How do you take T. rex's temperature?
asserted
you → take → temperature
These scientists did it
Chemistry provides 'compelling' evidence that T. rexes were warm-blooded
Scientists have long discussed whether and which dinosaurs were warm-blooded.
asserted
dinosaurs → do → whether
Now, researchers say they have used chemistry to take the temperature of two T. rexes.
asserted
they → say → rexes
It wasn't easy, acknowledged Aradhna Tripati, a professor and geochemist at the University of California, Los Angeles.
asserted
Tripati → acknowledge → California
She co-authored the research published Wednesday in the journal Science Advances, and explained it to CBC's Quirks & Quarks ahead of an interview with host Bob McDonald.
asserted
co → co → McDonald
"You would not want to go to a T. rex and stick a thermometer in its mouth or in its armpit or in its butt, you know, the way you might take temperature in a person or most other animals.
uncertain
you → want → person
"
Nor could you, considering they went extinct about 66 million years ago.
uncertain
they → consider → ?
How you take the temperature of an extinct animal
Instead, scientists used a technique that relies on chemistry that varies with temperature, and leaves signals in certain hard tissues such as tooth enamel and eggshells.
asserted
that → take → enamel
Those materials contain a mineral called bioapatite, where carbon atoms bond with oxygen.
asserted
atoms → contain → oxygen
A heavier kind of carbon atom (carbon-13, which has one more neutron than carbon-12) bonds preferentially with a heavier, rarer kind of oxygen atom (oxygen-18, rather than oxygen-16).
asserted
which → have → atom
By comparing the amount of "isotope clumping" in living animals with different body temperatures, scientists can estimate the body temperature of extinct animals, including dinosaurs.
asserted
scientists → compare → dinosaurs
In fact, UCLA scientists did that a decade ago using eggshells from titanosaurs and oviraptors, and concluded that they were both warm-blooded.
They had also analyzed teeth from some plant-eating dinosaurs, such as brachiosaurs, which have thick enamel for grinding plants.
asserted
which → do → plants
But tyrannosaurs have very thin tooth enamel, Tripati said, so getting enough tooth enamel for the analysis was tricky.
asserted
getting → have → analysis
The researchers worked on the technique with more common teeth from the megalodon, an ancient giant shark, until they could successfully do the analysis with very small samples.
uncertain
they → work → samples
Then they requested some tooth enamel from Thomas the tyrannosaur, a young adult T. rex skeleton displayed at the L.A. County Natural History Museum.
asserted
they → request → Museum
"They wouldn't let us pull a tooth off and just, you know, destroy it," Tripati recalled.
asserted
Tripati → let → it
But the scientists were permitted to shave a little bit off the sides of two teeth – "a pinch of salt amount.
asserted
scientists → permit → amount
They also managed to get a T. rex tooth fragment from a specimen identified only by a number.
asserted
They → manage → number
By analyzing the three teeth, the researchers estimated T. rex's body temperature at between 33.8 C and 38.8 C – similar to that of large mammals such as elephants and large and possibly flightless birds such as ostriches (which have temperatures between 38.1 C and 39.7 C), but lower than that of smaller birds that can fly, which tend to have body temperatures between 41.1 C and 42.1 C.
What this means for tyrannosaurs of the north
Tripati says an animal's body temperature affects its behaviour and where it can live.
uncertain
it → analyze → behaviour
A warm blooded T. rex is ... a T. rex that can go almost anywhere on the continent, including the Arctic.
asserted
that → go → Arctic
That's a very different animal from a sun-basking reptile."
asserted
That → bask → reptile
Anthony Fiorillo, a paleontologist who described a tiny tyrannosaur in Alaska a decade ago, said while predators like T. rex were speculated to have warmer body temperatures, "this paper makes a solid and compelling case."
asserted
paper → describe → case
Fiorillo, executive director of the New Mexico Museum of Natural History, added in an email that it provides "food for thought" about how dinosaurs may have adapted to life in the far north.
uncertain
dinosaurs → add → north
François Therrien, curator of dinosaur paleobiology at the Royal Tyrrell Museum in Alberta, was part of a team that used isotope clumping to analyze the eggshells of small, meat-eating dinosaurs called troodons, and found they were as warm-blooded as birds with body temperatures more than 40 C.
He said researchers knew that tyrannosaurs grew fast and weren't just sluggish, cold-blooded animals, but this study provides a more precise, confident measure of body temperature.
asserted
study → use → temperature
The fact that it had such a warm body temperature suggests T. rex could be active during the day, at night and in winter, said Therrien, and explains how tyrannosaurs could range from Mexico to Alaska, and could have crossed the Bering Strait between Asia and North America in the far north, as there's evidence they did.
uncertain
they → suggest → north
However, Therrien is not sure T. rex had quite the same kind of warm-blooded metabolism as modern mammals and birds do, which may have required more food than the ecosystem could support, given their size: "That's still subject to debate."
uncertain
That → have → debate
The Aporia
