- Published
One of the UK's biggest oil refineries spilled pollution into local rivers and the Mersey Estuary on dozens of occasions in 2023 and 2024, documents shared exclusively with the BBC suggest.
asserted
documents → publish → BBC
EET Fuels, formerly known as Essar, which runs Stanlow refinery, pleaded guilty this year to 12 charges of breaching environmental law between 2018 and 2020.
But documents obtained by investigative journalists from SourceMaterial describe other breaches from the refinery in Ellesmere Port, Cheshire, with toxic chemicals and oil regularly spilled into the waterways and even groundwater.
asserted
chemicals → know → waterways
EET Fuels said it "takes its environmental responsibilities extremely seriously".
asserted
it → say → responsibilities
The Environment Agency (EA) has confirmed that it is investigating the breaches.
asserted
it → confirm → breaches
The Stanlow oil refinery is one of only four remaining refineries in the UK and processes 10 million tonnes of crude oil each year - producing around 18% of the country's fuel for road transport like cars and trucks.
asserted
refinery → remain → cars
EET Fuels, which bought the refinery from Shell in 2011 for £842m, holds a permit to operate the site.
asserted
which → buy → site
This says it can discharge controlled amounts of oil and chemicals into the air and waterways.
asserted
it → say → air
However, it must make efforts to limit pollution to the environment and harm to humans.
asserted
it → make → humans
But reports from the EA into activities at the refinery, uncovered by environmental journalists SourceMaterial, show that in 2023 and 2024 the permitted levels for chemical releases were exceeded hundreds of times.
asserted
levels → uncover → times
The regulator has determined this meant EET Fuels broke its permit conditions 58 times over the two-year period - which could amount to an illegal offence.
uncertain
which → determine → offence
The documents show the spills included toxic chemicals such as cyanide, benzene, and heavy oils - into the air and local waterways like Thornton Brook and the River Gowy which connect onto the River Mersey Estuary.
asserted
which → show → Estuary
The Estuary is a Site of Special Scientific Interest (SSSI) and home to endangered species including dolphins and a breeding ground for rare birds.
asserted
Estuary → include → birds
"Species like dunlin, blacktail, godwit and red shank will travel all around the world to feed and roost in the land around the River Mersey," explained Charlotte Harris, chief executive of Cheshire Wildlife Trust.
asserted
Harris → travel → Trust
Harris said this has only been possible because organisations, including the Wildlife Trusts, have undertaken years of pollution clean up from legacy industry in the area.
asserted
organisations → say → area
"We've seen the Atlantic salmon return to the river and also the critically endangered European eel makes its way up the Mersey and into the River Gowy to breed each year as well," she said.
asserted
she → see → Gowy
EA documents detail how pollutants like sulphur dioxide were released into the air at seven times permitted levels, cyanide into waterways like the Gowy at more than eight times permitted levels, and oil at more than thirteen times the allowed levels.
asserted
pollutants → detail → levels
In one incident in July 2023, the company breached its permit after rainwater containing oil leaked from the site - the EA classed the event as "significant".
asserted
EA → breach → event
In its report it said there were a "significant number" of complaints from locals about the smell and further investigations indicated the oil had contaminated groundwater supplies.
asserted
oil → say → supplies
EET Fuels told the BBC that the oil lost was on a "low scale" and "was strictly localised to two boreholes, all well within the Stanlow site itself".
asserted
oil → tell → site
A year later on 12 September 2024, another EA report says that oil was spilled again from the site.
asserted
oil → say → site
Over a 36-hour period more than a tonne of oil was released into Thornton Brook and spread to the Mersey Estuary.
asserted
tonne → release → Estuary
EET Fuels reported the incident to the authorities, but it took nearly two weeks for the company to provide an estimate of how much oil was spilled - another breach of the regulations which requires this within 24 hours.
asserted
which → report → hours
An emergency response team was organised including regulators the EA and Natural England, local port authorities and the Fisheries Authority - according to meeting documents.
uncertain
team → organise → documents
Natural England (NE), which regulates SSSIs, said in one meeting: "What has gone in there is going to have some impact on the vegetation and salt marsh and there is probably still a risk of ingestion by birds."
asserted
gone → regulate → birds
A drone was sent up to survey the scale of the damage which revealed oil had spread for more than a mile down the river and "there was brown discolouration around the reedbed".
asserted
oil → send → reedbed
The footage showed wading birds - including the red-listed Dunlin - in the area.
asserted
footage → show → area
"Where we have chemical pollution the impact isn't just localised.
asserted
impact → have → pollution
When it enters the river system, that system is highly dynamic and high energy, which means that pollution spreads far and wide really, really quickly," said Harris.
asserted
Harris → enter → system
A floating barrier was deployed to try and contain the spill.
asserted
barrier → float → spill
The regulators decided that because the site was not easily reachable, the public health risk was low, but a decision was made to close local cockle beds in the Estuary while the water quality was tested by the Food Standards Agency (FSA).
The beds were given the all clear, but were closed for five weeks whilst testing took place.
asserted
testing → decide → place
Mark Taylor, CEO of the Inshore Fisheries and Conservation Authority North West, told the BBC: "The incident led to a delay in the fishers being able to derive an income from the bed".
asserted
fishers → tell → bed
He added that they were able to make up this income later in the season.
asserted
they → add → season
The incident was later categorised by the EA as a "minor" breach of the company's permit.
asserted
incident → categorise → permit
EET Fuels told the BBC in a statement: "Selectively chosen, historical permit exceedances from prior years in no way represent the current operational status, improving environmental performance, or governance of the refinery today."
asserted
exceedances → tell → refinery
The Environment Agency has launched a separate criminal investigation into what happened in September 2024 and told the BBC it remained "ongoing".
asserted
it → launch → BBC
It said it was yet to confirm what action to take in relation to the 2023 offences.
asserted
it → say → offences
Regulator drops investigation
asserted
Regulator → drop → investigation
, Natural England began its own investigation after the 2024 incident.
asserted
England → begin → incident
It eventually dropped this, and told the BBC: "Our assessment found that, while it was regrettable that the incident occurred, the environmental impact on the SSSI was minor."
But in internal emails Natural England told the EA its reason for dropping the investigation was it thought the company's permit to operate did not set any limits for how much oil could be released - despite the pollution risks.
uncertain
oil → drop → risks
Its officers wrote: "Thank you for sending the permit…. which verify Stanlow's stance that the storm overflow is permitted and further with no limit set to the quantity of oil released.
asserted
limit → write → oil
…and 12 more, not listed.
The Aporia
