A young man has become the target of a vicious harassment campaign after he was falsely accused of being one of seven Cornell fraternity brothers who allegedly drugged and raped a female student.
uncertain
who → become → student
The confusion came after a lawsuit named former Cornell student Matthew Ingalls as one of the seven accused by a woman identified as Jane Doe.
asserted
lawsuit → come → Doe
In the suit, Doe claimed that she was plied with alcohol, pressured to take ketamine and repeatedly sexually assaulted for hours at the Chi Phi fraternity house in October 2024.
asserted
she → claim → October
The 101-page civil complaint alleged she was 'gang raped' after one of her alleged attackers sent a Snapchat message telling fellow fraternity members there was 'free p***y' upstairs.
asserted
one → allege → members
The publicly available lawsuit listed the names and addresses of the accused, including Ingalls.
asserted
lawsuit → list → Ingalls
As it turned out, however, the court had mistakenly listed the address of a different young man with the same name who had never even been a student at Cornell.
asserted
who → turn → Cornell
Victoria Ingalls, the mother of the falsely accused 23-year-old man, was served the lawsuit in person at her home on the evening of September 26 while her son was away from home, as he is a Marine Corps sergeant on active duty.
asserted
he → accuse → duty
In the days since, the mom and her family have been doxxed and received many terrifying death threats by an online mob of vigilantes, she told The Free Press.
asserted
she → doxxe → Press
A young man was falsely accused of being one of seven Cornell fraternity brothers who allegedly drugged and raped a female student at the Chi Phi fraternity house (pictured) in 2024
One of the men allegedly posted to the fraternity's active-members Snapchat group saying that there was 'free p***y' upstairs, according to a recent lawsuit
One user on X created a post that said: 'This is definitely NOT Matthew Ingalls’ new phone number and address! ...
uncertain
This → accuse → post
Posting this for public awareness so people know to NOT reach out.'
asserted
people → post → awareness
The doxxing went beyond Matthew himself and targeted his family members as well.
asserted
doxxing → go → members
The young man's 26-year-old sister received text messages with a screenshot of her brother and a Google Earth image of his house.
asserted
sister → receive → house
Victoria said the family understood the text was a threat, and that they have also received more extreme and direct threats.
asserted
they → say → threats
Some of those messages said, 'Do the world a favor and go kill yourself,' 'Get f***ed in the a** to death b****' and 'Kill yourself,' Victoria told The Free Press.
asserted
Victoria → say → Press
'My family’s been terrorized, threatened and harassed,' she said.
asserted
she → terrorize → ?
'I can’t believe that people will just look someone up on the internet, take a phone number, and start texting someone or calling someone and saying the vile things they’re saying,' Victoria added.
asserted
Victoria → believe → things
'You don’t even know if you have the right person.
asserted
you → know → person
You’re creating more victims.'
asserted
You → create → victims
Major Michaela Connally, the public information officer at the military base where Matthew is stationed, confirmed to The Free Press that he is not the same Matthew Ingalls accused in the lawsuit.
asserted
he → station → lawsuit
The Chi Phi fraternity brothers have not been criminally charged, but that may change in the near future as prosecutors said they have reopened their investigation
'
uncertain
they → charge → investigation
Unfortunately, this mistaken identification has come at significant personal cost to Sergeant Ingalls and his family, including several threats of physical harm and the doxxing of his personal information,' the major said.
asserted
major → come → information
Ethan Cohen, an associate at the law firm that filed the lawsuit on behalf of Jane Doe, told The Free Press that they are working with the court to fix the error and that 'service upon the correct Matthew Ingalls is being arranged.'
Although the recent lawsuit alleges vile crimes, none of the seven individuals named in the civil complaint have been criminally charged.
asserted
none → file → complaint
That may change in the near future, however, as Tompkins County District Attorney Matthew Van Houten announced on Monday that his office has reopened a criminal probe into the accused, nearly two years after prosecutors initially declined to bring charges.
uncertain
prosecutors → change → charges
Van Houten said investigators will now assess whether new evidence that wasn't available to prosecutors in 2024 changes their view of the case, including the Snapchat exchange that has become central to Doe's lawsuit.
asserted
that → say → lawsuit
The DA has also said his decision not to bring charges against the seven alleged perpetrators was based on the contents of a 2024 statement signed by Doe.
asserted
decision → say → Doe
'She never says that she was drugged without her knowledge,' he previously told ABC News.
asserted
he → say → News
'She admits to taking drugs and alcohol voluntarily and with knowledge.'
asserted
She → admit → knowledge
'She does not allege that she was forced to engage in any acts.
asserted
she → allege → acts
She does not say that she was physically helpless or unconscious or incapacitated at any point during the time at the fraternity house.'
Tompkins County District Attorney Matthew Van Houten previously said his decision not to bring charges against the seven alleged perpetrators was based on the contents of Jane Doe's signed 2024 statement
Doe gave an interview to campus police in which she said she was '100 percent' confident she was raped, but the DA said he never received that evidence.
asserted
he → say → evidence
Students are pictured walking past Cornell Police headquarters
asserted
Students → picture → headquarters
But Van Houten said that the Snapchat messages, as well as an interview Doe had with campus police weeks after the alleged crime in which she said she was '100 percent' confident she was raped, would have prompted further investigation by his office if they had the evidence at the time.
asserted
they → say → time
'That wasn't information that I had, first of all.
asserted
I → have → all
Second of all, that is a legal conclusion,' the DA said of the campus police interview while speaking to CBS News.
asserted
DA → say → News
'If she had said those words, we certainly would want to have explored that more,' he added.
asserted
he → say → that
'Like I said, that wasn't provided to me.'
asserted
that → say → me
Victoria told The Free Press that she understands 'the public’s outrage' and 'feels for the victim in this case and everything she’s been through.
asserted
she → tell → everything
But she also said that online vigilantes need to 'do better' and 'can’t just lash out at random at somebody because they have the same name.'
The mother added that she is 'overwhelmed' and 'scared' for her children.
asserted
she → say → children
'We just really want to be left alone,' Victoria said.
asserted
Victoria → want → ?