Photo via Times of India

How Israeli passenger controlled plummeting flydubai jet after captain was stabbed

Read the original at Times of India ↗
Cite

Manral, K. (2026, October 1). How Israeli passenger controlled plummeting flydubai jet after captain was stabbed. Times of India. https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/world/middle-east/i-watch-air-crash-investigation-how-israeli-passenger-controlled-plummeting-flydubai-passenger-jet-after-co-pilot-stabbed-and-wounded-pilot/articleshow/134607099.cms

Dated when The Aporia collected the article, usually within hours of publication. Check the original for its exact date and byline.

Times of India · collected 2026-10-01 · by Karan Manral

Quick Summary

An Israeli passenger named Yaniv Hayun took control of a flydubai jet after its captain was stabbed by the co-pilot during an apparent hijacking attempt. In a video conversation with Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, Hayun described how he stabilized the plane and restrained the attacker until professional pilots could take over. The aircraft, en route to Israel from Pakistan, made an emergency landing in Tabuk Airport, Saudi Arabia after plummeting 17,400 feet in less than two minutes following the incident. Captain Smit Machchhar, an Indian national, is currently receiving medical treatment and is reported to be stable.
Written by AI on 2026-10-01, from this article's own text only (the story summary below draws on all the coverage).
See how they differ ↓

AI analysis

Story summary

On September 30, 2026, a Flydubai flight from Dubai to Tel Aviv signaled an emergency and was diverted to land at Tabuk airport in Saudi Arabia. The incident initially raised concerns about a possible hijacking, prompting Israel to scramble warplanes. However, Israeli officials later reported that the emergency signals were due to a physical altercation between the plane's two pilots rather than a hijacking attempt.

The flight, identified as Flydubai Flight FZ1073, transmitted multiple emergency alerts after takeoff and over Jordanian airspace before landing safely in Saudi Arabia. Passengers on board managed to overpower the attacker, who was later identified by UAE officials as Omani co-pilot Hamam al-Hammami. Al-Hammami allegedly attempted to crash the plane into Tel Aviv's airport but was stopped by passengers.

UAE Attorney-General Hamad Saif al-Shamsi stated that signs of al-Hammami’s radicalization first emerged in 2017 while he was studying engineering at RMIT University in Melbourne, Australia. He reportedly became influenced by extremist literature and online content glorifying terrorist organizations during this period.

Written for “Flydubai Hijacker's Radicalization Path” on 2026-11-18, grounded in this article and the 345 other(s) covering the same event.

How they differ

30 outlets covered “Flydubai Hijacker's Radicalization Path”.

What each outlet says

One AI summary per outlet of its latest article on this story, written from that article alone and checked against it. Open the article for the outlet's own words.

Times of IndiaThis outlet1 Oct

An Israeli passenger named Yaniv Hayun took control of a flydubai jet after its captain was stabbed by the co-pilot during an apparent hijacking attempt. In a video conversation with Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, Hayun described how he stabilized the plane and restrained the attacker until professional pilots could take over. The aircraft, en route to Israel from Pakistan, made an emergency landing in Tabuk…

How Israeli passenger controlled plummeting flydubai jet after captain was stabbed (this article)19 articles from Times of India on this story
CBS News6 Oct

On a recent flight, passengers aboard FlyDubai Flight 1073 witnessed and participated in averting a potential disaster when the co-pilot attacked the captain mid-flight. The plane experienced an emergency descent of 14,000 feet as passengers collaborated to restrain the attacker until another pilot could take control. ABC News correspondent Matt Gutman interviewed some of these passengers about their roles in…

Extended cut: Heroic FlyDubai passengers recall tense moments after pilot was stabbed →35 articles from CBS News on this story
New York Post10 Oct

Yasmin Ochayon, whose son Eviatar was killed in the October 7 Hamas attack on Israeli soldiers, narrowly avoided another tragedy when her daughter Miryam survived an attempted hijacking aboard a flydubai flight from Dubai to Tel Aviv. On September 30, during the chaotic incident where co-pilot Hamam al-Hammami stabbed the captain and tried to crash the plane, Miryam held hands with passengers near her seat while…

Israeli mom whose son was murdered on Oct. 7 nearly lost daughter in hijacked flydubai terrorist attack →25 articles from New York Post on this story
Al Jazeera4 Oct

Australian authorities are investigating connections between the co-pilot of the Flydubai flight, suspected to be Omani national Hamam al-Hammami, and Australia. Al-Hammami was reportedly barred from flying in Oman due to extremist views and had studied at RMIT University in Melbourne around a decade ago. The investigation is focused on his activities while in Australia, including visits to radical mosques and…

Police investigating Flydubai co-pilot’s Australia ties →23 articles from Al Jazeera on this story
Daily Mail11 Oct

Hamam al-Hammami, a co-pilot from Flydubai accused of attempting to hijack and crash an Israel-bound flight on September 30, reportedly became radicalized while studying in Melbourne around 2017, according to UAE Attorney-General Hamad Saif al Shamsi. Al-Hammami allegedly attended a mosque affiliated with the Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology and was influenced by extremist literature and online content…

Extraordinary claim that Flydubai co-pilot accused of trying to crash jet into Israel was radicalised in Melbourne →22 articles from Daily Mail on this story
The Straits Times7 Oct

A Flydubai co-pilot accused of attempting a murder-suicide on an Israel-bound flight trained as a pilot in Britain at L3 Airline Academy, now part of Acron Aviation. The Telegraph reports that Hamam al-Hammami received training at one or more centers in England and had previously studied engineering at RMIT University in Melbourne from 2015 to 2017 but did not complete his degree. Authorities are investigating his…

Flydubai co-pilot in murder-suicide mission trained to fly in Britain, Telegraph says →22 articles from The Straits Times on this story
Show 24 more outlets
The Independent9 Oct

The UAE attorney general reported that the co-pilot of a flydubai flight to Tel Aviv attempted to hijack and crash the aircraft into Ben Gurion Airport in Israel as a suicide attack. The 29-year-old Omani suspect had allegedly planned the act since September, familiarizing himself with the route on previous flights and even undergoing physical training for the assault. Investigators found that signs of his extremist…

FlyDubai co-pilot planned to crash flight into Ben Gurion Airport, UAE says →21 articles from The Independent on this story
Sydney Morning Herald6 Oct

A near-tragic incident involving a flydubai flight from Dubai to Tel Aviv on September 30 raised concerns about rogue pilots, with co-pilot Hamam al-Hammami allegedly attempting to crash the aircraft. The aviation industry is grappling with how to detect and prevent such incidents, which are rare but highly dangerous; for instance, the Germanwings Flight 9525 incident in 2015 resulted in 150 fatalities due to pilot…

Rogue pilots may be the most dangerous threat to passengers. They’re ‘just about impossible’ to stop →17 articles from Sydney Morning Herald on this story
The Hindu4 Oct

On October 4, 2026, media reports indicated that Hamam al-Hammami, an Omani national and co-pilot of flydubai flight FZ1073 from Dubai to Israel, attempted to hijack the plane on Wednesday, likely acting alone. The flight narrowly avoided disaster when Captain Smit Machchhar regained control after being attacked by the co-pilot. International investigations are ongoing, with Israeli officials stating there is no…

Co-pilot accused of trying to hijack flydubai plane likely acted alone: Reports →16 articles from The Hindu on this story
BBC10 Oct

UAE officials claim that Hamam al-Hammami, the Omani co-pilot accused of attempting to hijack a Flydubai plane on September 30, began drifting towards extremism while studying in Australia from 2015 to 2017. Al-Hammami is said to have been inspired by extremist literature and online content promoting terrorism during this period. He allegedly attempted to crash the Dubai-Tel Aviv flight into Tel Aviv airport but was…

Flydubai attacker began a 'drift towards extremism and terrorism' in Australia, UAE says →15 articles from BBC on this story
Washington Examiner7 Oct

This article discusses an incident where a co-pilot on Flydubai Flight 1073 attacked Captain Smit Machchhar with an onboard axe during a flight from Dubai to Tel Aviv, leading passengers and crew to intervene and save the plane. The event sparked online memes celebrating Israelis for their bravery in this crisis, contrasting sharply with previous negative stereotypes about Israel in media and public discourse. The…

The hijacker tried to kill them. The memes accidentally humanized them →12 articles from Washington Examiner on this story
ABC News (AU)10 Oct

Emirati authorities claim that the co-pilot who allegedly attempted to hijack a flydubai flight to Tel Aviv showed signs of extremist leanings while studying in Australia nearly 10 years ago. The man attacked his co-pilot with an axe during the flight but was stopped by passengers and crew. UAE officials say he planned to crash the plane into Tel Aviv's Ben Gurion Airport as a suicide attack, inspired by Al Qaeda’s…

Investigators say flydubai pilot's 'drift towards terrorism' started in Australia →10 articles from ABC News (AU) on this story
The Guardian7 Oct

New Zealand police have begun investigating the flight training received by flydubai co-pilot Hamam al-Hammami, who allegedly attempted to hijack an Israeli-bound plane in September. Hammami was trained in New Zealand for about five months in 2018-2019 and previously studied engineering in Australia until 2017 without completing his degree. Authorities are examining his activities and associations in both countries…

Flydubai attack investigation widens as alleged hijacker’s training in New Zealand scrutinised →10 articles from The Guardian on this story
Fox News7 Oct

Dr. Marc Siegel discusses the Hamas attacks on October 7, 2023, and their aftermath, emphasizing miraculous recoveries and narrow escapes as divine interventions. He recounts an incident from September 30, 2026, involving Flydubai Flight FZ1073, where passengers intervened to save the plane after a radical extremist co-pilot attacked the pilot. Siegel also details in his book "The Angels Among Us" how an Israeli…

DR MARC SIEGEL: I went looking for miracles after Oct. 7. I found angels hiding in plain sight →10 articles from Fox News on this story
Toronto Star5 Oct

Israeli and UAE authorities are investigating a cockpit attack on a FlyDubai flight last week where an Omani co-pilot attempted to hijack the plane en route to Israel. The suspect, Hamam al-Hammami, was detained after passengers subdued him; he had previously been barred from flying by Oman due to extremist views. Key questions focus on how al-Hammami was allowed to fly despite his history and the lack of Israeli…

FACT FOCUS: What's known about the FlyDubai attack probe and the red flags about the suspect →10 articles from Toronto Star on this story
Euronews9 Oct

An Omani co-pilot who had extremist views planned to crash a flydubai aircraft into Tel Aviv's international airport, inspired by the 9/11 attacks. On September 30, he attacked the plane’s captain with an axe during a flight carrying mostly Israeli passengers; however, the attack was thwarted when passengers stormed the cockpit and subdued him. The injured pilot managed to land the plane safely in Saudi Arabia after…

Flydubai co-pilot planned suicide attack in Tel Aviv airport inspired by 9/11 →9 articles from Euronews on this story
NBC News4 Oct

Early indications suggest that the Flydubai co-pilot accused of attacking his captain and attempting to seize control of an Israel-bound flight acted alone, according to U.S. officials briefed on the investigation and a former Israeli security official. The attack occurred on Wednesday when the co-pilot used a crash ax to assault the captain and attempted to take over the plane's controls; however, crew members and…

Early indications suggest Flydubai co-pilot acted alone in attack, officials say →9 articles from NBC News on this story
Dawn4 Oct

An Australian counterterrorism unit is investigating connections between Australia and Hamam Al-Hamami, the co-pilot involved in the alleged stabbing of his captain on flydubai flight FZ1073. Two sources claim that Al-Hamami studied at RMIT University in Melbourne around a decade ago. The incident occurred when the plane was en route from Dubai to Israel, leading to a sharp descent before being safely landed in…

Australia probes flydubai co-pilot's links to the country, police say →8 articles from Dawn on this story
ABC News (US)5 Oct

U.S. and Israeli officials claim that Hamam Al-Hammani, the suspected attacker on a recent FlyDubai flight to Tel Aviv, intended to crash the plane into Ben Gurion Airport. Al-Hammani was previously suspended from Oman Air in 2024 due to possession of extremist materials while undergoing training as a copilot there. ABC News reports this based on information from U.S. and Israeli sources familiar with the…

FlyDubai suspected attacker intended to crash into Tel Aviv airport, sources say →7 articles from ABC News (US) on this story
South China Morning Post4 Oct

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu ordered a security review of international flights to Israel following an attack by an Omani co-pilot aboard a Flydubai flight from Dubai to Tel Aviv, where he attempted to bring down the plane after stabbing the captain. The incident has led Netanyahu to instruct Shmuel Ben Ezra, head of the National Security Council, to appoint an examiner to conduct a thorough review of…

Netanyahu orders security review of international flights to Israel after Flydubai attack →6 articles from South China Morning Post on this story
CBC9 Oct

The UAE prosecutor reported that a FlyDubai co-pilot from Oman attempted to crash the plane into Tel Aviv's main airport with the goal of causing mass casualties. The suspect used two previous flights to familiarize himself with the route and airport, drawing inspiration from the 9/11 attacks in the U.S. He acted alone and provided a detailed confession about his motives and planning stages during questioning by…

FlyDubai co-pilot sought to crash plane into Tel Aviv's main airport: UAE →6 articles from CBC on this story
Evening Standard3 Oct

Flydubai co-pilot Hamam al Hammami, an Omani national who studied aviation management at a UK university through distance learning, allegedly stabbed Captain Smit Machchhar with a crash axe during a flight from Dubai to Tel Aviv on Wednesday. The attack caused the plane to descend sharply before passengers subdued Hammami and regained control of the aircraft. Investigations are ongoing to determine the motives…

Who is Hamam Al Hammami? FlyDubai pilot who ‘stabbed captain and tried to hijack plane’ studied at British university →3 articles from Evening Standard on this story
Semafor1 Oct

A recent incident where a civilian aboard a flydubai flight intervened to prevent a would-be stabber has intensified Israel’s upcoming election debates. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu used the event to support his security stance, while opposition leaders compared it to pre-October 7 security failures and criticized the government for failing to prevent such incidents proactively. The debate highlights ongoing…

Pilot stabbing on flydubai flight scrambles Israeli elections →3 articles from Semafor on this story
Time1 Oct

On September 30, Flydubai flight 1073 from Dubai to Tel Aviv experienced an incident where the co-pilot attacked the pilot with what was described as either an axe or knife. The attack caused a sharp descent and chaos on board before other passengers subdued the attacker. The flight safely landed in Tabuk, Saudi Arabia, thanks to two reserve pilots who took over control of the plane. Questions are now being raised…

What the Flydubai Incident Reveals About When a Pilot Becomes the Threat →2 articles from Time on this story
Deutsche Welle3 Oct

UAE investigators report that the co-pilot of Flydubai Flight 1073 attempted a terrorist attack using a crash ax, aiming to stab his captain and potentially crash the plane carrying 182 people from Dubai to Tel Aviv. The flight was diverted safely to Tabuk, Saudi Arabia. According to reports, the suspect is an Omani national barred by Oman from flying due to concerns about radical views, but he was still hired by…

Flydubai co-pilot attempted 'terrorist attack,' UAE says →2 articles from Deutsche Welle on this story
The Globe and Mail4 Oct

Passengers on a FlyDubai flight from Dubai to Tel Aviv experienced an attack when one pilot stabbed another during the flight. Passengers intervened and helped stabilize the plane for an emergency landing in Saudi Arabia. The attacker was arrested by Saudi authorities, though the motive behind the assault remains unclear. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu confirmed that warplanes were scrambled due to…

Morning Update: Pilot attacked fellow pilot in Israel-bound flight →2 articles from The Globe and Mail on this story
NPR5 Oct

An ongoing investigation has found that a co-pilot aboard a FlyDubai flight from Dubai to Tel Aviv attempted to crash the plane into Ben Gurion International Airport using an axe, but was stopped by passengers and crew who subdued him. The plane, carrying 172 people including mostly Israeli nationals, made an emergency landing in Saudi Arabia before being transported safely to Tel Aviv. The attacker is identified as…

FlyDubai attacker intended to crash plane into Tel Aviv airport, ongoing investigation finds →2 articles from NPR on this story
Global News3 Oct

The article reports that Hamam al-Hammami, an Omani national barred from flying for Oman Air due to concerns over extremist views, attacked the captain of a FlyDubai flight to Israel with the cockpit’s crash axe on Wednesday. The attack occurred less than a week before the anniversary of Hamas's October 7th assault and involved 182 passengers; Hammami was subdued by other passengers after attempting to take control…

Axe-wielding FlyDubai co-pilot had been flagged over extremism concerns →2 articles from Global News on this story
National Post8 Oct

Alan Kessel critiques Foreign Minister Anita Anand's statement regarding an attack on a Flydubai flight from Dubai to Tel Aviv, where an Omani co-pilot allegedly stabbed the Indian captain and injured several others before being subdued by passengers. The incident occurred on September 30, involving 174 passengers primarily bound for Israel. Kessel argues that Anand’s statement omitted critical terms like "attack,"…

Alan Kessel: Anand couldn’t bring herself to say ‘Israel’ or ‘terror’ in statement about Flydubai attack →2 articles from National Post on this story
The Free Press30 Sep

Douglas Murray argues in an article for The Free Press that despite ongoing threats, such as a recent attempted hijacking of a Flydubai plane bound for Tel Aviv by its co-pilot, Israel has been successful in its conflicts with Islamic radicals over the past three years. He emphasizes that while there are daily reports suggesting defeat, he maintains that practical victories on the ground outweigh negative public…

Douglas Murray: Israel Is Winning →

Compared with similar articles

This article reads unscored and hedges 12% of its claims. Each row says how that neighbour differs.
BBC News
Hedges 0 of 3 claims Outlet record 65/100
Times of India
Hedges 2 of 24 claims Outlet record 59/100
The Free Press
Leans strongly right Hedges 2 of 15 claims Outlet record 96/100
Al Jazeera
Hedges 1 of 10 claims Outlet record 60/100
The Sydney Morning Herald
Hedges 1 of 61 claims Outlet record 61/100

Story

Flydubai Hijacker's Radicalization Path
Crime & Law · 346 article(s) covering the same event. See how they differ ↑
How this article was measured signals, leaning charts, publisher record, byline, topics and claims

Signals How these are calculated →

Claims extracted
24
sentences that state something as happening or true
Uncertain
12%
3 of 24 hedged ("reportedly", "may", "according to")
Leaning
not political
takes no side on a contested political question
Publisher signals
59/100
Times of India's corrections and hedging, across everything collected from it. Not a measure of accuracy.
Outlets on this story
346
Crime & Law
Same framing elsewhere
1
articles that frame the event the way this one does
Analyzed 2026-10-01 · how these are computed

How this is being covered How these are calculated →

Article leaning vs. publisher reliability
Source leaning vs. consistency

Publisher

Times of India · 5272 article(s) · 6 correction(s) detected
Running correction rate · 6 correction(s)

Who wrote this

Karan Manral
52 article(s) here · 0 carrying a prediction
On Wednesday, Democratic Senator Ron Wyden of Oregon, who is set to take over as chair of a powerful Senate committee, wrote to Children’s Health Defense (CHD), a non-profit organisation known for its anti-vaccine activism that Kennedy chaired before joining the Trump administration.
But they will not be accepted!" Trump wrote on his Truth Social platform.
"Hopefully, Aleema sahiba and Bushra Bibi, will also be released soon," he added, referring to the cricketer-turned-politician's elder sister and wife, respectively.
Commanders would also be held more accountable for addressing misconduct.
"The records contain technical failures acknowledged by Facebook itself, but there are no elements allowing us to conclude, on a preliminary basis, that there was deliberate action to unbalance the election," Justice Marco Aurelio Bellizze wrote in the ruling, referring to submissions made by Meta. "That conclusion would require robust evidence, to be produced through the appropriate legal proceedings," he added.
He directed the prosecution to present its witnesses on December 9 so that the formal trial proceedings could begin,” the official said.
Qureshi has been in jail since August 2023 in multiple cases linked to the May 9, 2023, riots, when Tehreek-i-Insaf supporters went on a rampage following the arrest of party chairman and former Prime Minister Imran Khan.
It remains unclear whether Geller’s death will lead to changes in the charges against Akram.
'We might do better than the polls suggest.
The UK could issue its first apology for its role in the trans-Atlantic slave trade, with Prime Minister Andy Burnham stressing the need for Britain to acknowledge its “complicated history” to safeguard the Commonwealth, a grouping of 56 independent nations that evolved from the British Empire.
Also by Karan Manral
Nothing else under this byline is closely related to this article, so these are simply their most recent.
All 52 articles by Karan Manral →

Topics

Indian Israel Israeli Saudi Arabia flydubai

Subjects

Hayun PERSON · 5× Israeli NORP · 5× Netanyahu PERSON · 5× flydubai ORG · 5× Indian NORP · 3× Israel GPE · 2× Saudi Arabia GPE · 2× Benjamin Netanyahu PERSON · 1× India GPE · 1× Omani NORP · 1×

Narrative

An Israeli passenger, who took control of an Israel-bound flydubai passenger jet after its pilot was stabbed and wounded by the co-pilot during an apparent hijacking attempt told Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu that he knew how to control the aircraft because, “I watch Air Crash Investigation.”
framing: assertive · carried by 1 article(s) · first seen 2026-10-01

Claims (24 extracted, 3 hedged)

An Israeli passenger, who took control of an Israel-bound flydubai passenger jet after its pilot was stabbed and wounded by the co-pilot during an apparent hijacking attempt told Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu that he knew how to control the aircraft because, “I watch Air Crash Investigation.” asserted
I → take → Investigation
In a video posted by the Israeli Prime Minister’s Office, the man told Netanyahu how passengers restrained the co-pilot, reportedly an Omani citizen, after the captain, an Indian national, managed to open the cockpit door despite being seriously wounded. uncertain
captain → post → door
Also Read | ‘India is proud’: PM Modi lauds Flydubai pilot Machchhar after cockpit attackIsraeli media identified the passenger as Yaniv Hayun. asserted
media → read → Hayun
"I jumped back into it (the cockpit) and pulled the controls. asserted
I → jump → controls
I started pulling the...," Hayun said in Hebrew, before Netanyahu interjected: "You pulled the controls? asserted
You → start → controls
You knew?" asserted
You → know → ?
"Yes, because I watch Air Crash Investigations, Mr Prime Minister. asserted
I → watch → Investigations
And then the plane started to level out, a bit more. asserted
plane → start → ?
And then the pilot told me he was taking control from there," he added, as Netanyahu burst into laughter. asserted
Netanyahu → tell → laughter
Israeli media reported that two off-duty flydubai pilots who were on the flight as they were due to operate another flydubai flight then took over. asserted
they → report → flight
The plane later made an emergency landing at Tabuk Airport in northwestern Saudi Arabia. asserted
plane → make → Arabia
Also Read | 'A hero': Trump hails Indian captain after Flydubai attack, calls co-pilot ‘perhaps a terrorist’Meanwhile, earlier in the conversation, Hayun informed Netanyahu how passengers rushed into the cockpit after the wounded captain managed to open the door. asserted
captain → read → door
"...because of the pressure, a force like that pulled me down. asserted
force → pull → me
And standing at the door was someone else in a white shirt, I assume it was the pilot because inside there were two pilots, and outside two pilots happened to be sitting in the cabin," Hayun said. asserted
Hayun → stand → cabin
"He and I pushed the door," the man further stated, apparently referring to another passenger. asserted
man → push → passenger
He added that the stabbed pilot was very close to the entry, making it difficult for passengers to initially break in. asserted
passengers → add → entry
At this point, Netanyahu asked Hayun whether anyone had managed to open the cockpit door. asserted
anyone → ask → door
The man replied in the affirmative, saying the pilot was able to open it before collapsing. asserted
pilot → reply → it
Hayun then described how the plane began to descend - the jet plummeted 17,400 feet in less than two minutes, according to flight-tracking data. uncertain
jet → describe → data
I called out to the Israeli guys with us on the plane and two other guys came over to me. asserted
guys → call → me
We pinned him (co-pilot) down to keep him (pilot) secure," he said. asserted
he → pin → him
The Indian pilot, Captain Smit Machchhar, is undergoing treatment at a hospital in Saudi Arabia and is in stable condition, according to the Indian Embassy in Riyadh, the Saudi capital. uncertain
pilot → undergo → Riyadh
The incident occurred just days before the third anniversary of the October 7, 2023, Hamas attacks on Israel, and amid the ongoing US-Israeli war with Iran, raising security concerns. asserted
incident → occur → concerns
The Israeli Knesset elections are also scheduled for October 27. asserted
elections → schedule → October
Give feedback · no sign-in needed

No sign-in needed for now. Your note is sent without a name, so it cannot be answered.

History Support