Toronto Star
· collected 2026-10-05 · by Melanie Lidman, Aamer Madhani And Samy Magdy The Associated Press
analysis
The investigation into the thwarted FlyDubai cockpit attack last week has turned into a wide security and intelligence probe spanning from the Middle East to New Zealand as authorities try to figure out how the suspect, previously flagged for extremist views in Oman, was cleared to fly an Israel-bound flight.
asserted
suspect → thwart → flight
Investigators in the United Arab Emirates, along with Israeli and Saudi authorities, are treating the midair assault by the ax-wielding Omani co-pilot, Hamam al-Hammami, as a planned terror attack.
asserted
Investigators → treat → attack
The plane’s wounded captain managed to open the cockpit door to allow passengers in.
asserted
captain → manage → passengers
They subdued the attacker and the plane made an emergency landing in Saudi Arabia.
asserted
plane → subdue → Arabia
The suspect was detained and sent to the UAE, where he remains in custody, and the focus of the probe has now shifted toward addressing apparent vetting failures.
asserted
focus → detain → failures
Here are some key aspects of the investigation that are still being sorted out.
asserted
that → sort → investigation
CLAIM: The co-pilot should have been barred from flying to Israel.
uncertain
pilot → bar → Israel
It’s unclear how a citizen of Oman, an Arab country that has no diplomatic relations with Israel, was allowed to fly a planeload of Israelis to Tel Aviv.
uncertain
that → ’ → Aviv
Israeli law requires airlines to provide information about passengers and crew members, including their names and nationalities, to Israel up to 48 hours before a flight.
asserted
law → require → flight
Authorities in the UAE did share with Israel a list of passengers and crew ahead of the flight, according to officials who spoke on the condition of anonymity because they were not authorized to speak to reporters about the probe.
uncertain
they → share → probe
Israel had not raised red flags on any passengers or members of the crew, the officials said.
asserted
officials → raise → crew
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said on Thursday — a day after the attack — that Israel has long-standing agreements with foreign carriers to keep pilots from flying into the country if they are citizens of nations that don’t maintain diplomatic relations with Israel.
asserted
that → say → Israel
Separately, officials have said that al-Hammami, who had spent some time in New Zealand, had been barred from flying by his native Oman because of concerns there that he had adopted extremist views.
asserted
he → say → views
The Shin Bet, Israel’s domestic security agency, said the Transportation Ministry is responsible for vetting passenger lists from foreign flights.
asserted
Ministry → say → flights
However, Israeli Transportation Minister Miri Regev said on X that security agencies are responsible for flight security and that her ministry wasn’t given a list of passengers or any warnings.
asserted
ministry → say → passengers
CLAIM: Netanyahu said al-Hammami “underwent Islamist radical indoctrination.”
uncertain
Hammami → say → indoctrination
Officials have offered scant insight into al-Hammami’s motivations, and authorities in Israel, the UAE and Oman have not provided any details about his adoption of radical views.
asserted
authorities → offer → views
Still, it does appear he had been plotting to carry out an attack for some time.
asserted
he → appear → time
The initial investigation, which is being led by the Emiratis, found that al-Hammami originally planned to carry out the attack in July but did not go through with it at the time, according to a regional official who spoke on condition of anonymity because they were not authorized to speak to the media.
uncertain
they → lead → media
He specifically sought out work with an airline that flew to Israel in order to carry out the attack, according to the investigation.
uncertain
that → seek → investigation
In his first public comments about the incident, Trump hinted there could be a link when asked by reporters at the White House whether he had been briefed about any connection between the co-pilot and Tehran.
uncertain
he → hint → pilot
“I would say the answer, based on what I’m hearing, is yes, but we’re working on it right now,” Trump said.
asserted
Trump → say → it
He did not elaborate about why he suspected Iranian involvement.
asserted
he → elaborate → involvement
Trump also said that if the link to Iranian authorities was determined, they would face “very hard” retaliation.
asserted
they → say → retaliation
But in the days since, regional officials have said they’ve yet to find any Iranian nexus.
asserted
they → say → nexus
And Trump hasn’t offered any evidence backing his initial speculation.
asserted
Trump → offer → speculation
CLAIM: Netanyahu’s rivals say the prime minister’s government dropped the ball.
uncertain
government → say → ball
THE FACTS: In the days ahead, how the investigation plays out could have enormous consequences for Netanyahu as Israel gets ready to hold national elections on Oct. 27.
uncertain
Israel → play → Oct.
Netanyahu has long tried to cultivate an image as uniquely capable of keeping Israel strong and managing its existential threats.
asserted
Netanyahu → try → threats
Israelis celebrated their countrymen on the flight who quickly sprang to action to subdue the co-pilot after he attacked the plane’s captain, Smit Machchhar, and tried to crash the plane.
asserted
he → celebrate → plane
Netanyahu greeted the passengers after they arrived back in Tel Aviv and heralded the quick action of several aboard for preventing a catastrophe.
asserted
they → greet → catastrophe
But Netanyahu now finds himself facing criticism from some political opponents who say security lapses by his government led to the situation.
asserted
lapses → find → situation
Former prime minister and B’Yachad party leader Naftali Bennett and Yashar party leader Gadi Eisenkot, a leading rival to Netanyahu in this month’s election, have demanded Netanyahu fire Regev, the transportation minister, over the incident.
asserted
Netanyahu → lead → incident
Netanyahu has called on the head of the National Security Council to appoint an examiner to review “all security aspects” of Israel’s civil aviation in the aftermath of the incident.
asserted
Netanyahu → call → incident
But opposition leader Yair Lapid has dismissed Netanyahu’s ordered probe as a “sham.”
asserted
Lapid → dismiss → sham
“The chain of failures that preceded the incident could have led to a disaster of historic proportions, and this is how an Israeli prime minister responds?” Lapid wrote on X.
Bennett and Eisenkot sought to connect the FlyDubai attack with the Hamas-led October 2023 attack on southern Israel that triggered the war in Gaza.
Both attacks, they argue, reflect Netanyahu’s failure to keep Israelis safe and an unwillingness to acknowledge responsibility.
uncertain
they → precede → responsibility
___
Lidman reported from Tel Aviv, Israel, and Magdy from Cairo.
asserted
Lidman → report → Cairo
The Aporia
