Claims extracted
17
sentences that state something as happening or true
Uncertain
12%
2 of 17 hedged
("reportedly", "may", "according to")
Leaning
Leans left
of the writing, not the subject · beta estimate
Publisher signals
69/100
The Guardian's corrections and
hedging, across everything collected from it. Not a measure of accuracy.
Outlets on this story
2
Politics
Same framing elsewhere
1
articles that frame the event the way this one does
Russia did try to interfere in the Brexit referendum through social media and television reports, the head of MI5 said today, but he added that did not mean the Kremlin had any impact on the result.
asserted
Kremlin → try → result
Ken McCallum endorsed comments made by Andy Burnham, who raised the issue over the past two days, though he said continuing to debate it had given the Kremlin a needless propaganda victory.
asserted
continuing → endorse → victory
During an annual threat update, the head of Britain’s domestic intelligence agency said the Russian-owned English-language broadcasters RT and Sputnik “came in pretty strongly around the time of the referendum” with biased anti-migration and anti-EU reports.
asserted
broadcasters → say → reports
He said there had also been “a second line of interference attempted through [internet] trolls”: an unspecified number of fake social media accounts, operating largely on X, that had sought to influence the result.
asserted
that → say → result
Neither tactic was particularly sophisticated or successful, the spy chief said.
asserted
chief → say → ?
There was a big difference between “what may have been attempted and what actually resulted”.
uncertain
what → be → ?
Both interference attempts have been previously cited in studies released in the years after the Brexit vote.
asserted
attempts → cite → vote
The digital campaign group 89up said RT and Sputnik had published 261 mostly misleading articles highlighing immigration and other anti-EU issues that achieved 134m potential page impressions.
asserted
that → say → impressions
Other studies have reported on a “troll army” of state-linked Russian accounts tweeting about the referendum in the run-up to the vote, though estimates of numbers active have varied wildly from 54 to 150,000.
Burnham had first returned to the issue on Sunday, during a podcast interview, though at first it was unclear whether the prime minister had been given new intelligence on a topic that had largely been considered forgotten.
“I asked the question coming to Downing Street: ‘Was there interference in the 2016 referendum from Russia?’
uncertain
I → report → Russia
And I’ve had the clear answer that yes, there was,” said the prime minister, implying he had a discussion or briefing on the issue.
asserted
he → have → issue
A day later, however, he backed off when challenged by the Conservatives on whether this meant he regarded the Brexit vote as illegitimate, and he did not supply any additional information in the Commons.
asserted
he → back → Commons
On Tuesday Downing Street said it had been confirmed that Russia interfered in the 2019 general election and it was “inconceivable that they didn’t in 2016”.
asserted
they → say → 2016
But the prime minister’s spokesperson added: “We don’t believe it was successful in the British referendum in 2016.”
asserted
it → add → 2016
McCallum said it would be to Russia’s benefit if the issue was the subject of controversy for several more days.
asserted
issue → say → days
“It is up to us how far we allow our adversaries to divide us,” he said.
asserted
he → allow → us
Continued attention gave the impression that Kremlin disinformation attempts were more successful than they actually were, the MI5 chief added.
asserted
chief → continue → impression
“I’m a little bit worried that if we all stay in this debate for another few days, the Russian trolls who didn’t appear to do all that much at various points over the years, they’ll be delighted they are front-page news once again despite the comparative unimpressedness of what they do at all points along the journey,” he said.
asserted
he → ’m → journey
The Aporia
