Story summary
In October 2024, a former Cornell University student sued seven Chi Phi fraternity members, alleging sexual assault at an on-campus house. New York Attorney General Letitia James was appointed by Governor Kathy Hochul to independently investigate the case. However, one of the defendants' attorneys, Andrew Miltenberg, argues that James should recuse herself due to prior statements showing bias against the accused. James previously expressed support for the accuser on social media, which Miltenberg claims undermines her impartiality.
Gillio Lopes, represented by attorney Matthew Newman, filed an Article 78 petition in Albany County Supreme Court seeking to block James's appointment as special prosecutor. The petition argues that James demonstrated a presumption of guilt against the defendants and lacks objectivity. Critics like Rensselaer County Executive Steven McLaughlin also contend that James is politically biased and unethical, citing her past high-profile prosecutions where defendants were later acquitted.
James declined to comment on the Article 78 filing but maintains she will conduct an impartial investigation based on facts and law.
Written for “Cornell 7 Investigation” on 2026-10-08,
grounded in this article and the 5 other(s) covering the same event.
One of the seven men named in the lawsuit filed by a former Cornell University student who alleges that she was sexually assaulted at an on-campus fraternity house has filed a petition to block New York Attorney General Letitia James’ appointment as special prosecutor in the case.
asserted
she → name → case
The attorney for Gillio Lopes, who has denied that he sexually assaulted the woman, filed a petition in Albany County Supreme Court on Wednesday.
asserted
he → deny → Wednesday
His filing says James should not be the prosecutor in the case because she has “unequivocally demonstrated a bias and presumption of guilt against the defendants named in the Civil Case.”
asserted
she → say → Case
The Article 78 petition, filed against James and Gov. Kathy Hochul, is a proceeding used to challenge an action by a state or local government officer or agencies in New York.
asserted
petition → file → York
Hochul appointed James last week to independently investigate Jane Doe’s allegations in the lawsuit, in which she says she was plied with alcohol, sexually assaulted and gang-raped at the Chi Phi fraternity house in October 2024.
asserted
she → appoint → October
In her role, James will determine whether criminal charges are warranted.
asserted
charges → determine → role
James’ office declined to comment on the Article 78 filing.
asserted
office → decline → filing
In a statement Monday, James said: “My office enforces our state’s laws to protect all New Yorkers.
asserted
office → say → Yorkers
I am committed to leading a comprehensive investigation they can trust, guided only by the facts, the evidence, and the law.”
asserted
they → commit → facts
Hochul’s office reiterated support for James on Wednesday.
asserted
office → reiterate → Wednesday
Reached for comment on Lopes’ filing, the governor’s office referred to her comments last week.
asserted
office → reach → comments
“I have every confidence in our Attorney General to do what she has always done: look at the facts, examine the record and draw the proper conclusions.
asserted
she → have → conclusions
That’s exactly what’s going to happen in this case,” Hochul said at the time.
asserted
Hochul → ’ → time
Hochul appointed James after she expressed dismay over Tompkins County District Attorney Matthew Van Houten’s investigation of Doe’s allegations.
asserted
she → appoint → allegations
He has said his office found a lack of criminality at the time and declined to press charges, but he reopened the case after the lawsuit sparked national uproar.
asserted
lawsuit → say → uproar
Jane Doe’s civil suit was filed last month against Cornell, Chi Phi and seven fraternity brothers.
asserted
suit → file → Cornell
None of the men named have been criminally charged.
asserted
None → name → men
The fraternity was suspended from campus, and it remains barred.
asserted
it → suspend → campus
Cornell said in a statement Sept. 28 that it conducted a thorough, monthslong Title IX investigation in 2024 that handed down “a range of sanctions, which included expulsions and suspensions” from the university.
asserted
which → say → university
Two of the fraternity members were expelled, and two others were suspended.
asserted
others → expel → members
A third, who had already graduated, was barred from campus, and the final two were issued no-contact orders and required to write “reflection papers,” according to a source who has seen the written decision of the Title IX investigation.
uncertain
who → graduate → investigation
Lopes’ filing argues that James’ appointment is “improper” and cites a post her office shared on X on Sept. 28, three days before her appointment was announced.
asserted
appointment → argue → Sept.
In the post, she said: “What this young woman has been forced to endure is horrific and unacceptable.
asserted
forced → say → What
I’m holding her in my heart and in my prayers.
asserted
I → hold → prayers
To her, and to all survivors: you’re not alone.
asserted
you → ’re → survivors
We stand with you.”
asserted
We → stand → you
The post, the petition contends, “made clear that she has formed an opinion about the case” and that “she has already reached the conclusion that Petitioner and the other named Defendants are guilty.”
asserted
Petitioner → contend → conclusion
The petition also seeks to have the court review James’ appointment and asks that her appointment be annulled or modified so she is not personally directing the probe or any resulting prosecution.
asserted
she → seek → probe
Stuart Bernstein, an attorney for Lopes, said Wednesday: “As Governor Hochul has said, the public needs confidence in the individual leading this investigation.
asserted
public → say → investigation
AG James, based upon her very public statements validating Jane Doe, certainly doesn’t instill confidence in a fair investigation.
asserted
James → base → investigation
In her lawsuit, Doe accuses Lopes of kissing her and sexually assaulting her without her consent.
asserted
Doe → accuse → consent
Attorneys for two of the seven men, including Lopes, have denied to NBC News that they sexually assaulted Doe.
asserted
they → include → Doe
An attorney for a third man denied the allegations to ABC News.
asserted
attorney → deny → News
NBC News has not received responses to requests for comment from the other men.
asserted
News → receive → men
On Tuesday, Andrew Miltenberg, an attorney for Lopes, said he welcomes Cornell’s decision to have an independent review of its handling of Doe’s allegations, which will be led by former acting U.S. Attorney General Sally Yates.
asserted
which → say → Yates
That said, we have also seen due process problems that have affected respondents, and on at least two occasions we have gone to federal court to try to address those issues.
asserted
we → say → issues
In this case, we do not agree with the outcome as to Mr. Lopes,” Miltenberg said.
asserted
Miltenberg → agree → Lopes
The Aporia
