THIS is an obituary for the National Counter Terrorism Authority, once conceived as a civilian counterterrorism body that combined policymaking, coordination among law-enforcement agencies, and data collection and processing.
asserted
that → conceive → agencies
Since its inception in December 2008, and even after gaining legal cover under the Nacta Act, 2013, it has struggled to fully realise its role and mandate, while facing resistance from LEAs reluctant to coordinate with a police-led body.
Appointing a senior military officer as its national coordinator was not the first deviation from the Nacta Act.
asserted
Appointing → gain → Act
A bigger departure from the statute had come in 2025 with the establishment of the National Intelligence Fusion and Threat Assessment Centre.
asserted
departure → come → Centre
Niftac was created as a parallel body, apparently under Nacta but in effect superior to it, even though Nacta is the statutory body.
asserted
Nacta → create → it
This gave a superior security institution the leading role.
asserted
This → give → role
Nacta’s new form seems to have little to do with developing a counterterrorism strategy, building a coordination mechanism, or taking on a CT-related operational role.
asserted
form → seem → role
Its real purpose is to synchronise all civilian-led LEAs with the superior security institution, and, at the very least, to bring them under one roof.
asserted
purpose → synchronise → roof
This synchronisation of internal security policy with the security doctrine conceived by the establishment’s top brass has been underway for a long time, taking various forms.
asserted
synchronisation → conceive → forms
Bureaucrats see it in the National Security and War Course (NSWC) at the National Defence University (NDU), which is now equivalent to the National Management Course, a mandatory course for promotion from Grade 20 to 21.
asserted
which → see → 21
The NSWC gives senior bureaucrats more opportunities to align with evolving thinking at the top levels of the security institutions.
asserted
NSWC → give → institutions
At the narrative level, NDU and many other military-led institutions run short courses for opinion-makers, politicians, and business and community leaders to align them with the new thought process.
asserted
makers → lead → process
Interestingly, all these courses and discourses happen at the expense of civilian governments, whether provincial or federal.
asserted
courses → happen → governments
Nacta, the only civilian-led CT body, struggled to find its role and eventually lost.
asserted
Nacta → lead → role
One may argue that synchronisation within the internal security structure will improve coordination, the very dream for which Nacta was conceived.
uncertain
Nacta → argue → which
However, the new changes appear to be aimed at control, and the CT body is being used as an instrument of that.
asserted
body → appear → that
The structures of other LEAs, such as the police and FIA, leave little room for intervention by other institutions — unlike Nacta.
asserted
structures → leave → Nacta
Admittedly, Nacta had a few good leaders who clearly understood the terrorism challenge facing the country and how to respond.
asserted
who → have → country
But it is safe to say that most of its heads, and even others who served in the authority, had little idea of the CT body’s objectives.
asserted
who → say → objectives
Many came on deputation, or to rest before landing a field posting.
asserted
Many → come → posting
As mentioned earlier, Nacta faced pressure and challenges from superior security institutions, which were reluctant to work under or with a civilian-led body.
asserted
which → mention → body
Still, the police cadre is undoubtedly responsible for destroying the institution and providing an excuse for its takeover.
asserted
cadre → destroy → takeover
This did not happen overnight.
asserted
This → happen → ?
The process began much earlier.
asserted
process → begin → ?
When former prime minister Imran Khan chaired the Nacta board of governors meeting in September 2018, as required by law, two key realities emerged.
asserted
realities → chair → law
One, he was the first prime minister to convene a board meeting since the Act was passed, even though quarterly meetings were required.
asserted
meetings → convene → meeting
Two, the national coordinator at the time recommended that the prime minister dissolve the body, as it had no use or role in countering terrorism in the country.
asserted
it → recommend → country
This was the first and last board meeting held under the original Act.
asserted
This → hold → Act
In July 2019, parliament amended it through an ordinance, which it later passed in March 2020.
asserted
it → amend → March
The amendment made the interior minister the board chairman and the national coordinator its secretary.
asserted
coordinator → make → ?
Several references to the “prime minister” in the Act were also replaced, shifting Nacta’s reporting line to the interior ministry.
asserted
references → replace → ministry
The 2019-2020 amendments thus downgraded Nacta from a prime minister-led federal-provincial body to one under the interior minister.
asserted
amendments → downgrade → minister
Interestingly, one of the few board meetings held since then, and chaired by Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi, approved the establishment of Niftac.
asserted
one → hold → Niftac
Just before Niftac was introduced, Nacta inducted around 130 permanent officers.
asserted
Nacta → introduce → officers
Since Niftac’s establishment, most have struggled to find a role.
asserted
most → struggle → role
Niftac was described as a national platform connecting more than 50 federal and provincial departments and agencies — supported by provincial fusion centres — to improve intelligence coordination, speed up threat assessment, and strengthen information-sharing across institutional boundaries.
asserted
Niftac → describe → boundaries
A military or intelligence institution can possess information that a civilian authority cannot access.
asserted
authority → possess → that
It can conduct operations a civilian institution cannot.
asserted
institution → conduct → operations
It can assess threats from a classified perspective.
asserted
It → assess → perspective
But the state also needs an institution that can sit openly with provincial police, civil administration, prosecutors, courts, parliamentarians, researchers and international partners.
asserted
that → need → police
It needs an institution whose authority is intelligible within the civilian legal and administrative system.
asserted
authority → need → system
…and 7 more, not listed.
The Aporia
