The Guardian
· collected 2026-10-05 · by Peter Walker Senior political correspondent
Vivien Lichtenstein, head of the Jewish Greens, has indicated she may leave the party following its recent annual conference in Brighton where a controversial motion was passed. The motion equates Zionism with racism and calls for Israel to be replaced by a single Palestinian state. It received 1,022 votes for and 813 against. Lichtenstein criticized the policy as unhelpful but remains undecided on whether she will stay or leave the party.
Written locally by qwen2.5:14b on 2026-10-05,
using this article's own text rather than the other coverage of the
same event (that is the story summary below).
Why this leaning score
The model judged this article politically coded and scored it -0.45, but all 3 of its quote(s) are attributed speech - words the article quotes from someone, not the article's own narration, so the score is not published.
Written under an earlier scoring contract, which gave a paragraph
rather than checkable quotes. Re-analysing this article replaces it.
Leaning score withheld for article 56910: attributed speech only · logged 2026-10-05
The head of the Jewish Greens has said she may leave the party after it voted to adopt a policy that equates Zionism with racism and calls for Israel to be replaced by a single Palestinian state.
uncertain
Israel → say → state
Vivien Lichtenstein said that while opinion among Jewish members of the party was split on the motion passed at its annual conference in Brighton on Sunday, she said she believed it was unhelpful and it was “possible” she might quit.
uncertain
she → say → Sunday
It comes as anger grows among some in the party about the decision of Zack Polanski, the leader of the Greens in England and Wales, to miss the vote and to encourage supporters to do the same so they could instead campaign for him in Holborn and St Pancras before the parliamentary byelection for the seat next week.
uncertain
they → come → seat
Polanski sought to have the conference postponed so the party could focus on his efforts to win Keir Starmer’s former seat.
uncertain
party → seek → seat
When the Greens’ executive committee refused this, the party contacted members, encouraging them to get refunds on their conference tickets to campaign.
asserted
party → refuse → tickets
Sunday’s binding policy motion was passed by 1,022 votes to 813, and some Greens say more effort by Polanski could have stopped it.
uncertain
effort → bind → it
One long-standing member said: “There’s so much anger at his disinterest in such a critical issue.
asserted
member → stand → issue
You can’t run a party on vibes alone.”
asserted
You → run → vibes
The motion was opposed by four of the Greens’ five MPs, and is expected to face a legal challenge under equality laws.
asserted
motion → oppose → laws
Polanski did not take a side but justified the motion’s broad argument by pointing to the death toll in Gaza.
asserted
Polanski → take → Gaza
Speaking on BBC Radio 4’s Today programme, Lichtenstein condemned the motion: “I don’t think it’s helpful, and it doesn’t make any difference whatsoever to Palestinians.”
asserted
it → speak → Palestinians
Asked if she would remain in the party, she said: “I haven’t decided yet.
asserted
I → ask → party
Certainly it’s quite possible that I will leave the party, and I’m giving it a little time, and to talk with colleagues.”
asserted
I → ’ → colleagues
The motion says Zionism – the movement for a Jewish state – should be “treated as any other form of racism”.
asserted
Zionism → say → racism
It calls for Israel to be replaced by a single Palestinian state “with equal rights for all”.
asserted
Israel → call → all
Some Jewish Greens have expressed concern that this will mean they could face disciplinary action for belonging to Jewish organisations that officially support Zionism, even synagogues.
uncertain
that → express → Zionism
Supporters of the motion, which was led by a group called Greens for Palestine, have said this would not happen.
asserted
this → lead → Palestine
Asked about this issue, Lichtenstein said she was less worried about being personally targeted than about the potential impact on organisations.
asserted
she → ask → organisations
She said: “I’m not concerned about people accusing me of supporting Israel’s right to exist, and therefore, I’m a racist, which of course is not the case.
asserted
which → say → course
I’m just concerned that this is a very bad motion …
asserted
this → i’m → ?
“What concerns me is that the party might accuse UK organisations, Jewish organisations, and also Israeli-Jewish and joint Arab-Jewish organisations, of being Zionist and therefore racist.
uncertain
party → concern → organisations
“I support an awful lot of those sorts of organisations that are working against the occupation, and even go out on the ground to assist Palestinians.”
asserted
that → support → Palestinians
The idea of calling for a single Palestinian state was not an issue for all Jewish Greens, Lichtenstein said, but that party policy had been that it should be “up to Israelis and Palestinians to choose their future, one state or two”.
asserted
it → call → future
Israel’s foreign ministry condemned the motion, saying it “constitutes a clear antisemitic text”, with Polanski being barred from entering the country.
asserted
Polanski → condemn → country
It is understood some Green members are consulting lawyers over whether the policy could be challenged for breaching equalities legislation.
uncertain
policy → understand → legislation
Adam Wagner KC, the barrister who led a case that concluded Jeremy Corbyn’s Labour party broke equalities laws over antisemitism, said such a case would have a good chance of success.
asserted
case → lead → success
“I think there is a strong risk that the motion as passed contravenes the Equality Act 2010, which applies to political parties, as it will discriminate against and harass people who hold Zionist beliefs and Jewish people more generally,” he said.
asserted
he → think → beliefs
The Aporia
