe → world
Once species disappear from a particular place, Melkonian said, "they may not come back easily."
uncertain
they → disappear → place
Wagner said while restoring landscapes can be possible, "it's not easy, it's not always guaranteed that it works.
asserted
it → say → landscapes
"
Missing species may slow recovery
uncertain
species → miss → recovery
Those losses can have consequences that are not immediately visible.
asserted
that → have → consequences
Despite their small size, Melkonian said, algae have an enormous effect on the availability of oxygen and food on the planet.
asserted
algae → say → planet
"It's thought that algae in general are responsible for half of global photosynthesis," he said.
asserted
he → think → photosynthesis
Wagner said many species have important roles in ecosystems, and when diversity declines "this trickles down" and can negatively affect other species.
asserted
this → say → species
In boreal forests, Macdonald said, it's not surprising that many mosses, lichens and other understory plants take decades to recover after a clearcut.
asserted
mosses → say → clearcut
They depend on shade and old growth trees for habitat.
asserted
They → depend → habitat
"That's all the stuff that's missing in a forest after harvesting and the things that take a really long time to recover," she said.
asserted
she → miss → time
"You know, you can't just get old big trees, except by waiting for trees to grow older."
Knowing these patterns could show people who manage landscapes like forests how to do it in a way that preserves more species.
uncertain
that → know → species
Macdonald said the research suggests conifer forests might be harvested more selectively or partially rather than clearcut.
uncertain
forests → say → ?
An algal 'zoo'
Mekonian said habitats for algae are also under threat around the world, along with the species that live in them.
asserted
that → say → them
Many algae look like little more than a smudge of colour on snow or a spot of slime on a rock or in water — forms most people might not recognize as living things.
uncertain
people → look → things
…and 8 more, not listed.
The Aporia
