• As Islamabad negotiates its reapplication for critical trading scheme, EU envoy says GSP+ benefits ‘can’t be taken for granted’
asserted
benefits → negotiate → scheme
• Country may continue to receive benefits until 2028-end, but this doesn’t mean automatic rollover into new scheme
•
uncertain
this → continue → scheme
Islamabad remains engaged with bloc on ‘effective implementation of international conventions’; FO says EU assessment didn’t offer ‘sufficiently balanced picture’ of Pakistan’s performance
ISLAMABAD
asserted
assessment → remain → performance
Amid an ongoing intense engagement between Islamabad and Brussels over a trading scheme and its future, the European Union’s ambassador has cautioned that GSP+ benefits cannot be taken for granted.
asserted
benefits → caution → scheme
The cautionary note comes as the current EU Generalised Scheme of Preferences framework is set to expire at the end of this year, and Pakistan is required to seek inclusion in the successor regime, which would carry more stringent requirements.
asserted
which → come → requirements
“The government will need to take steps towards improving the situation, which will also be very important in the reapplication process,” EU Ambassador Raimundas Karoblis told Dawn.
asserted
Karoblis → need → Dawn
And, of course, GSP+ preferences cannot be taken for granted.
asserted
preferences → take → course
Though the new trading framework will take effect with the turn of the year, Pakistan and other existing beneficiaries will continue to receive preferences during a two-year transition period ending on Dec 31, 2028.
asserted
Pakistan → take → Dec
But the transition does not amount to an automatic continuation of the facility for the two-year period, or a roll over into the new scheme.
asserted
transition → amount → scheme
A European Commission assessment covering the years 2023-25, released in July this year, concluded that Pakistan had faced compliance issues with its obligations, regressed in a number of areas and made limited positive change.
asserted
Pakistan → cover → change
Moreover, while acknowledging legislative and administrative measures, it noted that much of the progress had yet to translate into improvements on the ground.
asserted
much → acknowledge → ground
The report had identified significant concerns relating to enforced disappearances and extrajudicial killings, freedom of expression, journalists’ and minority rights, judicial independence, access to justice and forced labour.
asserted
report → identify → justice
“There are areas of regression, and of course, this means that the government needs to address them,” Mr Karoblis said, adding that this applied both to the implementation of the current GSP+ convention, and its reapplication for the new scheme.
asserted
this → be → scheme
Diplomatic discussions between Pakistan and the EU suggest that Islamabad is aware of the gravity of the situation, though questions remain over whether it has yet moved decisively towards addressing the concerns that Brussels has repeatedly raised.
asserted
Brussels → suggest → that
At last week’s press briefing, Dawn asked outgoing Foreign Office Spokesperson Tahir Andrabi about how that dialogue is progressing, and how he viewed the EU’s assessment of Pakistan compliance.
asserted
he → ask → compliance
In response, the spokesperson said that while Pakistan appreciated the commission’s recognition of its continued compliance under 27 international conventions, he maintained that the report’s overall narrative did not present “a sufficiently balanced picture of Pakistan’s performance”.
asserted
narrative → say → performance
“GSP+ remains central to Pakistan’s economic relationship with the European Union, and we will remain constructively engaged with the EU and remain committed to the effective implementation of the international conventions underpinning the GSP framework
asserted
we → remain → framework
,” he said.
asserted
he → say → ?
Since GSP+ commitments straddle a wide array of sectors, Dawn sent written queries to the federal ministers for information, law and commerce last week to gain holistic perspective on how Pakistan is approaching the matter with the EU.
asserted
Pakistan → straddle → EU
However, neither the ministers nor their ministries responded to Dawn’s requests for comment.
asserted
ministers → respond → comment
It will have to demonstrate that it qualifies for the new framework while also ensuring that the deteriorations identified in the latest report do not jeopardise its existing status during the transition period.
asserted
deteriorations → have → period
Talking to Dawn, the European envoy acknowledged serious unease within the European Commission, which plays an influential role in monitoring compliance and decisions concerning the execution of the scheme.
asserted
which → talk → scheme
“Indeed, both from reading the report and from discussions with experts, there are serious doubts within the European Commission about the effective implementation of these conventions,” he said.
asserted
he → read → conventions
The EU’s GSP+ regime is tied to compliance with international conventions on human rights, labour rights, environmental protection and good governance, which Islamabad has already signed up.
asserted
Islamabad → tie → which
Pakistan has remained a beneficiary since 2014 and is the scheme’s largest beneficiary.
asserted
Pakistan → remain → 2014
In 2024, the country received nearly €732 million in tariff exemptions under GSP+, while €7.115 billion worth of its exports utilised the preferential access.
asserted
worth → receive → access
The EU accounts for about 28 per cent of Pakistan’s total exports and nearly 90pc of its exports to the bloc are GSP+ eligible.
asserted
90pc → account → bloc
The dependence on the trading scheme is particularly high in the textile and clothing sector, which accounts for between 70pc and 76pc of Pakistan’s exports to the European market.
asserted
which → account → market
Clothing, textiles, leather products, prepared foods and beverages are among the major beneficiaries.
asserted
Clothing → prepare → beneficiaries
Loss of preferential access would, therefore, have consequences beyond the immediate value of tariff exemptions and products such as textiles and clothing could lose competitiveness in one of the country’s most important export markets.
uncertain
products → have → markets
The fear of losing the preferential access is quite real, as the scheme provides for partial or full temporary withdrawal of preferences in cases of serious failure to comply with the underlying conventions.
asserted
scheme → lose → conventions
There are precedents at both ends of the spectrum, with Bolivia facing partial withdrawal and Sri Lanka previously losing its preferences altogether.
asserted
Lanka → be → preferences
Mr Karoblis, however, said no determination had so far been made in Pakistan’s case.
asserted
determination → say → case
“So far, it requires further investigation as to whether the regression in these specific areas has already reached the threshold concerning the implementation of the regulation, and whether it has reached the level that could trigger a partial or full temporary suspension,” he said.
uncertain
he → require → suspension
The envoy nevertheless made clear that the absence of such a determination should not be construed as a free pass.
asserted
absence → make → pass
“If the government is ready for cooperation and to make progress, let’s expect that the current conditions, situation and findings will not trigger this mechanism
asserted
conditions → make → mechanism
,” he emphasised.
asserted
he → emphasise → ?
The road ahead will become more demanding after the new framework takes effect.
asserted
framework → become → effect
While the present GSP+ regime is linked to 27 international conventions, the successor arrangement will cover 32.
asserted
arrangement → link → 32
Karoblis said Pakistan had already ratified the five additional conventions required under the new scheme and therefore would technically face no legal difficulty on that count.
asserted
Pakistan → say → count
…and 18 more, not listed.
The Aporia
